| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 GCW So Much Fun 2026
Mar 15th 2026 | Allie Katch & Effy | draw (NC) | Anakin Murphy & Gary Jay | | |
GCW Ransom 2026
Mar 8th 2026 | Alec Price (c) & Jordan Oliver (c) | def. | Abel & Jacksyn, Anakin Murphy & Gary Jay, August Matthews & Davey Bang | four-way tag | GCW Tag Team Titles
|
GCW So Alive 2026
Mar 7th 2026 | Gary Jay | def. | Beastman | | |
GCW Crime Wave 2026
Jan 18th 2026 | 1 Called Manders & Thomas Shire | def. (pin) | Anakin Murphy & Gary Jay | | |
GCW Rumble On The River
Sep 13th 2025 | KJ Orso | def. | Gary Jay | | |
GCW Hit 'Em Up 2025
Aug 1st 2025 | Masha Slamovich (c) | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | Jersey Championship Wrestling Heavyweight Title
|
GCW Bangin' In Little Rock
Jun 20th 2025 | Jonathan Gresham | def. | Gary Jay | | |
GCW Amerikaz Most Wanted 2025
Mar 30th 2025 | Mance Warner | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
GCW Thank Me Later 2025
Jan 11th 2025 | Isaiah Broner | def. | Gary Jay | | |
GCW Gateway To The Death 2
Nov 15th 2024 | Masha Slamovich (c) | def. | Gary Jay | "hardcore" | Jersey Championship Wrestling Heavyweight Title
|
Black Label Pro Observe This, Brother!!
Mar 25th 2023 | Levi Everett | def. | Adam Slade, Alice Crowley, Anakin Murphy, Arthur McArthur, Blair Onyx, Brayden Lee, Calvin Tankman, Chase Holliday, Chase Oliver, Crash Jaxon, Damian Chambers, Dan the Dad, Darius Latrell, Ezio Orlandi, Gary Jay, Haley Dylan, Jacob Gotch, Joey Gotch, Kevin Blackwood, Kobe Durst, Matt Brannigan, Matt Knicks, Myung-Jae Lee, Percy Davis, Rachel Armstrong, Regan Lydale, Sam Holloway, Shazza McKenzie, Steph De Lander, The Space Monkey, Tom Lawlor, Tony Adams, Trevor Outlaw, Trik Davis, ZDP | Rumble | |
Black Label Pro All My Friends Are Enemies
Feb 18th 2023 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | Dustin Waller & Kylon King | | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '20 - Day 2
Aug 1st 2020 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
FIP EVOLVE #46 Kickoff Show
Jul 11th 2015 | Alexandre Rudolph & Frank Wyatt & Jake Parnell | def. (pin) | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
EVOLVE #45
Jul 10th 2015 | Caleb Konley | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
FIP Accelerate '15
Jun 5th 2015 | Aaron Solow & Jason Cade | def. (pin) | Gary Jay & Jayson Falcone | | |
IWA-MS Spring's Eternal
May 3rd 2015 | Hy-Zaya (c) | def. | Dewey Barnes, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Mikey McFinnegan | 5-way | CCW Heavyweight Title
|
FIP Ascension 2015
Feb 20th 2015 | Eddie Graves (c) & Teddy Stigma (c) | def. (pin) | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | | FIP Tag Team Titles
|
FIP Ascension 2015
Feb 20th 2015 | Gary Jay | def. (pin) | Lince Dorado | | |
FIP Everything Burns '15
Jan 10th 2015 | Lince Dorado | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
FIP EVOLVE #36 Kickoff Show
Jan 9th 2015 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz & Lince Dorado | 6-person tag | |
FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz & Lince Dorado | 6-person tag | Fallout 2014 Trios Tournament
|
FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Jody Kristofferson & Maxwell Chicago & Rhett Giddins | 6-person tag | |
FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Graves & Jonny Vandal & Teddy Stigma | 6-person tag | |
Gary Jay