| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH HDNet taping No. 10
Aug 15th 2009 | Austin Aries (c) | def. | Alex Payne | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH HDNet taping No. 11
Sep 10th 2009 | Rhett Titus | def. | Alex Payne | | |
ROH Final Countdown Tour: Dayton
Sep 18th 2009 | Sal Rinauro | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| |
ROH Final Countdown Tour: Chicago
Sep 19th 2009 | Rasche Brown | def. | Alex Payne, Grizzly Redwood, Kyle O'Reilly, Sal Rinauro, Silas Young | "Six Man Mayhem" | |
ROH Final Countdown Tour: Boston
Sep 25th 2009 | Jon Davis & Kory Chavis | def. | Alex Payne & Bobby Dempsey | | |
ROH Clash Of The Contenders
Oct 8th 2009 | Alex Payne & Bobby Dempsey & Mike Sydal | def. | Aaron Scott & Muscle Machine & Shawn Schultz | dark
6-person tag | |
ROH Survival of the Fittest '09
Oct 10th 2009 | Muscle Gang | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| |
ROH HDNet taping No. 13
Nov 5th 2009 | Alex Payne | def. | Tony Nees | dark
| |
ROH HDNet taping No. 14
Nov 6th 2009 | Kevin Steen | def. | Alex Payne | | |
 ROH The Omega Effect
Nov 14th 2009 | Alex Payne & Bobby Dempsey | def. | Ethan Page & Michael Von Payton | dark
| |
ROH Reverse the Curse
Dec 5th 2009 | Grizzly Redwood & Pelle Primeau | def. | Alex Payne & Bobby Dempsey | dark
| |
ROH Eye of the Storm 2
Dec 18th 2009 | Pelle Primeau | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| |
ROH Final Battle '09
Dec 19th 2009 | Andy Ridge | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| |
CZW Maven Bentley Association Show: The Santa Claus Smackdown
Dec 26th 2009 | Alex Colon | def. | Alex Payne, Anthony Graves, J. T. Roberts | four-way | |
ROH HDNet taping No. 15
Jan 8th 2010 | Kevin Steen & Steve Corino | def. | Alex Payne & Bobby Dempsey | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect Inaugural Show
Jan 24th 2010 | Christian Merino & Rob Wolf & Shane Hagadorn | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Jacob Chamber & Professor Milo Shizo | 6-person tag | |
Pro Wrestling Respect Delirious vs. Ridge
Mar 14th 2010 | Orange Cassidy & Shane Hagadorn | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Mike Sydal | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect #3
Jun 6th 2010 | Shane Hagadorn | def. (KO) | Alex Payne | | |
 NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 2
Jun 27th 2010 | Akira Taue & Mohammed Yone | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Naomichi Marufuji | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 3
Jun 29th 2010 | Kento Miyahara | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 4
Jul 2nd 2010 | Atsushi Aoki | def. (sub) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 5
Jul 3rd 2010 | Kentaro Shiga | def. | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 6
Jul 4th 2010 | Akitoshi Saito | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 7
Jul 6th 2010 | Yoshinobu Kanemaru | def. (sub) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 1 - Day 8
Jul 7th 2010 | Katsuhiko Nakajima | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 1
Jul 14th 2010 | Go Shiozaki & Takashi Okita & Takeshi Morishima | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & KENTA & Mohammed Yone | 6-person tag | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 2
Jul 16th 2010 | KENTA | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 3
Jul 17th 2010 | Yoshihiro Takayama | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 4
Jul 19th 2010 | Taiji Ishimori | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 5
Jul 20th 2010 | Ricky Marvin | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
NOAH 10th Anniversary: Summer Navigation '10 Part 2 - Day 6
Jul 21st 2010 | Akira Taue & Yoshinari Ogawa | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Genba Hirayanagi | | |
NOAH 10 Years After - Day 2
Aug 5th 2010 | Genba Hirayanagi | def. (pin) | Alex Payne | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect #6
Feb 2nd 2011 | Alex Payne & Shane Hagadorn | def. (sub) | Andy Ridge & Pelle Primeau | | |
F1/wXw F1 vs. wXw
Apr 8th 2011 | Alex Payne (c) & Pelle Primeau (c) | def. | Bad Bones & Johnny Moss | | F1 Tag Team Titles
|
CZW Down With The Sickness '11 - Chri$ Ca$h Memorial Show
Sep 10th 2011 | The Latin Dragon | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| |
CZW Night of Infamy 10: Ultimatum
Nov 12th 2011 | Alex Colon & Rich Swann & Ruckus | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Joe Gacy & Ryan Slater | 6-person tag | |
CZW Cage of Death XIII
Dec 3rd 2011 | Drew Gulak | def. (pin) | Alex Payne, Derek Frazier, Dustin Rayz, Ryan McBride, tHURTeen | "Scramble" | |
CZW Dojo Wars 41
Aug 19th 2015 | Nate Carter | def. | Alex Payne | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 45
Sep 16th 2015 | Alex Payne | def. | Tjay Sykes | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 61
Feb 10th 2016 | Alex Payne | def. | Swift Kick | | |
Alex Payne