| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Beyond Time Capsule
Apr 10th 2021 | Dave Cole | def. (pin) | Anthony Stone, Dan Barry, Gary Jay | four-way elimination | |
Beyond Time Capsule
Apr 10th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. (pin) | Herzog | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X: Battle of the Tough Guys - Part 1
Apr 9th 2021 | Justin Kyle | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IndependentWrestling.tv Family Reunion 2021 - Part 2
Apr 8th 2021 | Gary Jay | def. | Billie Starkz | | |
No Peace Underground MurderMania
Apr 8th 2021 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Crist, Lucky tHURTeen, Neil Diamond Cutter | 5-way | |
IWA-MS The 1000th Show
Mar 6th 2021 | Gnarls Garvin | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Headed for a Heartbreak 2021
Feb 5th 2021 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | Jake Crist & Larry D | | |
IWA-MS You Can't Keep A Good Thing Down
Jan 21st 2021 | Devan Dixon (c) & Silas Mason (c) | def. | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | | IWA:MS Tag Team Titles
|
IWA-MS Out With The Old, In With The New 2021
Jan 2nd 2021 | Daniel Luck & Gary Jay | def. | Dewey Wellington & Kongo Kong | | |
IWA-MS Big Ass Christmas Bash 2020
Dec 19th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Dewey Wellington | | |
IWA-MS Hallobanger
Oct 22nd 2020 | Jake Crist (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS 24th Anniversary Show: In The Beginning
Oct 9th 2020 | Chris Dickinson | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro We're Back! A Wrestler's Story
Aug 22nd 2020 | Joshua Bishop | def. | Gary Jay | no disqualification | |
IWA-MS King of the Death Matches 2020 - Day 2
Aug 1st 2020 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Who's Your Dirty Daddy?
Jul 23rd 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Justin Kyle | | |
IWA-MS Unfinished Business
Jun 19th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Mance Warner | | |
IWA-MS The Eyes of March
Mar 12th 2020 | Brandon Taggart | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS In Like A Lion 2020
Mar 7th 2020 | Gary Jay | def. | Alice Crowley | | |
IWA-MS Let the Madness Begin
Mar 5th 2020 | Aaron Williams (c) | draw | Gary Jay | 2 out of 3 falls | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
Black Label Pro Quantum Leap
Feb 29th 2020 | Kobe Durst | def. | Brayden Lee, Gary Jay, Johnathan Wolf, Joshua Bishop, Levi Everett | 6-way scramble | |
IWA-MS This Means War
Jan 30th 2020 | Aaron Williams & Logan James & Project Monix & Tyler Matrix | def. | Gary Jay & Jason Kincaid & Kevin Giza & Kongo Kong | 8-person tag | |
Black Label Pro Nobody Puts BLP In A Corner
Jan 18th 2020 | Jake Something | def. | Aaron Williams, Ace Perry, Alice Crowley, Ashtyn Braven, Austin Manix, Billie Starkz, Blair Onyx, Brett Michael David, Chase James, Cole Radrick, Danhausen, Dave Turner, Davey Bang, Dean Jacobs, Gary Jay, Graham Bell, Hawlee Cromwell, Idol Heinze, Josh Crane, Joshua Bishop, Kobe Durst, Levi Everett, Logan James, Lord Crewe, Nolan Edwards, Percy Davis, Project Monix, Reilly MaGuire, Shane Sabre, Shawn Kemp, Thomas Shire, Tre Lamar, Wheeler YUTA | Rumble | |
IWA-MS Out With The Old, In With The New 2020 - Day 2
Jan 4th 2020 | Aaron Williams | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Big Ass Christmas Bash 2019
Dec 7th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Lukas Jacobs | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 9
Nov 28th 2019 | Aaron Rourke | def. | Gary Jay | Discovery Gauntlet Match | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 8
Nov 21st 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Facade | Discovery Gauntlet Match | |
Black Label Pro Slamilton 2
Nov 16th 2019 | A. J. Gray (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | BLP Midwest Title
|
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 7
Nov 14th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. (pin) | Matt Makowski | Discovery Gauntlet Match | |
IWA-MS The Show Must Go On
Nov 2nd 2019 | Kevin Giza | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 16 - Part 1
Sep 21st 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 16 - Part 2
Sep 21st 2019 | Erick Stevens (c) | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Something, Tom Lawlor | four-way | IndependentWrestling.tv Title
|
Black Label Pro/GCW 2 Cups Stuffed
Aug 30th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Warhorse | | |
Black Label Pro McWrestling
Aug 24th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Alex Zayne | | |
Black Label Pro Dropkicks & Dragons
Jul 27th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Tom Lawlor | | |
Black Label Pro There's Something About Barry
Jun 1st 2019 | Ethan Page | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IndependentWrestling.tv The Midwest Mixtape
May 26th 2019 | Craig Mitchell | def. | Gary Jay | street fight | |
CZW Tangled Web 2019
May 11th 2019 | Jimmy Lloyd | def. | Cole Radrick, Gary Jay | three-way | |
Black Label Pro Player's Brawl
Apr 20th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Anthony Greene | | |
CZW Best of the Best 18
Apr 13th 2019 | John Silver | def. | Fred Yehi, Gary Jay, Kris Stadtlander | four-way | |
WrestlePro/CZW WrestlePro Vs. CZW
Apr 6th 2019 | Jordan Oliver | def. | Gary Jay, Jaxon Stone, Mr. Iguana | four-way | |
Black Label Pro Adventures In Wrestling
Apr 5th 2019 | A. J. Gray & C. W. Anderson & Curt Stallion & Gary Jay | def. | Chris Dickinson & Daniel Makabe & Jake Parnell & Rory Gulak | 8-person tag | |
IndependentWrestling.tv Family Reunion
Apr 4th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Jake Parnell | "Last Man Standing" | |
Black Label Pro Whoomp! There It Is!
Mar 9th 2019 | Jake Parnell (c) | def. | Gary Jay | "I Quit" | BLP Indiana State Title
|
CZW Twenty
Feb 9th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | John Silver | | |
Black Label Pro Unplugged
Feb 2nd 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Tyler Bateman | | |
CZW Night of Infamy 2018
Nov 10th 2018 | Kobe Durst | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro Big Trouble in Little Crown Point
Nov 3rd 2018 | Kevin Ku | def. | Gary Jay | | |
CZW Better Than Our Best
Oct 13th 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Jake Parnell | | |
IWA-MS Week 85
Oct 5th 2018 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2018 - Day 2
Sep 22nd 2018 | Calvin Tankman & Jake Lander & Jake Omen & Matt Kenway | def. | Gary Jay & Joey Owens & Shane Mercer & Tripp Cassidy | 8-person tag | |
Gary Jay