| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Circle 6 Full Circle
Nov 13th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Lucky 13 | 500 Carpet Strips Deathmatch | |
Sean Henderson Presents Colby Corino's Painted Black
Nov 3rd 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Sawyer Wreck | ultraviolent rules | |
CZW Tournament of Death 19
Oct 29th 2022 | Bobby Beverly | def. (KO) | Otis Cogar | "Barbed Wire Massacre" | |
Sean Henderson Presents ...And Justice For All 2!
Sep 11th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Deklan Grant | deathmatch | |
Circle 6 Soon As I Get Home
Sep 10th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Vinnie Massaro | "hardcore" | |
Circle 6 The Catalyst
Sep 9th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Hoodfoot | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 30 - Ultraviolent Vortex
Aug 20th 2022 | Bobby Beverly | def. | Otis Cogar | deathmatch | |
Circle 6 Gangreen
Jul 22nd 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Jeff Cannonball, Jeff King | four corners of pain (3-way) | |
Sean Henderson Presents I'd Do Anything
Jun 24th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Louie Ramos | deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground/Circle 6 It's Not What You Think
May 21st 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. | Kevin Giza | no disqualification | |
No Peace Underground/Ruthless Pro/Circle 6 Body Count Battle
May 7th 2022 | Kevin Giza | def. | Apollo Starr, Bobby Beverly, Casanova Valentine, Darren McCarty, Gregory Iron, Josh Crane, Madman Pondo, Malcolm Monroe III, Mathias Thrasher, Mickie Knuckles, Neil Diamond Cutter, Otis Cogar, Remington Rhor, Rickey Shane Page, Satu Jinn, ThunderKitty, TJ Meyer | Body Count Battle Elimination Match | |
Circle 6 Terrible Lie
Apr 30th 2022 | Vinnie Massaro | def. (DQ) | Otis Cogar | pre-show
| |
Circle 6 Skewered
Mar 19th 2022 | Tyler Bateman | def. (DQ) | Otis Cogar | | |
IWA-MS It's A Mystery 3
Mar 6th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. (pin) | 1 Called Manders | texas bullrope barbed wire bat deathmatch | |
IWA-MS It's A Mystery 2
Feb 27th 2022 | Otis Cogar | def. (pin) | Remington Rhor | deathmatch | |
VxS/NPU Already Dead
Jan 7th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Chelsea Durden, Gory, Kit Osbourne, Otis Cogar, Tye Hyll | 6-Way Lucha Rules Mosh Pit Scramble Match | |
No Peace Underground The Negatives
Nov 20th 2021 | Lord Crewe & Otis Cogar | def. | Bam Sullivan & Raven Havok | | |
Hybrid Friday Night Fights
Nov 5th 2021 | Otis Cogar | def. | Gangrel | | |
Hybrid Aces Low
Oct 8th 2021 | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner | def. | Atticus Cogar & Otis Cogar | | |
Hybrid Aces Low
Oct 8th 2021 | 1 Called Manders | draw (NC) | Otis Cogar | | |
IWA-MS King Of The Deathmatch '21 - Day 2
Jul 31st 2021 | Orin Veidt | def. | John Wayne Murdoch, Otis Cogar | three-way dry ice deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Asmodeus
Jul 11th 2021 | Odinson & Parrow | def. | AKIRA & Hardway Heeter, Lord Crewe & Otis Cogar | three-way tag | |
GCW Backyard Wrestling 3
Jul 4th 2021 | Dexter White | def. | Otis White | | |
No Peace Underground MurderMania
Apr 8th 2021 | Lord Crewe & Otis Cogar | def. | Nolan Edward & Wolfe Taylor | | |
No Peace Underground Fatalism
Apr 7th 2021 | Lord Crewe & Otis Cogar | def. | Bam Sullivan & G-Raver | No Ring Deathmatch (tag) | |
IWA-MS Double Death Tag Team Tournament 2021
Apr 3rd 2021 | Atticus Cogar & Eric Ryan | def. | Lord Crewe & Otis Cogar | fans bring the weapons (2 on 2) | |
No Peace Underground You Will Never Be One Of Us
Dec 13th 2020 | Otis Cogar | def. | Beastly | no ring deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Body Count Battle 2020
Nov 12th 2020 | Allie Kat | def. | AKIRA, Alex Ocean, Casanova Valentine, Dominic Garrini, Eddy Only, Jimmy Lloyd, John Wayne Murdoch, Lindsay Snow, Matthew Justice, Neil Diamond Cutter, Orin Veidt, Otis Cogar, Reed Bentley, Robert Martyr | Body Count Battle Elimination Deathmatch | |
Otis Cogar