| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT TV #673
Jul 29th 2025 | Ethan Page (c) | def. (pin) | Santino Marella | | NXT North American Championship
|
 AAA Verano De Escandalo 2025
Jul 11th 2025 | La Hiedra & Mr. Iguana | def. | Lola Vice & Santino Marella | | |
TNA Against All Odds 2025
Jun 6th 2025 | Santino Marella | def. (pin) | Robert Stone | referee: Matt Cardona | |
TNA Border Brawl
May 25th 2025 | Cody Deaner & Jody Threat & Matt Hardy & Santino Marella & Tommy Dreamer | def. | Alisha Edwards & Brian Myers & Eddie Edwards & JDC & Moose | 10-person tag | |
TNA Border Brawl
May 25th 2025 | Santino Marella | def. | Nic Nemeth | flag | |
 TNA Impact #1088 Taping
May 24th 2025 | Robert Stone & Victoria Crawford | def. (pin) | Arianna Grace & Santino Marella | referee: Alisha Edwards | |
MLP Northern Rising
May 10th 2025 | Josh Alexander | def. | Alex Zayne, Bhupinder Gujjar, Billy Gunn, Bishop Dyer, Brent Banks, El Phantasmo, Johnny Parisi, Matt Cardona, Michael Allen Richard Clark, Mo Jabari, PCO, Psycho Mike, Q. T. Marshall, Raj Dhesi, Rhino, Rich Swann, Santino Marella, Sheldon Jean, Slex | "Gauntlet For The Gold" | MLP Canadian Championship
(title change) |
GLCW Blizzard Brawl 2024
Dec 7th 2024 | Al Snow (c) & Kal Herro (c) | def. | Damien Sandow & Santino Marella | referee: Braun Strowman | GLCW Tag Team Titles
|
 N/A Josh Barnett's Bloodsport Bushido
Jun 22nd 2024 | Kazushi Sakuraba | def. (sub) | Santino Marella | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #1010 - IPWF Throwback Throwdown IV Taping
Nov 11th 2023 | Tim Burr | def. (pin) | Boris Alexiev | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact #988 Taping
Jul 16th 2023 | Dirty Dango | def. (pin) | Santino Marella | | |
Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2023
Apr 16th 2023 | Dirty Dango & Joe Hendry & Santino Marella | def. (pin) | Angels & Callihan & Deaner & Kon | handicap tag | |
 OTT ScrapperMania VII - Day 2
Mar 18th 2023 | Ilija Zarkov & Renzo Rose | def. | Santino Marella & The Sem | | |
DWW Summer Heat 2022
Aug 21st 2022 | Gabriel Fuerza & Vaughn Vertigo | draw (NC) | Heath Miller & Santino Marella | | |
WWE Royal Rumble '20
Jan 26th 2020 | Charlotte Flair | def. | Alexa Bliss, Beth Phoenix, Bianca BelAir, Candice LeRae, Carmella, Chelsea Green, Dakota Kai, Dana Brooke, Kairi Sane, Kelly Kelly, Lana, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Mercedes Martinez, Mia Yim, Mighty Molly, Naomi, Natalya, Nikki Cross, Santina, Sarah Logan, Shayna Baszler, Shotzi Blackheart, Sonya Deville, Tamina, Tegan Nox, Toni Storm, Xia Li, Zelina Vega | 30-woman Royal Rumble | |
GCW Josh Barnett's Bloodsport 2
Sep 14th 2019 | Anthony Carelli | def. (sub) | Simon Grimm | | |
DDT Beer Garden Fight 2019 Extra Edition ~ Shin-Kiba Beer Garden One Night Stand ~
Aug 30th 2019 | Santino Marella | def. | Antonio Honda | | |
DDT Summer Vacation Memories 2019
Aug 25th 2019 | Antonio Honda & Konosuke Takeshita & Sanshiro Takagi & Yukio Sakaguchi | def. | Danshoku Dino & MAO & Santino Marella & Super Sasadango Machine | 8-person tag | |
WrestlePro Does Funny = Money?
Apr 3rd 2019 | Colt Cabana & Santino Marella | def. | Desirable Dustin & Gigolo Justin | | |
DWW Carnage 2019
Jan 20th 2019 | Santino Marella & Stone Rockwell | def. | Gursinder Singh & Raj Singh | | |
DWW Summer Heat 2017
Aug 27th 2017 | Chavo Guerrero Jr. & Santino Marella | def. | John Atlas & R. J. City | | |
DREAMWAVE Summer Spectacular 2016
Aug 6th 2016 | Joey Ryan | def. (pin) | Santino Marella (c) | referee: Mick Foley | DDT Iron Man Heavy Metal Title
(title change) |
DREAMWAVE Summer Spectacular 2016
Aug 6th 2016 | Santino Marella | def. (pin) | Suge D. (c) | referee: Mick Foley | DDT Iron Man Heavy Metal Title
(title change) |
WWE WWE Live
Jun 28th 2014 | Emma & Santino Marella | def. (pin) | Fandango & Layla | | |
WWE WWE Live
Jun 22nd 2014 | Emma & Paige & Santino Marella | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Fandango & Layla | 6-person tag | |
Santino Marella