| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT Detroit Show
Jan 30th 2016 | Elias Samson | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
NXT Pittsburgh Show
Jan 29th 2016 | Sami Zayn | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano | | |
NXT TV Taping #186
Jan 27th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Elias Samson | | |
EVOLVE #55
Jan 24th 2016 | Drew Galloway & Johnny Gargano | def. | Chris Hero & Tommy End | | EVOLVE Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
EVOLVE #54
Jan 23rd 2016 | Drew Galloway & Johnny Gargano | def. (sub) | Harlem Bravado & Lancelot Bravado | | |
EVOLVE #53
Jan 22nd 2016 | Drew Galloway & Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Drew Gulak & T. J. Perkins | | |
NXT TV Taping #180
Jan 22nd 2016 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano | | |
 Smash (Canada)/CZW Smash vs. CZW
Jan 16th 2016 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Sami Callihan | | Smash Wrestling Title
|
F1RST Wrestlepalooza VII
Jan 8th 2016 | Ariya Daivari (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano | referee: Arik Cannon | F1RST Wrestling Wrestlepalooza Title
|
NXT TV Taping #177
Jan 7th 2016 | Samoa Joe | def. (sub) | Johnny Gargano | | |
DREAMWAVE Season Premiere 2016
Jan 2nd 2016 | Christian Rose (c) & Matt Cage (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | | DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
|
2CW #2Sets: The Final Show
Dec 20th 2015 | Eddie Edwards | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Keep the Change, You Filthy Animal
Dec 18th 2015 | Brian Carson & Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham & Johnny Gargano & Joshua Singh & Tommaso Ciampa | def. | Alex Kellar & Candice LeRae & Evan Adams & Frankie Flynn & Kaplan | 10-person tag | |
PWG All-Star Weekend XI - Night 2
Dec 12th 2015 | Brian Cage & Michael Elgin | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | | |
PWG All-Star Weekend XI - Night 1
Dec 11th 2015 | Matt Jackson (c) & Nick Jackson (c) | def. | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | | PWG Tag Team Titles
|
2CW Dead On Arrival
Nov 29th 2015 | Johnny Mundo | def. | Johnny Gargano, Matt Cross | three-way | |
AIW Hell On Earth XI
Nov 27th 2015 | Candice LeRae | def. | Alex Daniels, DJ Z, Johnny Gargano | four-way | |
Smash (Canada) London Calling
Nov 22nd 2015 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Sebastian Suave | | Smash Wrestling Title
|
EVOLVE #52
Nov 7th 2015 | Drew Gulak | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
EVOLVE #51
Nov 6th 2015 | Timothy Thatcher (c) | def. (sub) | Johnny Gargano | | EVOLVE Title
|
EVOLVE #49
Oct 17th 2015 | Johnny Gargano | def. (sub) | Ethan Page | "I Quit" | |
AIW Big Trouble in Little Cleveland
Oct 16th 2015 | Johnny Gargano | def. | The Amazing Red | | |
AAW Jawbreaker 2015
Oct 9th 2015 | Ethan Page (c) | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano | 2 out of 3 falls | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
NXT TV Taping #166
Oct 8th 2015 | Apollo Crews | def. | Baron Corbin, Blake, Bull Dempsey, Colin Cassady, Danny Burch, Dash Wilder, Elias Samson, Enzo Amore, Johnny Gargano, Mojo Rawley, Murphy, Rhyno, Riddick Moss, Samoa Joe, Scott Dawson, Solomon Crowe, Steve Cutler, Tommaso Ciampa, Tye Dillinger, Tyler Breeze, Zack Ryder | Battle Royal | |
NXT TV Taping #168
Oct 8th 2015 | Chad Gable & Jason Jordan | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | | |
Johnny Gargano