| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 GCW Joey Janela's Spring Break: The Immortal Clusterf*ck
Apr 18th 2026 | Shotzi Blackheart | def. | 1 Called Manders, 25 Cent, Airica Demia, Alec Price, Anakin Murphy, B3cca, Bear Bronson, Beastman, Bobby Flaco, Brick Savage, Brooke Havok, Bryan Alvarez, Cereal Man, Channing Decker, Classy Ali, Conor Claxton, CPA, D-Lo Brown, Derek Dillinger, Devious Cass, Dinosaur 1, Dinosaur 2, Dinosaur 3, Don Freeze, Dr. Redacted, Emily Jaye, Frank the Clown, Gabby Forza, Gisele Shaw, Haley J, Heath Slater, Helix, Ian Maxwell, J. P. Grayson, Jack Osborne, Jay Lucas, Jazzy Yang, Jimmy Lloyd, Jimmy Townsend, Joey Janela, Jordan Oliver, Juicy Finau, Juli Montana, Juni Underwood, Kasey Owens, Katie Arquette, Killer Kelly, Kingsley, KJ Orso, L. J. Cleary, Logan Cavazos, Man Like DeReiss, Manny Lemons, Marcus Mathers, Matt Mako, Maya World, Monomoth, Mullet Man, Nate Webb, Nixi XS, Parrow, Rhys Maddox, Ro Montana, Ryan O'Neill, Sal Mistretta, Sam Holloway, Sam Osborne, Sam Stackhouse, Sean Ross Sapp, Shay Kassidy, Slade, Sleepy Ed, Starman, Stunt Marshall, Tara Zep, Terry Yaki, The Dark Sheik, The Invisible Man, Thomas Shire, Toby Klein, Tombstone Jesus, Tommy Grayson, Vipress, Wayne Rhodes, Will Kiedis, Wyatt Rhodes | Clusterfuck Battle Royal | |
GCW MDK Fight Club
Apr 17th 2026 | Otis Cogar (c) | def. (pin) | Toby Klein | unsanctioned street fight | GCW Ultraviolent Title
|
SHP High Stakes
Apr 15th 2026 | Dr. Redacted (c) | def. | Toby Klein | | ICW American Deathmatch Title
|
IWA-DS Smoky Mountain Massacre
Feb 21st 2026 | Toby Klein | def. (pin) | Satu Jinn | fans bring the weapons | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 91
Feb 20th 2026 | Hoodfoot | def. (pin) | Toby Klein | | |
JCW Bloodymania 14
Aug 20th 2021 | Shane Mercer | def. | Arthur McArthur, August Matthews, Cash Flo, Chuck Stone, Corporal Robinson, Davey Bang, Doink the Clown (Unknown), Hy-Zaya, Joshua Bishop, Kaplan, Shark Boy, Smokey C., Toby Klein, Unknown Participants | battle royale | |
CZW Tournament of Death 17
Jun 9th 2018 | Matt Tremont | def. (pin) | Jeff Cannonball, Toby Klein | fans bring the weapons (three-way) | |
IWA-MS Kings of the Crimson Mask 2.0
Sep 16th 2017 | Toby Klein | def. | The Zodiak | "Thumbtack Madness Carpet Strips" Match | |
IWA-MS 19th Anniversary Show
Oct 9th 2015 | Insane Lane | def. | Mr. Insanity | | |
CZW Brain Damage Memorial Show
Nov 10th 2012 | Toby Klein | def. | Danny Havoc | | |
CZW Night of Infamy 11
Nov 10th 2012 | Azrieal (c) & Bandido Jr. (c) | def. (pin) | BLK Jeez & Ruckus, Human Tornado & Toby Klein | three-way tag | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
AIW The J.T. Lightning Memorial Show
Sep 26th 2011 | Ian Decay | def. | Toby Klein | "hardcore" | |
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 5
May 24th 2010 | Mad Man Pondo (c) | def. | Toby Klein | | JCW Heavyweight Title
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 5
May 24th 2010 | Toby Klein | def. | A Dead Guy, Bobby Beverly, Dave Crist, Eric Ryan, Facade, Jake Crist, Jason Gory, John Thorne, Luis Diamante, Tarek the Legend | Battle Royal | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Bobby Beverly & Eric Ryan & T. J. Dynamite | def. | Chris Dickinson & Toby Klein & Tommy Mercer | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 1
Apr 9th 2010 | Chris Dickinson & Toby Klein & Tommy Mercer | def. | Elkview Adam & Mad Man Pondo & Zac Vincent | 6-person tag | |
CZW Tournament of Death VIII
Jun 6th 2009 | WHACKS | def. (pin) | Toby Klein | "Barbed Wire Boards & Light Tubes" | |
CZW Eye for an Eye
Apr 11th 2009 | Jon Dahmer | def. (pin) | Toby Klein | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 1
Mar 27th 2009 | Chuck Taylor & Gran Akuma & Icarus | def. (pin) | Brain Damage & Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | 6-person tag | |
CZW Total Havoc
Mar 14th 2009 | Mad Man Pondo & Nate Hatred & Nick Gage | def. (sub) | Brain Damage & Deranged & Toby Klein | "Barbed Wire Tables" (3 on 3) | |
IWA-MS Double Death Tag Tournament - Night 1
Oct 18th 2008 | Brain Damage & Deranged | def. | Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | fans bring the weapons (2 on 2) | |
IWA-MS 12th Anniversary Show
Oct 4th 2008 | Corporal Robinson & Ian Rotten | def. | Deranged & Toby Klein | | |
CZW Down With The Sickness Forever '08
Sep 13th 2008 | Brain Damage & Danny Havoc | def. | Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | | |
CZW Chri$ Ca$h Memorial Show '08
Sep 13th 2008 | Brain Damage (c) | def. (pin) | Toby Klein | | CZW Ironman Title
|
IWA-MS KIngs of the Crimson Mask
Aug 2nd 2008 | Insane Lane | def. | Toby Klein | "Stairway to Hell Barbed Wire Boards" | |
Toby Klein