| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CZW Cage of Death XI
Dec 12th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | B-Boy, Eddie Kingston, Egotistico Fantastico | four-way | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 2
Nov 21st 2009 | Silas Young | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 1
Nov 20th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Brad Attitude | | |
CZW Night of Infamy 8
Nov 14th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Nate Hatred & Nick Gage | def. | D. J. Hyde & Drake Younger & Eddie Kingston | 6-person tag elimination | |
CZW Tournament of Death: Rewind
Oct 25th 2009 | Thumbtack Jack | def. (forfeit) | Jon Moxley | four corners dog collar deathmatch | |
CZW Severed Ties
Oct 10th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Nate Hatred & Nick Gage | def. | D. J. Hyde & Scotty Vortekz & XOMGX | Fans Bring the Weapons (3 on 3) | |
CZW Maven Bentley Association Show: Diapers Are Expensive
Oct 8th 2009 | Jon Moxley (c) & Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Adam Cole & Tyler Veritas | | WXW Tag Team Titles
|
 wXw 18+ Underground - The First Stand
Oct 4th 2009 | HATE | def. | Jon Moxley | fans bring the weapons | |
wXw True Colors 2009 - World Tag Team Title Tournament
Oct 3rd 2009 | Jon Moxley (c) & Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Axeman & Bernd Föhr, Big Van Walter & D. J. Hyde, Mark Haskins | four-way elimination tag | |
wXw True Colors 2009 - World Tag Team Title Tournament
Oct 3rd 2009 | Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan | def. | Sha Samuels (c) & Terry Frazier (c) | | wXw World Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
CZW Down With The Sickness Forever '09
Sep 12th 2009 | Jon Moxley | draw (NC) | XOMGX | | |
IWA-MS Kings of the Crimson Mask 2009
Aug 28th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Mickie Knuckles & Sami Callihan | def. | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter & Neil Diamond Cutter | Barbed Wire Boards & Glass Pits Deathmatch (tag) | |
IWA-MS Another Night in Bellevue
Aug 14th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Mason Cutter | | |
IWA-MS Another Night in Bellevue
Aug 14th 2009 | Ryan Phoenix | def. | Ashton Vuitton, Bucky Collins, Coach Havens, Corbin Helms, Dan the Man, Devin Cutter, Egotistico Fantastico, Hammett, Ian Rotten, Jon Moxley, Jonathan Gresham, King Vu, Mason Cutter, Matt Cage, Mickie Knuckles, Neil Diamond Cutter, Rick King, Sal Thomaselli, The Dixieland Destroyer, Tyler Priegel | Battle Royal | |
CZW A Tangled Web 2
Aug 8th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan | def. (pin) | Drake Younger & Scotty Vortekz | "A Tangled Web" tag | |
IWA-MS The Night the Lights Went Out in Bellevue
Jul 25th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Shawn Vincent | | |
CZW Starting Point
Jul 11th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Scotty Vortekz | | |
CZW Who's The F'n Man? - Nick Gage Benefit Show
Jul 11th 2009 | Joe Gacy & Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan | def. | Drew Gulak & Little Mondo & Tyler Veritas | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Ricochet | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Donovan Cain & Marshe Rockett & Ryan Phoenix & Tim Donst | def. | Jason Hades & Jon Moxley & Ricochet & Shane Hollister | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Tim Donst | def. | Donovan Cain & Marshe Rockett | | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Future Stars 2
Jul 10th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Donovan Cain | | |
ROH HDNet taping No. 8
Jun 20th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. | Unknown Male Wrestler | dark
| |
ROH HDNet taping No. 7
Jun 19th 2009 | J-Sin & Lance Lude | def. | Aaron Scott & Jon Moxley | dark
| |
CZW Best of the Best 9
Jun 13th 2009 | D. J. Hyde | def. | Danny Havoc, Jon Moxley, Thumbtack Jack | four-way bring your weapons | |
AIW Absolution 4
Jun 12th 2009 | Flip Kendrick & Louis Lyndon | def. | Amasis & Ophidian, Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan, Frightmare & Klondike Kremlin | four-way tag | |
CZW Tournament of Death VIII
Jun 6th 2009 | Zandig | def. | Brain Damage, D. J. Hyde, Drake Younger, Dysfunction, Jon Moxley, Sami Callihan, Scotty Vortekz, Thumbtack Jack, XOMGX | ultraviolent battle royale | |
CZW Tournament of Death VIII
Jun 6th 2009 | Nick Gage | def. (pin) | Jon Moxley, Scotty Vortekz | fans bring the weapons (three-way) | |
CZW Tournament of Death VIII
Jun 6th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. (pin) | Brain Damage | tables, chairs and silverware death | |
IWA-MS Opportunity
May 22nd 2009 | Drake Younger | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
CZW Blood Pressure: Rising
May 9th 2009 | Brain Damage | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
CZW Eye for an Eye
Apr 11th 2009 | Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan | def. | Brain Damage & Drake Younger | | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2009 - Day 1
Apr 3rd 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Bill the Butcher, Jon Moxley, Keith Walker | four-way | |
AIW All Out War
Mar 26th 2009 | Jason Gory | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
IWA-MS March Massacre 2009
Mar 20th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
CZW Total Havoc
Mar 14th 2009 | Jon Moxley | def. (pin) | Jon Dahmer | | |
IWA-MS February Fury 2009
Feb 6th 2009 | Drake Younger | def. | B-Boy, Devon Moore, Jon Moxley | fatal 4-way | |
Jon Moxley during 2009