| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Freelance Wrestling Golden Double Axe Handle
Dec 1st 2022 | August Matthews (c) & Davey Bang (c) | def. | Ashton Starr & Rico Gonzalez | | Freelance Tag Team Titles
|
GCW Effy's Big Gay Brunch 5
Sep 4th 2022 | Ashton Starr | def. | Sandra Moone | | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 13
Aug 1st 2022 | Ashton Starr | def. | Rico Gonzalez, Rob Killjoy | three-way elimination | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 12
Jul 25th 2022 | Adam Priest | def. | Ashton Starr, Rico Gonzalez, Rob Killjoy | four-way | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 11
Jul 18th 2022 | Jaden Newman | def. | Ash Bennett, Ashton Starr, Billie Starkz, Billy Tipton, Bobby Flaco, Brandon Williams, Brogan Finlay, Carson Dillbeck, Diego Hill, Dillon McQueen, Erron Wade, Hunter Drake, Kenzie Paige, Kody Manhorn, Krule, Merrik Donovan, Nick Iggy, Pete Youngblood, Rico Gonzalez, Rob Killjoy, Sean Campbell, Suge D., Tre Havoc, White Mike | Rumble | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 9
Jul 4th 2022 | Rob Killjoy | def. | Ashton Starr, Rico Gonzalez | three-way | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 8
Jun 27th 2022 | Hunter Drake & Kenzie Paige & Nick Iggy | def. | Ashton Starr & Rico Gonzalez & Rob Killjoy | 6-person tag | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 4
May 30th 2022 | Ashton Starr | def. | Rob Killjoy | | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 2
May 16th 2022 | Derek Neal | def. | Ashton Starr | | |
IWTV Southeast First Uncharted Territory: Season 4 Episode 1
May 9th 2022 | Alec Price (c) | def. | Ashton Starr | | SUP Bonestorm Title
|
GCW Effy's Big Gay Brunch 2022
Apr 2nd 2022 | Dillon McQueen & Kenzie Paige | def. | Ace Perry & Devon Monroe, A. C. Mack & Ashton Starr, Aiden Aggro & The Danger Kid | four-way tag | |
WWR Galentine's Day Massacre
Feb 13th 2022 | Ashton Starr | def. | Jody Threat | | |
AEW Dark #132 Taping
Feb 5th 2022 | Sonny Kiss | def. (pin) | Ashton Starr | | |
IWTV The Masked Wrestler: Season 2 Episode 2 (airdate)
Feb 2nd 2022 | El Gato Blanco | def. | Jesterclops | | |
ACTION/IWTV Southeast First
Jan 21st 2022 | BK Westbrook & BoJack & Diego Hill | def. | Ashton Starr & Bobby Flaco & Brogan Finlay | 6-person tag | |
N/A Zicky Dice's Outlandish Paradise
Jan 15th 2022 | Carlie Bravo | def. | Andreas Ziegler, Ashton Starr, Brogan Finlay, Check Guzman, Dillon McQueen, Donnie Janela, Jonah Turk, Kenny Alfonso, Luca Proctor, Manny Lemons, Nasty Leroy, Owen Knight, Sal Rinauro, Shoot Taylor, SK Bishop, Stunt Marshall, The Warden, Trip Jordy, Victor Cortez | battle royale | |
GCW Effy's Big Gay Brunch Chicago
Sep 5th 2021 | Ashton Starr | def. | Devon Monroe | | |
Tmart Promotions The Gathering II: Hilton Rumble
Jul 24th 2021 | Caleb Konley & Zane Riley | def. | Ashton Starr & David Ali | | |
No Peace Underground Effy's Fear the Gay Agenda
Jun 11th 2021 | Billy Dixon | def. | Ashton Starr | no ring deathmatch | |
GCW Effy's Big Gay Brunch 2021
Apr 10th 2021 | Ashton Starr | def. | Allie Kat, Frontman Jah, Jared Evans, Killian McMurphy, The Whisper | 6-way scramble | |
IWTV Family Reunion 2021 - Part 2
Apr 8th 2021 | A. C. Mack & MV Young | def. | Ashton Starr & Jared Evans, Erica Leigh & The Boar, Eel O'Neal & Jordan Black | four-way tag | |
IWTV Cassandro Cup
Mar 28th 2021 | Edith Surreal | def. | Ashton Starr | | |
IWTV Cassandro Cup
Mar 28th 2021 | Ashton Starr | def. | A. C. Mack | | |
IWTV Cassandro Cup
Mar 28th 2021 | Ashton Starr | def. | Jared Evans | | |
GCW Fight Forever: Effy's Big Gay Block
Jan 30th 2021 | Ashton Starr | def. (pin) | Dillon McQueen | | |
AEW Dark #61 Taping
Nov 4th 2020 | Penta El Zero Miedo & Rey Fenix | def. (pin) | Ashton Starr & David Ali | | |
GCW Effy's Big Gay Brunch
Oct 10th 2020 | Ashley Vox & Delmi Exo | def. | A. C. Mack & Ashton Starr | | |
WWNLive Style Battle - S1:E6
Aug 4th 2017 | Leon Ruff | def. | A. C. Mack, Alan Angels, Ashton Starr, David Ali, James Bandy, Kavron Kanyon, Tony Midas | 8-way | |
WWNLive Style Battle - S1:E2
Feb 10th 2017 | Austin Theory | def. (pin) | A. C. Mack, Alan Angels, Alex Taylor, Ashton Starr, Connor Braxton, CT Brown, Eddie Machete, Jackson Kelly, Matt Palmer, Snoop Strikes, Tommy Maserati, Xander Killen | fray | |
Beyond Sleeper Cell
Jun 28th 2014 | Da Fireman | def. | Ashton Starr, Marko Polo, Wade Adams | four-way | |
Ashton Starr