| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 EVOLVE #3: Rise or Fall
May 1st 2010 | Johnny Gargano | draw (DCO) | Ricochet | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '10: Night 1
Apr 23rd 2010 | Fire Ant & Green Ant & Soldier Ant | def. (pin) | Flip Kendrick & Johnny Gargano & Louis Lyndon | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Flip Kendrick & Johnny Gargano & Louis Lyndon | def. | Bobby Beverly & Eric Ryan & T. J. Dynamite | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Flip Kendrick & Johnny Gargano & Louis Lyndon | def. | Acid Jaz & Marshe Rockett & Willie Richardson | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Flip Kendrick & Johnny Gargano & Louis Lyndon | def. | Chase Burnett & Davey Vega & Zane Silver | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 1
Apr 9th 2010 | Flip Kendrick & Johnny Gargano & Louis Lyndon | def. | Corvis Fear & Facade & Shiima Xion | 6-person tag | |
EVOLVE #2: Hero vs. Hidaka
Mar 13th 2010 | Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 5
Feb 19th 2010 | Facade, Johnny Gargano, Sterling James Keenan, Tommy Mercer | def. | Ben Fruith, Benny Boone, Bobby Beverly, Chest Flexor, Chris Dickinson, Corey Winters, Dave the Potato, Eric Ryan, Flip Kendrick, Gregory Iron, Hobo Joe, Jack Verville, Jay Ice, Jefferson Saint, John Thorne, Johnny Cockstrong, Jonny Mangue, K-Fed, K. Fernandez, Louis Lyndon, Marion Fontaine, Nick Belushi, Robert Paulson, Southside St. Clair, The Duke | Battle Royal | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 5
Feb 19th 2010 | Sterling James Keenan | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AAW The Chaos Theory 2010
Jan 22nd 2010 | Colt Cabana (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano | | AAW Heritage Title
|
AIW Bring the Ruckus
Jan 21st 2010 | Eric Alverado | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
EVOLVE #1: Richards vs. Ibushi
Jan 16th 2010 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Chris Dickinson | | |
AIW Nightmare Before X-Mas 3: 50th Show Celebration
Dec 19th 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Eric Alverado | | |
Dragon Gate USA Open the Freedom Gate
Nov 28th 2009 | Gran Akuma | def. | Hallowicked, Johnny Gargano, Lince Dorado, Matt Jackson, Nick Jackson | six-way | |
AIW Hell on Earth 5
Nov 27th 2009 | Facade (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano | | AIW Intense Championship
|
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 2
Nov 21st 2009 | Silas Young | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 2
Nov 21st 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Louis Lyndon | | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '09 - Day 1
Nov 20th 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Chris Jones | | |
AIW/Hybrid Double Edge Sword
Sep 17th 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Bryan Danielson | | |
AAW Us vs. Them
Sep 5th 2009 | Shiima Xion | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Honor and Vengeance
Aug 28th 2009 | Facade | def. | Johnny Gargano, Sonjay Dutt | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
Dragon Gate USA Open The Historic Gate
Jul 25th 2009 | Lince Dorado | def. | Aaron Arbo, Andy Harner, Cheech, Chris Jones, Cloudy, Johnny Gargano, Louis Lyndon | dark
8-way elimination | |
AIW Absolution 4
Jun 12th 2009 | Josh Prohibition (c) | def. | Facade, Johnny Gargano | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
|
AIW Zero Hour
May 21st 2009 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Louis Lyndon | | |
AIW Girls' Night Out
May 15th 2009 | Josh Prohibition | def. | Johnny Gargano (c) | | AIW Intense Championship
(title change) |
Johnny Gargano