| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AAW Unstoppable 2022
Dec 30th 2022 | Fred Yehi | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X13
Nov 18th 2022 | Joe Black | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 36
Nov 12th 2022 | Aaron Williams | def. | Gary Jay | deathmatch | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 24 - Part 1
Sep 24th 2022 | Kylon King | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Destination Chicago 2022
Sep 1st 2022 | Gnarls Garvin | def. | Ace Perry, Dante Leon, Gary Jay, Gringo Loco, Laredo Kid | 6-way scramble | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 29
Jul 23rd 2022 | Hardway Heeter | def. | Gary Jay | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X11
Jul 22nd 2022 | Gary Jay | def. | Joe Black | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 26 - Summer Stunner
Jun 30th 2022 | Pedro Dones | def. | Bobby Orlando, Brad Hollister, Gary Jay, Ryan Clancy, Tyree Taylor | 6-Way | |
AAW Crush And Destroy
Jun 11th 2022 | Davey Vega | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Freelance Wrestling Over The Top Rope
May 20th 2022 | Storm Grayson | def. | Aaron Payne, Alfonso Gonzalez, Angel Escalera, Blair Onyx, Chicago Brawler, Chico Suave, Chris Castro, Dan Perch, Dan the Dad, Darin Corbin, Ethan Price, Gary Jay, GPA, Guerrera de Brisenas, Isaias Velazquez, Kenny Sutra, Kylie Rae, Laynie Luck, Levy Cruise, Marino Tenaglia, Matt Knicks, Philly Collins, Project Monix, Rylie Jackson, Sabin Gauge, Sean Galway, Wes Barkley, Xavier Sky | Rumble | |
Freelance Wrestling Thrash Unreal
Apr 22nd 2022 | Storm Grayson | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 11
Mar 17th 2022 | Gary Jay | def. | Brandon Williams | | |
ICW No Holds Barred The Pit 6
Nov 19th 2021 | AKIRA | def. (ref) | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Alive #24 Taping
Oct 1st 2021 | Thomas Shire | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2021 - Day 2
Sep 11th 2021 | Jake Crist | def. | 1 Called Manders, Gary Jay | three-way elimination | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2021 - Day 1
Sep 10th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. | Dimitri Alexandrov | | |
AAW Alive #23 Taping
Sep 2nd 2021 | Ren Jones | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 16
Jul 10th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. | Aaron Williams | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 14
Jul 4th 2021 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X9
Jul 3rd 2021 | Gary Jay | def. | Azrieal | | |
IWA-MS Who's Your Daddy
Jun 20th 2021 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | KTB & Shane Mercer | | |
IWA-MS Livin La Vida Loco
May 21st 2021 | Tyler Matrix (c) | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS Spring Fever 2021
Apr 15th 2021 | Kevin Giza | def. | Gary Jay | "pick your poison" | |
Beyond Time Capsule
Apr 10th 2021 | Dave Cole | def. (pin) | Anthony Stone, Dan Barry, Gary Jay | four-way elimination | |
Beyond Time Capsule
Apr 10th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. (pin) | Herzog | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X: Battle of the Tough Guys - Part 1
Apr 9th 2021 | Justin Kyle | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWTV Family Reunion 2021 - Part 2
Apr 8th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. | Billie Starkz | | |
No Peace Underground MurderMania
Apr 8th 2021 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Crist, Lucky 13, Neil Diamond Cutter | 5-way | |
AAW Alive #5 Taping
Apr 3rd 2021 | Matthew Justice | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS The 1000th Show
Mar 6th 2021 | Gnarls Garvin | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 10
Feb 27th 2021 | Justin Kyle | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X6
Feb 27th 2021 | Tony Deppen | def. | Gary Jay | | |
F1RST Live! - Show 1
Feb 21st 2021 | Don't Die Miles | def. | Gary Jay | | |
F1RST Live! - Show 2
Feb 21st 2021 | Arik Cannon (c), Devon Monroe | def. | Gary Jay, Jah-C | four-way | F1RST Wrestling Uptown VFW Title
|
IWA-MS Headed for a Heartbreak 2021
Feb 5th 2021 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | Jake Crist & Larry D | | |
IWA-MS You Can't Keep A Good Thing Down
Jan 21st 2021 | Devan Dixon (c) & Silas Mason (c) | def. | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | | IWA:MS Tag Team Titles
|
IWA-MS Out With The Old, In With The New 2021
Jan 2nd 2021 | Daniel Luck & Gary Jay | def. | Dewey Wellington & Kongo Kong | | |
IWA-MS Big Ass Christmas Bash 2020
Dec 19th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Dewey Wellington | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X5
Dec 12th 2020 | Dominic Garrini | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Hallobanger
Oct 22nd 2020 | Jake Crist (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS 24th Anniversary Show: In The Beginning
Oct 9th 2020 | Chris Dickinson | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro We're Back! A Wrestler's Story
Aug 22nd 2020 | Joshua Bishop | def. | Gary Jay | no disqualification | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '20 - Day 2
Aug 1st 2020 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Who's Your Dirty Daddy?
Jul 23rd 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Justin Kyle | | |
IWA-MS Unfinished Business
Jun 19th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Mance Warner | | |
IWA-MS The Eyes of March
Mar 12th 2020 | Brandon Taggart | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS In Like A Lion 2020
Mar 7th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Alice Crowley | | |
Freelance Wrestling Lucky Punks
Mar 6th 2020 | GPA | def. | Arik Cannon, Dan the Dad, Darin Corbin, Gary Jay, Kenny Sutra | 6-way scramble | |
IWA-MS Let the Madness Begin
Mar 5th 2020 | Aaron Williams (c) | draw | Gary Jay | 2 out of 3 falls | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
Black Label Pro Quantum Leap
Feb 29th 2020 | Kobe Durst | def. | Brayden Lee, Gary Jay, Johnathan Wolf, Joshua Bishop, Levi Everett | 6-way scramble | |
Gary Jay