| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Smash (Canada) Vampiro's Underground Invasion
May 28th 2017 | Channing Decker & Trent Gibson | def. | Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman | | |
 Impact Wrestling Impact/Xplosion Tapings
Apr 22nd 2017 | KM | def. (pin) | Joe Coleman | | |
Impact Wrestling Impact/Xplosion Tapings
Apr 20th 2017 | Ortiz & Santana | def. | Jake Holmes & Joe Coleman | | |
Smash (Canada) F8ful Eight 2017
Mar 4th 2017 | Russ Myers & T-Money | def. | Joe Coleman & Mike Rollins | | |
OVW TV Taping #909
Jan 18th 2017 | Rocco Bellagio | def. (pin) | Joe Coleman | | OVW Heavyweight Title
|
Smash (Canada) This is Smash 4th Anniversary Tour - Day 2
Nov 12th 2016 | Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | def. | Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman | | |
Smash (Canada) The Legend of Smash
Oct 23rd 2016 | Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | def. | Idris Abraham & Joe Coleman | | |
EVOLVE #71
Oct 16th 2016 | Blaster McMassive & Flex Rumblecrunch | def. (pin) | Eric Locker & Joe Coleman | | |
DWW/GFW Global Showdown
Oct 2nd 2016 | Mike Rollins | def. | Joe Coleman | | |
GFW/MXPW Northern Justice
Oct 1st 2016 | Joe Coleman | def. (pin) | El Tornado | | |
GFW Amped Live
Jul 1st 2016 | Cody Deaner & Colt Cabana & Swoggle | def. | Connor Braxton & Jake Dirden & Joe Coleman | 6-person tag | |
Smash (Canada) Barry's Bay Beatdown
Jun 4th 2016 | Sebastian Suave | def. | Joe Coleman | | |
DWW Justice 2016
Apr 10th 2016 | Joe Coleman | def. | John Atlas | | |
DWW Carnage 2016
Jan 31st 2016 | R. J. City | draw (NC) | Brent Banks, Joe Coleman, Mathieu St. Jacques, Matt Burns, Rude Boy Riley, Scotty O'Shea, Stone Rockwell, Thomas Dubois, Tyler Tirva, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
EVOLVE #53
Jan 22nd 2016 | Jason Cade | def. (pin) | Joe Coleman | | |
DWW Night of Glory
Jul 28th 2015 | P. J. Black | def. | Joe Coleman, R. J. City, Randy Reign, Tyson Dux, Will White | 6-way elimination | DWW Title
(title change) |
DWW Night of Glory
Jul 28th 2015 | Joe Coleman | def. | Cody Deaner | | |
OVW/Round Peg Promotions Summer Fight Fest
Jul 11th 2015 | Dylan Bostic | def. (pin) | Joe Coleman | | |
OVW TV Taping #743
Nov 13th 2013 | Joe Coleman | def. (DQ) | Shiloh Jonze (c) | | OVW Television Title
|
OVW Louisville Show
Nov 10th 2013 | Michael Hayes | def. | Joe Coleman | | |
OVW TV Taping #742
Nov 6th 2013 | Joe Coleman | def. (pin) | Raul LaMotta | | |
OVW Old School
Nov 3rd 2013 | The Bodyguy | def. | Joe Coleman | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special
Nov 2nd 2013 | Clint Poe & Joe Coleman & Nick Dumeyer | def. (pin) | Elvis Pridemoore & J. Best & Robo De Luna | 6-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #741
Oct 30th 2013 | Clint Poe & Joe Coleman | def. (pin) | Rockstar Spud & Ryan Howe | dark
| |
OVW Louisville Show
Oct 26th 2013 | Michael Hayes & Mohamad Ali Vaez | def. | Joe Coleman & Shiloh Jonze | | |
Joe Coleman