| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X19
Apr 19th 2024 | Malcolm Monroe III | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Legacy - The 20th Anniversary Event
Feb 23rd 2024 | Robert Anthony | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Windy City Classic XVIII
Dec 30th 2023 | Gary Jay | def. | David Ali | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X18
Nov 17th 2023 | Gary Jay | def. | Anakin Murphy | | |
AAW Unstoppable 2023
Oct 28th 2023 | Ren Jones | def. | Aaron Arsenal, August Matthews, Chico Suave, Conan Lycan, Davey Bang, Gary Jay, Gnarls Garvin, Hartenbower, Heather Reckless, Isaiah Moore, Jah-C, Jake Something, Joey Avalon, John E. Bravo, Koda Hernandez, Levi Everett, Maggie Lee, Perch, Robert Anthony, Russ Jones, Sabin Gauge, Sean Logan, Silas Young, Solomon Tupu, Sorta Incredible Iverson, Tony Rican, Victor Iniestra, Warhorse, Xavier Walker | Rumble | |
AAW Unstoppable 2023
Oct 28th 2023 | Silas Young | def. | Gary Jay | lumberjack match | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 95 - Are You Afraid Of The Dark?
Oct 26th 2023 | Mortar | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW The Chaos Theory 2023
Sep 29th 2023 | Jake Something | def. | Gary Jay, Isaiah Moore, Koa Laxamana, Levi Everett, Silas Young | 6-way scramble | |
AAW The Art Of War 2023
Aug 31st 2023 | Gary Jay | def. | Silas Young | | |
 wXw We Love Wrestling #46
May 27th 2023 | Laurance Roman (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | wXw Shotgun Title
|
KCW One Last Dance With Death
May 21st 2023 | Alton Throne | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro Observe This, Brother!!
Mar 25th 2023 | Levi Everett | def. | Adam Slade, Alice Crowley, Anakin Murphy, Arthur McArthur, Blair Onyx, Brayden Lee, Calvin Tankman, Chase Holliday, Chase Oliver, Crash Jaxon, Damian Chambers, Dan the Dad, Darius Latrell, Ezio Orlandi, Gary Jay, Haley Dylan, Jacob Gotch, Joey Gotch, Kevin Blackwood, Kobe Durst, Matt Brannigan, Matt Knicks, Myung-Jae Lee, Percy Davis, Rachel Armstrong, Regan Lydale, Sam Holloway, Shazza McKenzie, Steph De Lander, The Space Monkey, Tom Lawlor, Tony Adams, Trevor Outlaw, Trik Davis, ZDP | Rumble | |
AAW EPIC 19th Anniversary Show
Mar 24th 2023 | Gnarls Garvin | def. | Axel Rico, Brayden Lee, Crash Jaxon, Damian Chambers, Gary Jay | 6-way scramble | |
Black Label Pro All My Friends Are Enemies
Feb 18th 2023 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | Dustin Waller & Kylon King | | |
Limitless High Strung
Dec 31st 2022 | B3cca | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Unstoppable 2022
Dec 30th 2022 | Fred Yehi | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X13
Nov 18th 2022 | Joe Black | def. | Gary Jay | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 36
Nov 12th 2022 | Aaron Williams | def. | Gary Jay | deathmatch | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 24 - Part 1
Sep 24th 2022 | Kylon King | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW Destination Chicago 2022
Sep 1st 2022 | Gnarls Garvin | def. | Ace Perry, Dante Leon, Gary Jay, Gringo Loco, Laredo Kid | 6-way scramble | |
Freelance Underground This Thing Of Ours
Aug 13th 2022 | Aaron Williams & Gary Jay | def. | Joey Marx & Mason Conrad | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 29
Jul 23rd 2022 | Hardway Heeter | def. | Gary Jay | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X11
Jul 22nd 2022 | Gary Jay | def. | Joe Black | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 26 - Summer Stunner
Jun 30th 2022 | Pedro Dones | def. | Bobby Orlando, Brad Hollister, Gary Jay, Ryan Clancy, Tyree Taylor | 6-Way | |
AAW Crush And Destroy
Jun 11th 2022 | Davey Vega | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Gary Jay