| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 JCW Bloodymania 14
Aug 20th 2021 | Shane Mercer | def. | Arthur McArthur, August Matthews, Cash Flo, Chuck Stone, Corporal Robinson, Davey Bang, Doink the Clown (Unknown), Hy-Zaya, Joshua Bishop, Kaplan, Shark Boy, Smokey C., Toby Klein, Unknown Participants | battle royale | |
CZW Tournament of Death 17
Jun 9th 2018 | Matt Tremont | def. | Jeff Cannonball, Toby Klein | fans bring the weapons (three-way) | |
IWA-MS Kings of the Crimson Mask 2.0
Sep 16th 2017 | Toby Klein | def. | The Zodiak | "Thumbtack Madness Carpet Strips" Match | |
IWA-MS 19th Anniversary Show
Oct 9th 2015 | Insane Lane | def. | Mr. Insanity | | |
CZW Brain Damage Memorial Show
Nov 10th 2012 | Toby Klein | def. | Danny Havoc | | |
CZW Night of Infamy 11
Nov 10th 2012 | Azrieal (c) & Bandido Jr. (c) | def. (pin) | BLK Jeez & Ruckus, Human Tornado & Toby Klein | three-way tag | CZW Tag Team Titles
|
AIW The J.T. Lightning Memorial Show
Sep 26th 2011 | Ian Decay | def. | Toby Klein | "hardcore" | |
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 5
May 24th 2010 | Mad Man Pondo (c) | def. | Toby Klein | | JCW Heavyweight Title
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 5
May 24th 2010 | Toby Klein | def. | A Dead Guy, Bobby Beverly, Dave Crist, Eric Ryan, Facade, Jake Crist, Jason Gory, John Thorne, Luis Diamante, Tarek the Legend | Battle Royal | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Bobby Beverly & Eric Ryan & T. J. Dynamite | def. | Chris Dickinson & Toby Klein & Tommy Mercer | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 1
Apr 9th 2010 | Chris Dickinson & Toby Klein & Tommy Mercer | def. | Elkview Adam & Mad Man Pondo & Zac Vincent | 6-person tag | |
CZW Tournament of Death VIII
Jun 6th 2009 | WHACKS | def. | Toby Klein | "Barbed Wire Boards & Light Tubes" | |
CZW Eye for an Eye
Apr 11th 2009 | Jon Dahmer | def. | Toby Klein | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 1
Mar 27th 2009 | Chuck Taylor & Gran Akuma & Icarus | def. (pin) | Brain Damage & Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | 6-person tag | |
CZW Total Havoc
Mar 14th 2009 | Mad Man Pondo & Nate Hatred & Nick Gage | def. | Brain Damage & Deranged & Toby Klein | deathmatch (3 on 3) | |
IWA-MS Double Death Tag Tournament - Night 1
Oct 18th 2008 | Brain Damage & Deranged | def. | Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | fans bring the weapons (2 on 2) | |
IWA-MS 12th Anniversary Show
Oct 4th 2008 | Corporal Robinson & Ian Rotten | def. | Deranged & Toby Klein | | |
CZW Down With The Sickness Forever '08
Sep 13th 2008 | Brain Damage & Danny Havoc | def. | Necro Butcher & Toby Klein | | |
CZW Chri$ Ca$h Memorial Show '08
Sep 13th 2008 | Brain Damage | def. | Toby Klein | | |
IWA-MS KIngs of the Crimson Mask
Aug 2nd 2008 | Insane Lane | def. | Toby Klein | "Stairway to Hell Barbed Wire Boards" | |
IWA-MS Gory Days 4: Home Sweet Home
Jul 26th 2008 | Deranged & Toby Klein | def. | Corey Shaddix & Freakshow & Corporal Robinson & Mad Man Pondo | "Barbed Wire Massacre" (3-way tag) | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '08: Night 2
Jun 21st 2008 | Dingo (c) | def. | Toby Klein | | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '08: Night 1
Jun 20th 2008 | Jimmy Jacobs & Tyler Black | def. | Robert Anthony & Toby Klein | | |
IWA-MS Extreme Intentions
Jun 7th 2008 | Deranged | def. | Tank & Toby Klein | street fight | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2008
Apr 12th 2008 | Michael Elgin (c) | def. | Tank, Toby Klein | three-way | IWA:MS Strong Style Championship
|
Toby Klein