| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 GCW/DDT GCW Vs. DDT
Mar 31st 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Chris Brookes & Mizuki Watase & Shunma Katsumata | 6-person tag | |
MLW War Chamber 2023
Apr 6th 2023 | AKIRA & Delirious & Doctor Cornwallis & Rickey Shane Page | def. | 1 Called Manders & Alex Hammerstone & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | War Chamber | |
DEFY Vertigo
May 13th 2023 | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Judas Icarus & Travis Williams | | DEFY Tag Team Title
|
Wrestling Revolver And The Ring of Destiny
Jun 17th 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Jon Moxley & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Myron Reed & Rickey Shane Page & Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | 8-person tag | |
DEFY Heathens
Jun 24th 2023 | Gurv Sihra & Harv Sihra | def. | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | street fight (tag) | DEFY Tag Team Title
(title change) |
Wrestling Revolver Cage of Horrors 2
Jul 1st 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Myron Reed & Trey Miguel (c) & Zachary Wentz (c) | "Cage of Horrors" (3 on 3) | PWR Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
MLW Fusion TV Tapings
Jul 8th 2023 | Rickey Shane Page | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
JCW Bloodymania 16: Voltage 2 High!
Jul 8th 2023 | Joshua Bishop | def. | Joey Janela, Matthew Justice, Tom Lawlor | Four-Way Electrified Steel Cage | JCW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
MLW Fusion TV Tapings
Jul 8th 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | def. | Delirious & Doctor Cornwallis, Juicy Finau & Lance Anoa'i | three-way tag | |
Wrestling Revolver Heat Em Up
Aug 3rd 2023 | 1 Called Manders (c) & Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Brent Oakley & K.C. Jacobs & The Pledge | 6-person tag | PWR Tag Team Titles
|
Circle 6 (Sic)est Of The Six
Sep 1st 2023 | Matthew Justice | def. | Atticus Cogar | deathmatch | |
Wrestling Revolver Redacted 4Ever
Sep 2nd 2023 | 1 Called Manders (c) & Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin | 6-person tag | PWR Tag Team Titles
|
MLW Fusion TV Taping
Sep 3rd 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | def. | Cannonball & Talon | tornado tag | |
MLW Fusion TV Taping
Sep 3rd 2023 | AKIRA | draw (NC) | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW The JT Lightning Invitational Tournament 2023 - Day 1
Sep 15th 2023 | Derek Dillinger | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW The JT Lightning Invitational Tournament 2023 - Day 2
Sep 16th 2023 | Isaiah Broner (c) | def. | Matthew Justice | | AIW Intense Championship
|
Wrestling Revolver Redemption 2023
Oct 8th 2023 | Alex Colon & Rickey Shane Page | def. | 1 Called Manders (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | | PWR Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
MLW Slaughterhouse
Oct 14th 2023 | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Cannonball & Talon | "Chamber of Horrors" | |
MLW Fusion TV Tapings
Oct 14th 2023 | AKIRA (c) & Rickey Shane Page (c) | draw (NC) | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | tag team tables | MLW Tag Team Titles
|
Circle 6 Thriller
Oct 15th 2023 | Matthew Justice | def. | Masato Tanaka | no disqualification | |
Circle 6 Thriller
Oct 15th 2023 | Matthew Justice | def. | Vinnie Massaro | | Circle 6 World Title
(title change) |
PCW ULTRA Creature Feature
Oct 28th 2023 | Jacob Fatu (c) & Josef (c) | def. | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | | PCW ULTRA Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Hallowicked 2023
Oct 31st 2023 | Facade | vs. | Matthew Justice | | |
MLW Fightland 2023
Nov 18th 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | def. | AKIRA (c) & Rickey Shane Page (c) | tag team ladder | MLW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
MLW Fusion TV Tapings
Nov 18th 2023 | Josh Bishop | def. | Brett Ryan Gosselin, Good Brother #3, Griffin McCoy, Ichiban, Kevin Blackwood, Love, Doug, Matthew Justice, Mr. Thomas, Nolo Kitano, O'Shay Edwards, T. J. Crawford, Tom Lawlor, Tony Deppen, Yoscifer El | battle royale | |
Circle 6 Highway To Hell
Nov 19th 2023 | Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Krule | "Last Man Standing" | Circle 6 World Title
|
Wrestling Revolver Season Finale 2023
Dec 2nd 2023 | Alex Colon (c) & Rickey Shane Page (c) & Steve Maclin | def. | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | 6-person tag | PWR Tag Team Titles
|
MLW Holiday Rush
Dec 7th 2023 | Josh Bishop | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
Circle 6 King of the Deathmatches 2023
Dec 30th 2023 | Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Homicide | "hardcore" | Circle 6 World Title
|
MLW Kings of Colosseum 2024
Jan 6th 2024 | 1 Called Manders (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Josh Bishop & Tom Lawlor | | MLW Tag Team Titles
|
Wrestling Revolver Mox Vs. Gringo
Jan 25th 2024 | James Drake & Zack Gibson | def. | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice, Alex Colon (c) & Rickey Shane Page (c), Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | four-way tag | PWR Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
MLW Burning Crush Taping
Feb 3rd 2024 | Tom Lawlor | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
MLW Intimidation Games
Feb 29th 2024 | Davey Boy Smith Jr. & Tom Lawlor | def. (pin) | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | | |
Circle 6 EIP - 2 Year Anniversary
Mar 3rd 2024 | Bobby Beverly & Matthew Justice | def. | Jacob Fatu & Journey Fatu | steel cage (2 on 2) | |
Wrestling Revolver Ready Or Not!
Mar 16th 2024 | Alex Colon & Killer Kelly & Rickey Shane Page & Steve Maclin | def. | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Masha Slamovich & Matthew Justice | 8-person tag elimination | |
Wrestling Revolver Grit Your Teeth
Mar 28th 2024 | Gringo Loco (c) | def. | Brayden Lee, Damian Chambers, Fulton, Matthew Justice | 5-way | PWR Remix Title
|
MLW War Chamber 2024 - Day 1
Mar 29th 2024 | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice & Satoshi Kojima & Shigeo Okumura | def. | Davey Boy Smith Jr. & Josh Bishop & Richard Holliday & Tom Lawlor | War Chamber | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 63
May 4th 2024 | Hoodfoot | def. | Matthew Justice | deathmatch | |
MLW Azteca Lucha
May 11th 2024 | Okumura & Satoshi Kojima | def. | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | | MLW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
Matthew Justice