| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AIW Gauntlet For The Gold 19
Mar 20th 2026 | Chuck Stone, Eric Taylor | def. | Alonzo Cruz, Austin James, Brian Carson, Burt Dangle, Danny Orion, Derek Dillinger, Dominic Garrini, Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Eric Taylor, Isaiah Broner, Jessie Blair, Joseline Navarro, Katie Arquette, Marino Tenaglia, Marion Fontaine, Matthew Justice, Mikey Montgomery, MJ Maverick, Philly Collins, Rudy Ray Woods, Ryan Your Cousin You Only See At Christmas, Shaw Mason, Shelby Wylder, Shimbashi, The Duke, Tyler Jordan, Tyson Riggs, Wes Barkley | "Gauntlet For The Gold" | |
AIW Gauntlet For The Gold 19
Mar 20th 2026 | Derek Dillinger (c) & Tyson Riggs (c) | def. | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
AIW Gauntlet For The Gold 19
Mar 20th 2026 | Mance Warner | draw (NC) | Matthew Justice | | |
MLW Fusion Taping
Mar 14th 2026 | Trevor Lee | def. | Andrew Everett, Beastman, Diego Hill, Festus, Ikuro Kwon, Jesus Rodriguez, Josh Bishop, Matthew Justice, Paul Walter Hauser | "Bunkhouse Stampede" | MLW Southern Crown Championship
(title change) |
GCW So Alive 2026
Mar 7th 2026 | Atticus Cogar & Christian Napier & Otis Cogar | def. | A. J. Gray & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | 6-person tag | |
GCW So Alive 2026
Mar 7th 2026 | A. J. Gray & Matthew Justice | draw (NC) | Atticus Cogar & Otis Cogar | | |
MLW/CMLL Lucha Apocalypto 2026
Feb 7th 2026 | Josh Bishop | def. | Matthew Justice | street fight | |
MLW Battle Riot VIII
Jan 29th 2026 | Killer Kross | def. | Adam Brooks, Alan Angels, Alex Hammerstone, Anthony Greene, Ariel Dominguez, Austin Aries, Babathunder, Ben Bishop, Bishop Dyer, Cha Cha Charlie, Cody Fluffman, Diego Hill, Doc Gallows, Don Gato, Donovan Dijak, Festus, Ikuro Kwon, Jesus Rodriguez, Joe Coffey, Josh Bishop, Karl Anderson, KUSHIDA, L. J. Cleary, Madman Fulton, Mads Krule Krügger (c), Mark Coffey, Matt Riddle, Matthew Justice, Mr. Thomas, Onix the One, Paul London, Paul Walter Hauser, Ricky Martinez, Sidney Akeem, Simon Gotch, Stallion Rogers, Trevor Lee, Unknown Male Wrestler, Wolfgang | Battle Riot Match | MLW World Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
AIW Alive Out Of Habit
Jan 23rd 2026 | Philly Collins | def. | Matthew Justice, Mikey Montgomery | four-way | |
AIW Malice At The Palace
Dec 27th 2025 | Tyler Jordan | def. | Matt Cross, Matthew Justice, Shimbashi | four-way | |
AIW Hell On Earth XX
Nov 28th 2025 | Derek Dillinger (c) & Tyson Riggs (c) | def. | Matthew Justice & Tommy Dreamer | | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
AIW Hell On Earth XX
Nov 28th 2025 | Matthew Justice | draw (NC) | Tommy Dreamer | | |
AIW Death Of Seasons
Oct 18th 2025 | Wes Barkley | def. | Matthew Justice, Mikey Montgomery, Shelby Wylder | four-way | |
MLW Slaughterhouse 2025
Oct 4th 2025 | Mads Krule Krügger (c) | def. | Brock Anderson & C. W. Anderson & Chris Adonis & Matthew Justice & Mr. Thomas | "Chamber of Horrors" | MLW World Heavyweight Title
|
 wXw We Love Wrestling #71
Sep 28th 2025 | Matthew Justice | def. | M4 | | |
wXw Extreme Wrestling Party 2025
Sep 26th 2025 | Iceman | def. | Matthew Justice, The Green Phantom | fans bring the weapons (three-way) | |
wXw We Love Wrestling #70
Sep 19th 2025 | Elijah Blum | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW Absolution XVIII
Jul 18th 2025 | Vincent Nothing | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
MLW Summer of the Beasts 2025
Jun 26th 2025 | Ultimo Guerrero (c) | def. | Alex Hammerstone, Matthew Justice | three-way | MLW National Openweight Title
|
MLW Blood & Thunder 2025 Taping
Jun 26th 2025 | Mads Krule Krügger | def. | Ariel Dominguez, C. W. Anderson, Matthew Justice, Mr. Thomas, Okumura | 6-way scramble | |
AIW Kash Rules Everything Around Me
Jun 21st 2025 | Derek Dillinger & Vincent Nothing | def. | Dominic Garrini & Matthew Justice | | |
Wrestling Revolver Unreal
May 31st 2025 | Krule | def. | Matthew Justice | street fight | |
AIW 20th Anniversary
May 16th 2025 | Matthew Justice | def. | Kaplan | | |
MLW War Chamber 2025 Taping
May 10th 2025 | Alex Kane & Matthew Justice & Mr. Thomas & Paul London | def. | Bobby Fish & Brett Ryan Gosselin & Brock Anderson & C. W. Anderson | War Chamber | |
 CMLL CMLL vs. MLW
May 2nd 2025 | Ultimo Guerrero | def. (pin) | Matthew Justice (c) | | MLW National Openweight Title
(title change) |
Matthew Justice