| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Pro Wrestling Respect #6
Feb 2nd 2011 | Alex Payne & Shane Hagadorn | def. (sub) | Andy Ridge & Pelle Primeau | | |
ROH Final Battle '10
Dec 18th 2010 | Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe & Mike Briscoe | def. (pin) | Chris Hero & Claudio Castagnoli & Shane Hagadorn | 6-person tag | |
Pro Wrestling Respect #5
Aug 22nd 2010 | Colby Godwin | def. (DQ) | Shane Hagadorn | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect #4
Jul 18th 2010 | Shane Hagadorn | def. (sub) | Lance Bravado | Intergender Match | |
Pro Wrestling Respect #3
Jun 6th 2010 | Shane Hagadorn | def. (KO) | Alex Payne | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect Delirious vs. Ridge
Mar 14th 2010 | Orange Cassidy & Shane Hagadorn | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Mike Sydal | | |
Pro Wrestling Respect Inaugural Show
Jan 24th 2010 | Christian Merino & Rob Wolf & Shane Hagadorn | def. (pin) | Alex Payne & Jacob Chamber & Professor Milo Shizo | 6-person tag | |
ROH Night Of The Butcher II
Aug 16th 2008 | Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn | Sweet n' Sour Inc. Gauntlet | |
ROH Fueling The Fire
Aug 1st 2008 | Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | def. | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH New Horizons
Jul 26th 2008 | Erick Stevens | def. (pin) | Delirious, Ruckus, Shane Hagadorn | four corners survival | |
ROH Battle For Supremacy
Jun 27th 2008 | Shane Hagadorn & Tank Toland | def. | Mitch Franklin & Silas Young | | |
ROH Respect Is Earned II
Jun 7th 2008 | Mitch Franklin & Shane Hagadorn | def. | Amasis & Ophidian | dark
| |
ROH Up For Grabs
Jun 6th 2008 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Alex Payne | | |
FIP Unfinished Business '08
Mar 22nd 2008 | Erick Stevens | def. | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Take No Prisoners
Mar 16th 2008 | Bushwhacker Luke | def. | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Double Feature Part II
Mar 15th 2008 | Jigsaw & Ruckus | def. | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '08: Night 1
Feb 29th 2008 | Chiva II & Chiva III & Chiva IV | def. | Alex Payne & Rhett Titus & Shane Hagadorn | 6-person tag | |
ROH Without Remorse
Jan 26th 2008 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Pelle Primeau | | |
ROH Transform
Jan 12th 2008 | B.J. Whitmer & Shane Hagadorn | def. | Bobby Fish & Eddie Edwards | | |
ROH Unscripted III
Dec 1st 2007 | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | def. | Ernie Osiris & Mitch Franklin | | |
ROH Glory By Honor VI - Night 2
Nov 3rd 2007 | Austin Aries | def. | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Glory By Honor VI - Night 1
Nov 2nd 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Rhett Titus | dark
| |
ROH Survival Of The Fittest 2007
Oct 19th 2007 | Human Tornado | def. | Shane Hagadorn, Tony Kozina | triple-threat | |
ROH Motor City Madness 2007
Sep 14th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Kyle Durden | dark
| |
ROH Death Before Dishonor V - Night 2
Aug 11th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Alex Payne, Eddie Kingston, Rhett Titus | dark
four-way | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor V - Night 1
Aug 10th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Alex Payne, Bobby Dempsey, Ernie Osiris, Mitch Franklin, Rhett Titus | dark
6-Way | |
ROH Race To The Top Tournament - Night 2
Jul 28th 2007 | Ernie Osiris & Gran Akuma & Mitch Franklin | def. | Alex Payne & Rhett Titus & Shane Hagadorn | dark
6-person tag | |
ROH Race To The Top Tournament - Night 1
Jul 27th 2007 | Alex Payne & Shane Hagadorn | def. | Ernie Osiris & Mitch Franklin | dark
| |
ROH Reborn Again
May 11th 2007 | Bryan Danielson | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Fighting Spirit
Apr 14th 2007 | Pelle Primeau | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn (c) | | ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
(title change) |
ROH Fifth Year Festival: Chicago
Feb 24th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Mitch Franklin | dark
| |
ROH Fifth Year Festival: Philly
Feb 17th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. | Alex Payne | dark
| ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
ROH Battle Of The Icons
Jan 27th 2007 | Shane Hagadorn | def. | Michael Elgin | dark
| |
ROH Dedicated
Jan 26th 2007 | Delirious & Pelle Primeau | def. (pin) | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | | |
FIP Unfinished Business '07
Jan 13th 2007 | Joey Machete & Shawn Murphy | def. | Shane Hagadorn & Shingo, Chasyn Rance & Kenny King | three-way dance tag | |
FIP New Year's Classic '07
Jan 12th 2007 | Claudio Castagnoli | def. | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH The Chicago Spectacular - Night 2
Dec 9th 2006 | Homicide | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH The Chicago Spectacular - Night 1
Dec 8th 2006 | Ace Steel & Delirious | def. (pin) | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Dethroned
Nov 25th 2006 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. (pin) | Bobby Dempsey | | ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
ROH Black Friday Fallout
Nov 24th 2006 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. | Rhett Titus | dark
| ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
CHIKARA Talent Borrows, Genius Steals
Nov 18th 2006 | Fire Ant & Soldier Ant & Worker Ant | def. | Pelle Primeau & Rhett Titus & Shane Hagadorn | 6-person tag | |
FIP Evening the Odds '06
Nov 11th 2006 | Erick Stevens & Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe & Pelle Primeau & Roderick Strong | def. | Bryan Danielson & Davey Richards & Shane Hagadorn & Shingo & Steve Madison | 10-man tag elimination | |
FIP All or Nothing
Nov 10th 2006 | The Canadian Cougar | def. | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH The Bitter End
Nov 4th 2006 | Ricky Reyes | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Honor Reclaims Boston
Nov 3rd 2006 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. | Pelle Primeau | dark
| ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
ROH Irresistible Forces
Oct 28th 2006 | Adam Pearce & Shane Hagadorn | def. (pin) | David Crist & Jake Crist | | |
ROH Motor City Madness
Oct 7th 2006 | Pelle Primeau | def. (pin) | David Crist, Jake Crist, Jimmy Rave, Matt Cross, Shane Hagadorn | "Six Man Mayhem" | |
ROH Survival of the Fittest 2006
Oct 6th 2006 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. | Pelle Primeau | dark
| ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
ROH Glory By Honor V - Night 1
Sep 15th 2006 | Delirious | def. (pin) | Shane Hagadorn | | |
ROH Gut Check
Aug 26th 2006 | Shane Hagadorn (c) | def. | Pelle Primeau | dark
| ROH Top Of The Class Trophy
|
Shane Hagadorn