| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NEW Autumn Ambush 2021
Nov 20th 2021 | Cole Karter | def. | Brett Ryan Gosselin | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #34 Taping
Oct 23rd 2021 | Paul Wight | def. (pin) | Arjun Singh & Carlie Bravo & Cole Karter | handicap tag | |
IWC Super Indy 20
Oct 16th 2021 | Cole Karter | def. | Anthony Greene | | IWC Super Indy Championship
(title change) |
IWC Super Indy 20
Oct 16th 2021 | Cole Karter | def. (CO) | Alexander Hammerstone | | |
IWC Super Indy 20
Oct 16th 2021 | Cole Karter | def. | Matt Cross | | |
NEW Better Than You
Oct 2nd 2021 | Cole Karter | def. | J. Heru | | |
AEW Dark #109 Taping
Sep 11th 2021 | Aaron Solo & Nick Comoroto & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Cole Karter & Darian Bengston & Sean Maluta | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark #103 Taping
Aug 13th 2021 | PAC & Penta El Zero Miedo & Rey Fenix | def. | Cole Karter & Luther & Serpentico | 6-person tag | |
AAW Alive #20 Taping
Aug 7th 2021 | Axel Rico & Rico De La Vega | def. | Cole Karter & Jake Omen | | |
NEW Wrestling Under the Stars 2021
Jul 10th 2021 | Wrecking Ball Legursky | def. | Cole Karter | | |
IWC/NEW Superstar Showdown
Jul 9th 2021 | Wrecking Ball Legursky | def. | Cole Karter | | |
AAW Alive #13 Taping
Jun 11th 2021 | Mike Hartenbower | def. | Cole Karter | | |
IWA-MS Revenge Best Served Cold
Jun 10th 2021 | Piper & Prima Donny | def. | Cole Karter & Jayce Karr | | |
IWA-MS You Ain't Seen Crazy Yet
Jun 3rd 2021 | Dale Patricks & Kevin Giza | def. | Cole Karter & Jayce Karr, Corey Storm & Daniel Luck | three-way tag | |
AEW Dark #88 Taping
May 5th 2021 | Alan "5" Angels & Colt Cabana & Evil Uno | def. (pin) | Andrew Palace & Cole Karter & Spencer Slade | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark #86 Taping
Apr 21st 2021 | Colt Cabana | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dark #85 Taping
Apr 14th 2021 | The Blade & The Butcher | def. (pin) | Brick Aldridge & Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dynamite #80
Apr 14th 2021 | Anthony Ogogo | def. | Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dark #84 Taping
Apr 7th 2021 | Lance Archer | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #5 Taping
Apr 7th 2021 | Nick Comoroto & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Andrew Palace & Cole Karter | | |
AAW Alive #4
Apr 3rd 2021 | Hakim Zane | def. | Cole Karter | | |
IWA-MS Headed for a Heartbreak 2021
Feb 5th 2021 | Cole Karter | def. | Anakin Murphy, Billy Tipton, Corey Storm, Crash Jaxon, Jayce Karr, Un4seen Perez | Ladder (7-way) | |
IWA-MS Opportunity Knocks
Feb 4th 2021 | The Zodiak | def. | Aaron Williams, Anakin Murphy, Billy Tipton, Blake Steel, Cole Karter, Corey Storm, Crash Jaxon, Daniel Luck, Dewey Wellington, Gaston LaRue, Gnarls Garvin, Hunter Drake, J. C. Rotten, Jayce Karr, Kenzie Paige, Larry D, Pompano Joe, Snoop Strikes, Tony Evans | Battle Royal | |
Cole Karter during 2021