Carmella

Introduction
Below you can see all known star ratings for wrestling matches featuring in Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Please note that ratings are given to the overall match; not to the performers within them. Therefore, high or low ratings may reflect aspects of the match including booking, length and performance of partners/opponents, over which the performers may have little or no control. Please also note that a match that received a particular rating many years ago may have been judged on a different criteria from today's.

Following the same rating system devised in part by Jim Cornette, matches are rated from the lowest rating of -***** (-5) through to the highest rating of ***** (+5), with a small number of matches being rated above that theoretical maximum. Matches with a rating of zero stars are referred to as a "DUD" and an average match tends to score around a ** (2) rating. All ratings can only be considered subjective and this page is designed purely for reference purposes.

Carmella

Promotion Search: All • WWE
Year Search: All • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017 • 2018 • 2019 • 2020 • 2021 • 2022
Matches Shown: 1 to 37 of 37 (first • prev • next • last) ... Results per page: 10 • 25 • 50 • 100 • 250 • All ... Sort: newest first • oldest first ... Title Matches: Click to View

NXT Women's Title WWE 24/7 Title WWE Raw Women's Title WWE Smackdown Women's Title WWE Smackdown Womens Championship

WWE Womens Tag Team Championship

card/ date	match			match type	title(s)	Rating
WWE Elimination Chamber 2023 Feb 18th 2023	Asuka	def. (sub)	Carmella, Liv Morgan, Natalya, Nikki Cross, Raquel Rodriguez	"Elimination Chamber"		**** (4.00)
WWE Money In The Bank 2022 Jul 2nd 2022	Bianca BelAir (c)	def. (pin)	Carmella		WWE Raw Women's Title	** (2.00)
WWE WrestleMania 38 - Night 2 Apr 3rd 2022	Naomi & Sasha Banks	def. (pin)	Carmella (c) & Queen Zelina (c), Liv Morgan & Rhea Ripley, Natalya & Shayna Baszler	fatal 4-way tag	WWE Womens Tag Team Championship (title change)	**½ (2.5)
WWE Royal Rumble 2022 Jan 29th 2022	Ronda Rousey	def.	Alicia Fox, Aliyah, Bianca BelAir, Brie Bella, Cameron, Carmella, Charlotte Flair, Dana Brooke, Ivory, Kelly Kelly, Lita, Liv Morgan, Melina, Michelle McCool, Mickie James, Molly Holly, Naomi, Natalya, Nikki A.S.H., Nikki Bella, Queen Zelina, Rhea Ripley, Sarah Logan, Sasha Banks, Shayna Baszler, Shotzi, Sonya Deville, Summer Rae, Tamina	30-woman Royal Rumble		**¼ (2.25)
WWE Survivor Series 2021 Nov 21st 2021	Bianca BelAir & Carmella & Liv Morgan & Queen Zelina & Rhea Ripley	def. (pin)	Natalya & Sasha Banks & Shayna Baszler & Shotzi & Toni Storm	"Survivor Series"		**½ (2.5)
WWE Extreme Rules 2021 Sep 26th 2021	Liv Morgan	def. (pin)	Carmella			**¼ (2.25)
WWE WrestleMania 37 - Night 1 Apr 10th 2021	Liv Morgan & Ruby Riott	def. (pin)	Billie Kay & Carmella	tag team turmoil		½* (0.5)
WWE WrestleMania 37 - Night 1 Apr 10th 2021	Billie Kay & Carmella	def. (pin)	Lana & Naomi	tag team turmoil		¾* (0.75)
WWE Royal Rumble 2021 Jan 31st 2021	Bianca BelAir	def.	Alexa Bliss, Alicia Fox, Bayley, Billie Kay, Carmella, Charlotte Flair, Dakota Kai, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Jillian Hall, Lacey Evans, Lana, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Mickie James, Naomi, Natalya, Nia Jax, Nikki Cross, Peyton Royce, Rhea Ripley, Ruby Riott, Santana Garrett, Shayna Baszler, Shotzi Blackheart, Tamina, Toni Storm, Torrie Wilson, Victoria	30-woman Royal Rumble		***¾ (3.75)
WWE Royal Rumble 2021 Jan 31st 2021	Sasha Banks (c)	def. (sub)	Carmella		WWE Smackdown Women's Title	**¾ (2.75)
WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders, and Chairs 2020 Dec 20th 2020	Sasha Banks (c)	def. (sub)	Carmella		WWE Smackdown Women's Title	***¾ (3.75)
WWE Royal Rumble '20 Jan 26th 2020	Charlotte Flair	def.	Alexa Bliss, Beth Phoenix, Bianca BelAir, Candice LeRae, Carmella, Chelsea Green, Dakota Kai, Dana Brooke, Kairi Sane, Kelly Kelly, Lana, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Mercedes Martinez, Mia Yim, Mighty Molly, Naomi, Natalya, Nikki Cross, Santina, Sarah Logan, Shayna Baszler, Shotzi Blackheart, Sonya Deville, Tamina, Tegan Nox, Toni Storm, Xia Li, Zelina Vega	30-woman Royal Rumble		***½ (3.5)
WWE Survivor Series 2019 Nov 24th 2019	Bianca BelAir & Candice LeRae & Io Shirai & Rhea Ripley & Toni Storm	def. (pin)	Asuka & Charlotte Flair & Kairi Sane & Natalya & Sarah Logan, Carmella & Dana Brooke & Lacey Evans & Nikki Cross & Sasha Banks	"Survivor Series" (5 vs. 5 vs. 5)		**¾ (2.75)
WWE Money in the Bank '19 May 19th 2019	Bayley	def.	Carmella, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Mandy Rose, Naomi, Natalya, Nikki Cross	"Money in the Bank"		***¼ (3.25)
WWE WrestleMania 35 Apr 7th 2019	Carmella	def.	Asuka, Candice LeRae, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Kairi Sane, Lana, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Maria Kanellis, Mickie James, Naomi, Nikki Cross, Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan, Sonya Deville, Zelina Vega	dark ring announcer: Lilian Garcia Battle Royal		**¼ (2.25)
WWE Elimination Chamber '19 Feb 17th 2019	Bayley & Sasha Banks	def. (sub)	Carmella & Naomi, Mandy Rose & Sonya Deville, Nia Jax & Tamina, Billie Kay & Peyton Royce, Liv Morgan & Sarah Logan	commentator: Beth Phoenix Elimination Chamber (tag)	WWE Womens Tag Team Championship (title change)	***½ (3.5)
WWE Royal Rumble '19 Jan 27th 2019	Becky Lynch	def.	Alexa Bliss, Alicia Fox, Bayley, Billie Kay, Candice LeRae, Carmella, Charlotte Flair, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Io Shirai, Kacy Catanzaro, Kairi Sane, Lacey Evans, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Maria Kanellis, Mickie James, Naomi, Natalya, Nia Jax, Nikki Cross, Peyton Royce, Rhea Ripley, Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan, Sonya Deville, Tamina, Xia Li, Zelina Vega	30-woman Royal Rumble		***¼ (3.25)
WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs '18 Dec 16th 2018	Carmella & R-Truth	def. (sub)	Alicia Fox & Jinder Mahal			*½ (1.5)
WWE Survivor Series '18 Nov 18th 2018	Bayley & Mickie James & Nia Jax & Sasha Banks & Tamina	def. (pin)	Asuka & Carmella & Mandy Rose & Naomi & Sonya Deville	"Survivor Series"		**¾ (2.75)
WWE Evolution Oct 28th 2018	Nia Jax	def.	Alundra Blayze, Asuka, Billie Kay, Carmella, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Ivory, Kelly Kelly, Lana, Mandy Rose, Maria Kanellis, Michelle McCool, Molly Holly, Naomi, Peyton Royce, Sonya Deville, Tamina, Torrie Wilson, Zelina Vega	Battle Royal		***¼ (3.25)
WWE SummerSlam '18 Aug 19th 2018	Charlotte Flair	def. (pin)	Becky Lynch, Carmella (c)	triple-threat	WWE Smackdown Women's Title (title change)	***½ (3.5)
WWE Extreme Rules 2018 Jul 15th 2018	Carmella (c)	def. (pin)	Asuka	James Ellsworth in Cage	WWE Smackdown Women's Title	*¼ (1.25)
WWE Money in the Bank ‘18 Jun 17th 2018	Carmella (c)	def. (pin)	Asuka		WWE Smackdown Women's Title	*½ (1.5)
WWE Backlash '18 May 6th 2018	Carmella (c)	def. (pin)	Charlotte Flair		WWE Smackdown Women's Title	* (1.00)
WWE WrestleMania 34 Apr 8th 2018	Naomi	def.	Bayley, Becky Lynch, Bianca BelAir, Carmella, Dakota Kai, Dana Brooke, Kairi Sane, Kavita Devi, Lana, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Mickie James, Natalya, Peyton Royce, Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan, Sasha Banks, Sonya Deville, Taynara Conti	dark commentator: Paige commentator: Beth Phoenix Battle Royal		*½ (1.5)
WWE Fastlane '18 Mar 11th 2018	Carmella & Natalya	def. (pin)	Becky Lynch & Naomi			**¼ (2.25)
WWE Royal Rumble '18 Jan 28th 2018	Asuka	def.	Bayley, Becky Lynch, Beth Phoenix, Brie Bella, Carmella, Dana Brooke, Ember Moon, Jacqueline, Kairi Sane, Kelly Kelly, Lana, Lita, Liv Morgan, Mandy Rose, Michelle McCool, Mickie James, Molly Holly, Naomi, Natalya, Nia Jax, Nikki Bella, Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan, Sasha Banks, Sonya Deville, Tamina, Torrie Wilson, Trish Stratus, Vickie Guerrero	ring announcer: Maria Menounos commentator: Stephanie McMahon 30-woman Royal Rumble		***¼ (3.25)
WWE Survivor Series '17 Nov 19th 2017	Alicia Fox & Asuka & Bayley & Nia Jax & Sasha Banks	def. (sub)	Becky Lynch & Carmella & Naomi & Natalya & Tamina	"Survivor Series"		**½ (2.5)
WWE Money In The Bank '17 Jun 18th 2017	Carmella	def.	Becky Lynch, Charlotte, Natalya, Tamina Snuka	"Money in the Bank"		*** (3.00)
WWE Backlash '17 May 21st 2017	Carmella & Natalya & Tamina	def. (sub)	Becky Lynch & Charlotte Flair & Naomi	6-person tag		** (2.00)
WWE WrestleMania 33 Apr 2nd 2017	Naomi	def. (sub)	Alexa Bliss (c), Becky Lynch, Carmella, Mickie James, Natalya	6-pack challenge	WWE Smackdown Womens Championship (title change)	*½ (1.5)
WWE MSG Show (Mar. '17) - Road To Wrestlemania Mar 12th 2017	Asuka & Becky Lynch & Nikki Bella & Tamina Snuka	def. (sub)	Alexa Bliss & Carmella & Mickie James & Natalya	8-person tag		**¾ (2.75)
WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs '16 Dec 4th 2016	Nikki Bella	def. (pin)	Carmella	no disqualification		** (2.00)
WWE Survivor Series '16 Nov 20th 2016	Alicia Fox & Bayley & Charlotte Flair & Nia Jax & Sasha Banks	def. (pin)	Alexa Bliss & Becky Lynch & Carmella & Naomi & Natalya	"Survivor Series"		**¾ (2.75)
WWE No Mercy '16 Oct 9th 2016	Nikki Bella	def. (pin)	Carmella			*¾ (1.75)
WWE Backlash '16 Sep 11th 2016	Becky Lynch	def. (sub)	Alexa Bliss, Carmella, Naomi, Natalya, Nikki Bella	6-pack challenge	WWE Smackdown Womens Championship (title change)	**¼ (2.25)
WWE SummerSlam '16 Aug 21st 2016	Alexa Bliss & Natalya & Nikki Bella	def. (pin)	Becky Lynch & Carmella & Naomi	6-person tag		** (2.00)

To show more matches, change the "Results per Page" value above.

When using information on this webpage elsewhere, please include a link to either of the following:

• this page (http://www.profightdb.com/wrestler-star-ratings/carmella-10077.html)
• the Internet Wrestling Database homepage (www.profightdb.com)