| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 GCW Amerikaz Most Wanted 2025
Mar 30th 2025 | Masha Slamovich (c) | def. (sub) | Blake Christian, Caleb Konley, Jimmy Lloyd | four-way | Jersey Championship Wrestling Heavyweight Title
|
JCW/ALW JCW Vs. ALW Wicked Game
Mar 28th 2025 | Caleb Konley | def. | Mike Mondo | | |
JCW Lunacy #30 Taping
Mar 8th 2025 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Luigi Primo | | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #29 Taping
Mar 8th 2025 | Dani Mo & Facade | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley & Colby Corino | | |
JCW Lunacy #27 Taping
Mar 7th 2025 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Facade | | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #28 Taping
Mar 7th 2025 | Luigi Primo | def. | Billy Crook, Caleb Konley, Cocaine, Colby Corino, Dani Mo, Earnest Olsson, El Lycan, Facade, J.C. Westerfield, Javi Chacon, Kendrick Averys, King Khan, Kongo Kong, Lucha Mike, Mateo Gemini, Maverick the Unbranded Bull, Maxo, Miles Clark, Narval, Ozzi G, Painful Paul, Stud Bronson, The Manimal | battle royale | JCW Battle Royale Championship
(title change) |
JCW Lunacy #25 Taping
Mar 6th 2025 | Caleb Konley | def. (pin) | 2 Tuff Tony (c) | | JCW American Title
(title change) |
JCW Lunacy #24 Taping
Feb 15th 2025 | Mickie Knuckles | def. | Caleb Konley | | |
JCW Lunacy #22 Taping
Feb 14th 2025 | Caleb Konley & Painful Paul | def. | Luigi Primo & Mickie Knuckles | | |
JCW Lunacy #20 Taping - Big Baller Holiday Party 2024
Dec 21st 2024 | 2 Tuff Tony | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley (c) | | JCW American Title
(title change) |
JCW Lunacy #19 Taping - Big Baller Holiday Party 2024
Dec 21st 2024 | Dani Mo & Facade | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley & Rae Larson | | |
JCW Deck The Jaws
Dec 19th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Cocaine, Tarzan | three-way | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #18 - March of Madness: St. Louis
Dec 5th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | draw (NC) | Tarzan | | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #17 - March of Madness: Little Rock
Dec 4th 2024 | Breyer Wellington & Caleb Konley & Painful Paul | def. (pin) | Cocaine & Luigi Primo & Lumber Pit Mike | 6-person tag | |
JCW Spanks Givin'
Nov 30th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. | Facade, Mosh Pit Mime | three-way | JCW American Title
|
GCW Hawaiimania
Nov 2nd 2024 | 2 Tuff Tony & Aerial Van Go & Caleb Konley & Matt Cross | def. | Bobby Flaco & Jake Lander & Jeffrey John & King Atapa | 8-person tag | |
JCW Lunacy #16 - Train of Terror Tour: Hallowicked
Oct 31st 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Alex Taylor, Simon Gotch, Tarzan | four-way | JCW American Title
|
JCW Devil's Night 2024
Oct 30th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Matt Riddle | | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #15 - Train of Terror Tour: Joliet
Oct 29th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Luigi Primo, Officer Colt Cabana, Willie Mack | four-way | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy #14 - Train of Terror Tour: Milwaukee
Oct 28th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Mecha Wolf, Tarzan | three-way | JCW American Title
|
Wrestling Revolver Taste Of Truth
Aug 24th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. | Facade, Fulton, Jeffrey John, Robert Martyr, Simon Gotch | 6-way scramble | JCW American Title
|
JCW Bloodymania 17
Aug 16th 2024 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. | Simon Gotch | | JCW American Title
|
JCW Lunacy @ The Gathering of the Juggalos (incomplete card)
Aug 15th 2024 | Caleb Konley | def. | 2 Tuff Tony, Alex Taylor, Breyer Wellington, Chris Malvado, Deputy Dickhead, Dick Ramirez, J. P. Grayson, Jeeves, Kerry Morton, Kongo Kong, Matt Cross, MLB, Painful Paul, Super Beast, The Green Phantom, Tommy Grayson | battle royale | JCW American Title
(title change) |
JCW Three Town Beatdown - Day 1
Jul 25th 2024 | Matt Cross | def. | Ace Austin, Caleb Konley, Jake Crist | four-way | |
Black Label Pro Showdown At The Shoreline
May 5th 2024 | Aero Boy | def. | El Manik | | |
JCW Lunacy #1 Taping
May 3rd 2024 | Ruffo The Clown (c) & Yabo the Clown (c) | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley & Facade | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Lunacy #2 Taping
May 3rd 2024 | Caleb Konley | def. (pin) | Facade | | |
Limitless Guilty Pleasures
Apr 13th 2024 | Hazard | def. | Suicide | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 119
Apr 11th 2024 | T. J. Crawford | def. | Suicide | | |
WCPBTW The Reunion 3: Cavalcade Of Legends
Mar 9th 2024 | Ultimo Dragon | def. | El Manik | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade SuperShow 2023
Nov 25th 2023 | Violent J | def. | A. J. Cazana, Alex Taylor, Axton Ray, Barry Royal, Ben Bishop, Caleb Konley, Dave Dawson, Facade, Freeman, Griff Garrison, Gustavo, JAC, Jay Insane, Johnny Swinger, K. C. Cazana, Kerry Morton, LT James, Mad Man Pondo, Marcus Kross, Mr. Hughes, Richard Holliday, Ricky Morton, Ruffo The Clown, Shane Douglas, Shane Taylor, Silas Mason, Vampiro, White Mike, Yabo the Clown, Zane Dawson, Zuka King | battle royale | |
GCW At WrestleCade Weekend
Nov 24th 2023 | Richard Holliday | def. | Caleb Konley | | |
WCPBTW The Great Fall Bash 2
Sep 30th 2023 | Dru Skillz & Meng & The Barbarian | def. | Bushwhacker Luke & Caleb Konley & Tommy Rich | 6-person tag | |
WCPBTW The Great Fall Bash 2
Sep 30th 2023 | N8 Mattson | def. | Suicide | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #28 Taping
Sep 2nd 2023 | Boulder & Bronson | def. | Caleb Konley & Ren Jones | | |
GCW My Name Is
Aug 4th 2023 | Jordan Oliver | def. | Adrian Alanis, Caleb Konley, Jimmy Lloyd, Rico Gonzalez, Shane Mercer | 6-way scramble | |
GCW I Can't Save You
May 21st 2023 | Ciclope & Crazy King & Miedo Extremo | def. | Caleb Konley & Chico Suave & Jimmy Lloyd | 6-person tag | |
GCW The Way I Am
May 20th 2023 | Cole Radrick | def. | Alec Price, August Matthews, Caleb Konley, Davey Bang | 5-way | |
GCW Into The Light
Apr 21st 2023 | Jimmy Lloyd & Mr. Danger & Terry Yaki & Yoya | def. | Bobby Flaco & Caleb Konley & Donnie Primetime & Hunter Drake | 8-person tag | |
AEW Dark #184 Taping
Jan 28th 2023 | Tony Deppen | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley | | |
GCW Don't Talk To Me
Jan 20th 2023 | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | BoJack & Lucky Ali, Caleb Konley & Zane Riley, George South & John Wayne Murdoch | four-way tag | |
AEW Dark #175 Taping
Dec 17th 2022 | Kip Sabian | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley | | |
Impact Wrestling IPWF Throwback Throwdown III Taping
Nov 25th 2022 | DJ 2Large | def. (pin) | Buck Humphrey | | |
AEW Dark #169 Taping
Oct 21st 2022 | Eddie Kingston & Ortiz | def. | A. R. Fox & Caleb Konley | | |
N/A Best Trivia Ever Presents Slam Two
Sep 22nd 2022 | Jaylen Brandyn & Traevon Jordan | def. | Caleb Konley & Zane Riley | | |
AEW Dark #163 Taping
Aug 21st 2022 | Angélico | def. (sub) | Caleb Konley | | |
GCW Sanctified
Aug 19th 2022 | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Caleb Konley & Zane Riley | | |
Tmart Promotions The Gathering III
Aug 6th 2022 | Lodi | def. | Caleb Konley | | |
AEW Dark #150 Taping
Jun 11th 2022 | Ariya Daivari | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley | | |
WrestleCon USA Vs. The World 2022
Apr 2nd 2022 | Aero Boy & Aramis & Arez | def. (pin) | Caleb Konley & Flip Gordon & Gringo Loco | 6-person tag | |
Caleb Konley