| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 DREAMWAVE Nothin' But A Good Time
Jun 17th 2023 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Florida Man | | |
 Smash (Canada) Put Up Or Shut Up
Apr 30th 2023 | Charles Crowley | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
Smash (Canada) Live, Laugh, Lariat
Apr 29th 2023 | Psycho Mike | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
Limitless Identity Crisis
Apr 22nd 2023 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Mac Daniels | | |
Heroes & Legends XVIII
Oct 29th 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Scotty Young | | |
WrestlePro Champions Of Hope
Oct 28th 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Dan Maff | | |
WrestlePro Alaska: Back With a Bang
Oct 1st 2022 | Jay Lethal | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
N/A Best Trivia Ever Presents Slam Two
Sep 22nd 2022 | Dan the Dad & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Dean Alexander & Rosario Grillo | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special - Saturday Night Riot 2022
Aug 6th 2022 | Kal Herro & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. (pin) | Deget Bundlez & Eric Darkstorm | | |
 OTT Poetry Slam
Jul 22nd 2022 | Scott Garland | def. | Renzo Rose | "open challenge" | |
 Wrestle Carnival Ring Masters
Jul 10th 2022 | Charles Crowley (c) | def. | Scott Garland | | Wrestle Carnival King of the Carnival
|
Prestige Roseland 3 - Day 2
May 29th 2022 | Tom Lawlor | def. | MV Young, Scotty 2 Hotty | three-way | |
Prestige Roseland 3 - Day 1
May 28th 2022 | Ethan HD | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
FWF Live! 3
May 15th 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty & Thrasher (c) | def. | Bobby Orlando & Bryce Donovan | | FWF Tag Team Titles
|
WrestlePro May-Hem
May 7th 2022 | Colt Cabana | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
OTT Turn It Up!
Apr 17th 2022 | Adam Maxted | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
N/A Zicky Dice's Trouble in Paradise 2
Apr 1st 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Rich Swann | | |
CYN The Awakening: Dallas
Mar 31st 2022 | Scott Garland | def. | AJZ | | |
OTT The Hangover Show
Mar 13th 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty & Session Moth Martina | def. | B-Cool & Danny Cross | | |
OTT ScrapperMania VI
Mar 12th 2022 | Sammy D | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
Limitless 2 Hot To Handle
Feb 26th 2022 | Dirty Dango & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Aaron Rourke & Brad Cashew & Ricky Smokes | handicap tag | |
BTW Live in Spartanburg
Jan 22nd 2022 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Teddy Goodz | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special - Nightmare Rumble 2022
Jan 15th 2022 | Omar Amir | def. | Amon, Big Zo, Brandon Espinosa, Cash Flo, D'mone Solavino, Deget Bundlez, Dimes, Dustin Jackson, Eric Darkstorm, Gustavo, Hy-Zaya, Jack Vaughn, Joey Avalon, Kal Herro, Kevin Thorn, Koda Jacobs, Luscious Lawrence, Mahabali Shera, Matt Vine, Reverend Ronnie Roberts, Scotty 2 Hotty, Star Rider, Steve Michaels, Tom Coffey, Tony Bizo, Tony Evans, Tony Gunn, Truth Magnum, Turbo Floyd | Nightmare Rumble | |
GCW Die 4 This
Jan 1st 2022 | Joey Janela | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
Wrestling Revolver The Debut
Jun 10th 2016 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. (pin) | Jake Manning | | |
ECWA 20th Annual Super 8 Tournament - All Star Edition
Apr 23rd 2016 | John Skyler | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro BLITZKRIEGPROANDCHILL
Jan 9th 2016 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Jeremy Leary | | |
 wXw Fans Appreciation Night 2015: Hamburg
Aug 28th 2015 | Grandmaster Sexay & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Kevin Roadster & Marius van Beethoven | | |
GLCW Casablanca Rumble 2015
Jul 25th 2015 | Scotty 2 Hotty & Vic Capri | def. | Hardcore Craig & Tony Scarpone | | |
2CW Living On The Edge X - Day 1
Apr 4th 2015 | Gregory Iron & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Little Guido & Tony Mamaluke | | |
 NOAH Great Voyage '14 in Tokyo Vol. 3 - The Battle of Ariake in Winter
Dec 6th 2014 | FUNAKI & Scotty 2 Hotty & Super Crazy | def. | Pesadilla & Yoshinari Ogawa & Zack Sabre Jr. | 6-person tag | |
RevPro Uprising 2014
Oct 18th 2014 | Brian Christopher & Rikishi & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Josh Bodom & Sha Samuels & Terry Frazier | 6-person tag | |
OMEGA Loco in Joco 2
Sep 20th 2014 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Mickey Gambino | | |
MCW (Maryland) Rally In The Ally
Sep 5th 2014 | Napalm Bomb (c) & Solo (c) | def. | Grandmaster Sexay & Scotty 2 Hotty | | MCW Tag Team Titles
|
Heroes & Legends III
Mar 22nd 2014 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Kharn Alexander | | |
NXT ArRIVAL
Feb 27th 2014 | Konnor (c) & Viktor (c) | def. (pin) | Grandmaster Sexay & Scotty 2 Hotty | | NXT Tag Team Titles
|
WWE Monday Night Raw
Jan 6th 2014 | Grandmaster Sexay & Rikishi & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. (pin) | Drew McIntyre & Heath Slater & Jinder Mahal | 6-person tag | |
NXT TV Taping #9
Jul 11th 2012 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. (pin) | Heath Slater | | |
2CW Parole Violation
Mar 3rd 2012 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Cheech | | |
AWR Title Fight Limerick
Oct 7th 2011 | Dunkan Disorderly | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
2CW Beadledom Begets Bedlam
Sep 17th 2011 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Zachary Springate III | | |
SMASH (Japan) Show #10
Nov 22nd 2010 | AKIRA & KAORU & Nagisa Nozaki & Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Nunzio & TAKA Michinoku & Tomoka Nakagawa & Toshi Uematsu | 8-person tag | |
VPW Terror Dome '10
Oct 24th 2010 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. (pin) | Matt Carlos | | |
SMASH (Japan) Show #5
Jul 24th 2010 | Eugene & Scotty 2 Hotty & TAKA Michinoku | def. | KUSHIDA & Lynn Byron & TAJIRI | 6-person tag | |
SMASH (Japan) Show #6
Jul 24th 2010 | Eugene & Shuri | def. | Scotty 2 Hotty & TAKA Michinoku | | |
ROH SoCal Showdown
Jan 29th 2010 | Larry Zbyszko | def. (pin) | Scotty 2 Hotty | | |
 AWR European Invasion '09 - Day 13
Dec 9th 2009 | Scotty 2 Hotty | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR European Invasion '09 - Day 12
Dec 8th 2009 | Scotty 2 Hotty & X-Pac | def. | Justin Shape & Sean Maxer Brennan | | |
 AWR European Invasion '09 - Day 11
Dec 6th 2009 | Scotty 2 Hotty & X-Pac | def. | Dunkan Disorderly & Sean Maxer Brennan | | |
 AWR European Invasion '09 - Day 10
Dec 4th 2009 | Scotty 2 Hotty & X-Pac | def. | Dunkan Disorderly & Sean Maxer Brennan | | |
Scotty 2 Hotty