| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Honor Club TV #59 Taping - Part 4
Apr 10th 2024 | Christopher Daniels | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
ROH Supercard of Honor 2024
Apr 5th 2024 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. (pin) | Angélico & Serpentico | pre-show
| |
 ROH Honor Club TV #57 Taping - Part 2
Mar 16th 2024 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. (pin) | Kaz Jordan & Victor Castella | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #55 Taping
Mar 7th 2024 | Orange Cassidy & Trent Beretta | def. (pin) | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #50 Taping - Part 2
Feb 3rd 2024 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison & Lee Moriarty & Shane Taylor | def. (pin) | Boulder & Bronson & Carlie Bravo & Shawn Dean | 8-person tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #48 Taping
Jan 20th 2024 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. (pin) | Angélico & Serpentico | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #46 Taping
Jan 6th 2024 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Serpentico | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #43 Taping
Dec 16th 2023 | Brandon Tate & Brent Tate & Dalton Castle & Gravity | def. (pin) | Angélico & Cole Karter & Griff Garrison & Serpentico | 8-person tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #42 Taping - Part 1
Dec 5th 2023 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. (pin) | Bobby Sharp & Shaun Moore | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #40 Taping
Nov 22nd 2023 | Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal | def. | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | dark
| |
ROH Honor Club TV #37 Taping
Nov 4th 2023 | Boulder & Bronson | def. | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #36 Taping
Oct 28th 2023 | Brandon Tate & Brent Tate & Dalton Castle & Gravity | def. (pin) | Griff Garrison & J. D. Drake & Anthony Henry & Cole Karter | 8-person tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #35 Taping
Oct 21st 2023 | Bishop Kaun & Toa Liona | def. (pin) | Boulder & Bronson, Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | three-way tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #34 Taping
Oct 14th 2023 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. | Myron Reed & Ren Jones | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #32 Taping
Sep 30th 2023 | Lee Moriarty & Shane Taylor | def. | Anthony Henry & J. D. Drake, Boulder & Bronson, Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | four-way tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #31 Taping
Sep 23rd 2023 | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | def. (pin) | Carlie Bravo & Shawn Dean | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #30 Taping
Sep 16th 2023 | Action Andretti & Darius Martin | def. | Cole Karter & Griff Garrison | | |
Nightmare Factory Student Showcase #10 (airdate)
Aug 22nd 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Elijah Drago | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #27 Taping - Part 2
Aug 19th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Dustin Jackson | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #25 Taping - Part 2
Aug 12th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Griff Garrison | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #24 Taping
Aug 5th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Rhett Titus | | |
NEW Wrestling Under The Stars 2023
Jul 30th 2023 | Brian Pillman Jr. | def. | Cole Karter | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #23 Taping
Jul 29th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | LSG | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #13 Taping
May 7th 2023 | Action Andretti & Darius Martin | def. (pin) | Cole Karter & Zack Clayton | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #12 Taping - Part 1
May 6th 2023 | Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal | def. | Cole Karter & Zack Clayton | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #8 Taping
Apr 12th 2023 | Alex Reynolds & John Silver | def. (pin) | Cole Karter & Lee Johnson | | |
AEW Dark #192 Taping
Mar 24th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Hunter James | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #105 Taping
Mar 1st 2023 | Christopher Daniels | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dark #189 Taping - Part 1
Feb 26th 2023 | Konosuke Takeshita | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
NEW The Future Is Now 2023
Feb 18th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. (pin) | Wrecking Ball Legursky | | |
Nightmare Factory Student Showcase #8 (airdate)
Jan 24th 2023 | John Schearly | def. | Cole Karter, Corey Calhoun, Devin Sullivan, Dylan Davis, HJZ, Kayjay Impala, Levi Night, Matt Serpiente, Matthew Mercer, Michael Solar, Mike Vandal, Tom Marciano, Trevor Terry | Rumble | |
Battle Slam Dream
Jan 15th 2023 | Shoot Taylor | def. | Cole Karter | | |
NEW Over The Top 2023
Jan 14th 2023 | Kerr | def. | Alec Price, Antonio Zambrano, Brett Ryan Gosselin, Channing Thomas, Charlie Gryver, Chris Battle, Cole Karter, Dutch, Encore Moore, Flip Gordon, Greg Baylor, J. Heru, J. T. Dunn, Jay Blade, Jaylen Brandyn, JCruz, Jordan Oliver, K. C. Navarro, Lorenzo Vendetta, Love, Doug, Lucas Chase, R. J. Rude, Rex Lawless, Ryan Clancy, Vargas, Victor Chase, Willow Nightingale, Wrecking Ball Legursky, Zane Bernardo | Rumble | |
NEW Over The Top 2023
Jan 14th 2023 | Cole Karter | def. | Vinny Pacifico | | |
AEW Dynamite #167 - Winter Is Coming 2022
Dec 14th 2022 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Aaron Solo & Cole Karter & Q. T. Marshall | 6-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #69 Taping
Nov 30th 2022 | Darby Allin | def. (pin) | Cole Karter | | |
AEW Full Gear 2022
Nov 19th 2022 | Chuck Taylor & Danhausen & Orange Cassidy & Rocky Romero & Trent Beretta | def. (pin) | Aaron Solo & Cole Karter & Lee Johnson & Nick Comoroto & Q. T. Marshall | 10-person tag | |
AEW Dark #172 Taping
Nov 18th 2022 | Cole Karter & Lee Johnson & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Justin Corino & Ryan Mooney & Steven Josifi | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #90 Taping
Nov 16th 2022 | Chuck Taylor & Orange Cassidy & Trent Beretta | def. (pin) | Aaron Solo & Cole Karter & Lee Johnson | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark #174 Taping
Nov 4th 2022 | Cole Karter & Lee Johnson & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Chris Steeler & Joe Keys & LSG | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #88 Taping
Nov 2nd 2022 | Cole Karter & Lee Johnson & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Cheeseburger & Logan Easton LaRoux & Rhett Titus | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark #170 Taping
Oct 28th 2022 | Cole Karter & Lee Johnson & Q. T. Marshall | def. (pin) | Channing Thomas & Man Scout & Teddy Goodz | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark #169 Taping
Oct 21st 2022 | Cole Karter & Q. T. Marshall | def. | Brian Pillman Jr. & Griff Garrison | | |
NEW The Show With No Name
Oct 15th 2022 | Cole Karter | def. (ref) | Kylon King | | |
IWC Super Indy 21
Oct 8th 2022 | Cole Karter | def. | Derek Dillinger | | IWC Super Indy Championship
(title change) |
IWC Super Indy 21
Oct 8th 2022 | Cole Karter | def. | Dak Draper | | |
IWC Super Indy 21
Oct 8th 2022 | Cole Karter | def. | Brian Pillman Jr. | | |
AEW Dark #165 Taping
Oct 7th 2022 | Dante Martin & Matt Sydal | def. (pin) | Aaron Solo & Cole Karter | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #83 Taping
Sep 28th 2022 | Chuck Taylor & Danhausen & Rocky Romero & Trent Beretta | def. (pin) | Aaron Solo & Cole Karter & Nick Comoroto & Q. T. Marshall | 8-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #59 - Grand Slam Taping
Sep 21st 2022 | Adam Page | def. | 10, Alex Reynolds, Ari Daivari, Brandon, Brent, Brian Cage, Chuck Taylor, Cole Karter, Dalton Castle, Danhausen, Daniel Garcia, Dante Martin, Evil Uno, Isiah Kassidy, Jake Hager, Jay Lethal, John Silver, Lance Archer, Lee Moriarty, Marq Quen, Matt Hardy, Penta El Zero Miedo, Rush, The Blade, The Butcher, Trent Beretta, W. Morrissey | battle royale | |
Cole Karter