| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT Fort Pierce Show
Dec 13th 2019 | Travis Banks | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Dec 7th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Omari Palmer | | |
NXT Dade City Show
Dec 6th 2019 | KUSHIDA | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
Nov 15th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Omari Palmer | | |
NXT TV #375
Nov 13th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Daniel Vidot | dark
| |
NXT St. Augustine Show
Nov 9th 2019 | Denzel Dejournette & Nick Ogarelli | def. | Aleksander Jaksic & Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Nov 8th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Mofahim | | |
NXT Ocala Show
Nov 7th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Omari Palmer | | |
NXT Largo Show
Nov 1st 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Cal Bloom | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Oct 31st 2019 | Bronson Reed | def. | Aleksander Jaksic, Brendan Vink, Cal Bloom, Cezar Bononi, Chase Parker, Daniel Vidot, Dexter Lumis, Jeet Rama, Marcel Barthel, Mohamed Fahim, Nick Ogarelli, Steve Cutler | Halloween Costume Battle Royal | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Oct 25th 2019 | Jeet Rama | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Dade City Show
Oct 24th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Mohamed Fahim | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Oct 18th 2019 | Boa & Jeet Rama & Raul Mendoza | def. | Dexter Lumis & Ridge Holland & Rocky | 6-person tag | |
NXT Tampa Show
Oct 17th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Aleksander Jaksic | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Oct 10th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Jeet Rama | | |
NXT Sanford Show
Oct 3rd 2019 | Jeet Rama | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT TV #369
Oct 2nd 2019 | Isaiah "Swerve" Scott | def. | Dexter Lumis | dark
| |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Sep 29th 2019 | Mansoor | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Sep 27th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Rik Bugez | | |
NXT St. Petersburg Show
Sep 26th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Daniel Vidot | | |
NXT Melbourne Show
Sep 21st 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Sep 20th 2019 | Mansoor | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Sep 13th 2019 | Angel Garza | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Aug 29th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Daniel Vidot | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Aug 24th 2019 | Jordan Omogbehin | def. | Angel Garza, Boa, Brendan Vink, Cal Bloom, Chase Parker, Daniel Vidot, Denzel Dejournette, Dexter Lumis, Kona Reeves, Mansoor, Matt Martel, Mohamed Fahim, Nick Ogarelli, Rik Bugez | Battle Royal | |
NXT Largo Show
Aug 3rd 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Nick Ogarelli | | |
NXT Melbourne Show
Aug 2nd 2019 | Danny Burch & Oney Lorcan | def. | Brendan Vink & Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Jul 27th 2019 | Bronson Reed | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Jul 26th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Cezar Bononi | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Jul 19th 2019 | Humberto Carrillo | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Jul 18th 2019 | Tyler Breeze | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Winter Haven Show
Jul 11th 2019 | Rik Bugez | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Venice Show
Jun 29th 2019 | Jeet Rama | def. | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Ocala Show
Jun 14th 2019 | Dexter Lumis | def. | Denzel Dejournette | | |
NXT TV Taping #358 Part 1
Jun 12th 2019 | Bronson Reed | def. (pin) | Dexter Lumis | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Jun 8th 2019 | Danny Burch | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Daytona Beach Show
May 25th 2019 | Brennan Williams | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Bartow Show
May 23rd 2019 | Samuel Shaw | def. | Denzel Dejournette | | |
NXT St. Augustine Show
May 11th 2019 | Jeet Rama | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Sebring Show
May 10th 2019 | Jeet Rama | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Largo Show
May 9th 2019 | Babatunde | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Apr 25th 2019 | Keith Lee | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Apr 18th 2019 | Albert Hardie Jr. | def. (pin) | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Largo Show
Apr 12th 2019 | Nick Comoroto | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NXT Ocala Show
Mar 16th 2019 | Fabian Aichner | def. | Samuel Shaw | | |
NWA Pop Up - New Years Clash
Jan 5th 2019 | Crazzy Steve | def. (pin) | Samuel Shaw (c) | no disqualification | Tried-N-True Title
(title change) |
Dexter Lumis during 2019