| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Honor Club TV Taping
Apr 17th 2024 | Anna Jay | def. | Allysin Kay | | |
AEW Dynamite #236
Apr 10th 2024 | Mariah May | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #59 Taping - Part 3
Apr 3rd 2024 | Anna Jay | def. (pin) | LMK | | |
 AEW Dynamite #234
Mar 27th 2024 | Willow Nightingale | def. (pin) | Anna Jay, Kris Statlander, Skye Blue | four-way | |
ROH Honor Club TV #58 Taping - Part 1
Mar 20th 2024 | Anna Jay | def. (pin) | Nikita | | |
ROH Honor Club TV #56 Taping - Part 1
Mar 13th 2024 | Mina Shirakawa | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Rampage #133 Taping
Feb 21st 2024 | Mariah May | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Rampage #132 Taping
Feb 14th 2024 | Queen Aminata | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Rampage #129 Taping
Jan 24th 2024 | Anna Jay | def. | Ruby Soho | | |
AEW Dynamite #224
Jan 17th 2024 | Deonna Purrazzo | def. (sub) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Battle of the Belts IX
Jan 13th 2024 | Julia Hart (c) | def. (sub) | Anna Jay | | AEW TBS Championship
|
AEW Dynamite #223 - Homecoming
Jan 10th 2024 | Anna Jay & Kris Statlander & Thunder Rosa & Willow Nightingale | def. (sub) | Julia Hart & Ruby Soho & Saraya & Skye Blue | 8-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #126 Taping
Jan 3rd 2024 | Hikaru Shida | def. | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Rampage #123 - Winter Is Coming 2023 Taping
Dec 13th 2023 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Red Velvet | | |
AEW Rampage #121 Taping
Nov 29th 2023 | Hikaru Shida & Kris Statlander & Skye Blue | def. (pin) | Anna Jay & Ruby Soho & Saraya | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #216 - Thanksgiving Eve 2023
Nov 22nd 2023 | Skye Blue | def. (pin) | Anna Jay, Ruby Soho | three-way | |
AEW Dynamite #215
Nov 15th 2023 | Anna Jay | def. | Vipress | dark
| |
AEW Rampage #116 Taping
Oct 25th 2023 | Abadon | def. (pin) | Anna Jay, Skye Blue, Willow Nightingale | four-way | |
AEW Rampage #111 - Grand Slam 2023 Taping
Sep 20th 2023 | Hook & Kris Statlander & Orange Cassidy | def. (pin) | Angelo Parker & Anna Jay & Matt Menard | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #206
Sep 13th 2023 | Anna Jay & Taya Valkyrie | def. | Arie Alexander & Shawna Reed | dark
| |
AEW Rampage #109 Taping
Sep 6th 2023 | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Hikaru Shida & Skye Blue | def. (sub) | Anna Jay & Taya Valkyrie & The Bunny | 6-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #108 Taping
Aug 30th 2023 | Skye Blue & Willow Nightingale | def. (pin) | Anna Jay & Taya Valkyrie | | |
AEW Dynamite #201
Aug 9th 2023 | Hikaru Shida (c) | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | AEW Women's Championship
|
AEW Rampage #104 Taping - Part 1
Aug 2nd 2023 | Anna Jay | def. | Skye Blue | | |
AEW Dynamite #199
Jul 26th 2023 | Skye Blue | def. | Anna Jay | dark
| |
AEW Rampage #98 Taping
Jun 21st 2023 | Skye Blue | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Dynamite #192
Jun 7th 2023 | Kris Statlander (c) | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. | | AEW TBS Championship
|
AEW House Rules
Jun 3rd 2023 | Toni Storm (c) | def. | Anna Jay A.S., Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D., Skye Blue | four-way | AEW Women's Championship
|
AEW House Rules
Jun 2nd 2023 | Kris Statlander | def. | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Dynamite #188
May 10th 2023 | Julia Hart | def. (sub) | Anna Jay | no holds barred | |
AEW Rampage #90 Taping
Apr 26th 2023 | Anna Jay A.S. | def. (sub) | Ashley D'Amboise | | |
AEW Rampage #87
Apr 7th 2023 | Julia Hart | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW House Rules
Mar 18th 2023 | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. | def. | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Rampage #75 Taping
Jan 11th 2023 | Ruby Soho & Willow Nightingale | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. & Tay Melo | street fight (tag) | |
AEW Dark #178 Taping
Jan 6th 2023 | Anna Jay A.S. & Tay Melo | def. (sub) | Kel & Teal Piper | | |
AEW Dynamite #169 - New Year's Smash
Dec 28th 2022 | Anna Jay & Tay Melo | def. (pin) | Ruby Soho & Willow Nightingale | | |
AEW Dynamite #165
Nov 30th 2022 | Willow Nightingale | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Dynamite #164 - Thanksgiving Eve
Nov 23rd 2022 | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Jamie Hayter | def. (pin) | Anna Jay & Tay Melo, Skye Blue & Willow Nightingale | three-way tag | |
AEW Dynamite #163
Nov 16th 2022 | Toni Storm | def. (sub) | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Dark #169 Taping
Oct 21st 2022 | Anna Jay A.S. | def. (sub) | Sio Nieves | | |
AEW Rampage #62 Taping
Oct 13th 2022 | Nyla Rose | def. (pin) | Anna Jay A.S. | | |
AEW Rampage #61
Oct 7th 2022 | Anna Jay A.S. & Tay Melo | def. (sub) | Madison Rayne & Skye Blue | | |
AEW Dark #163 Taping
Aug 21st 2022 | Anna Jay A.S. | def. (sub) | Kelly Madan | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #77 Taping
Aug 17th 2022 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Nikki Victory | | |
AEW Dark #156 Taping
Aug 5th 2022 | Anna Jay A.S. | def. (sub) | Megan Meyers | | |
AEW Rampage #51 - Fight For the Fallen 2022 Taping
Jul 27th 2022 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Ruby Soho | | |
AEW Dynamite #145 - Fyter Fest 2022 - Week 1
Jul 13th 2022 | Serena Deeb | def. (sub) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #71 Taping
Jul 6th 2022 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Shawna Reed | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #70 Taping
Jun 29th 2022 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Megan Meyers | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #69 Taping
Jun 22nd 2022 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Heather Reckless | | |
Anna Jay