| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AEW Full Gear 2023
Nov 18th 2023 | Eddie Kingston (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | pre-show
| ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
WrestlePro On The Spot Title Shot Rumble
Oct 22nd 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | Cheeseburger | | |
AEW Rampage #114 Taping
Oct 10th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Trent Beretta | | |
AEW Rampage #110 Taping
Sep 13th 2023 | Jeff Hardy & Matt Hardy & Penta El Zero Miedo & Rey Fenix | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & The Blade & The Butcher | 8-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #109 Taping
Sep 6th 2023 | Penta El Zero Miedo | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | |
AEW All Out 2023
Sep 3rd 2023 | Anthony Bowens (c) & Daddy Ass (c) & Max Caster (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh | 6-person tag | AEW World Trios Titles
|
NEW Six Flags Slam Fest 2023
Aug 13th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | Dan Maff | | |
AEW Dynamite #200
Aug 2nd 2023 | Kenny Omega & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh | 6-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #103 Taping
Jul 26th 2023 | Big Bill & Brian Cage | def. | Angelo Parker & Matt Menard, The Blade & The Butcher, Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal, Brother Zay & Ethan Page, Jay Lethal & Satnam Singh, Jeff Hardy & Matt Hardy, Luther & Serpentico | tag team battle royale | |
AEW Rampage #102 - Royal Rampage Taping
Jul 19th 2023 | Darby Allin | def. | Angelo Parker, Big Bill, Bishop Kaun, Brian Cage, Brother Zay, Ethan Page, Jake Hager, Jay Lethal, Jeff Jarrett, Komander, Matt Hardy, Matt Menard, Matt Sydal, Minoru Suzuki, Nick Wayne, Swerve Strickland, The Blade, The Butcher, Toa Liona | Royal Rampage | |
AEW Rampage #97 Taping
Jun 14th 2023 | Aubrey Edwards & Mark Briscoe & Papa Briscoe | def. | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Karen Jarrett | 6-person tag | |
AEW House Rules
Jun 2nd 2023 | Jay Lethal & Satnam Singh | def. | Brandon Tate & Brent Tate | | |
AEW Double Or Nothing 2023
May 28th 2023 | Cash Wheeler (c) & Dax Harwood (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | referee: Mark Briscoe | AEW Tag Team Championship
|
AEW Rampage #90 Taping
Apr 26th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Cash Wheeler | enforcer: Mark Briscoe | |
WrestlePro Alaska: 4th Anniversary SuperShow
Apr 22nd 2023 | Dan Maff | def. | Bobby Wayward (c), Deonn Rusman, Jay Lethal | ladder (four-way) | WrestlePro Championship
(title change) |
AEW Rampage #89 Taping
Apr 19th 2023 | Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood & Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. | Ari Daivari & Josh Woods & Slim J & Tony Nese | 8-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #88 Taping
Apr 12th 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Mark Briscoe & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | Angélico & Luther & Man Scout & Serpentico | 8-person tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #6 Taping
Apr 5th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Darius Martin | | |
AEW Dynamite #179
Mar 8th 2023 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | AEW All-Atlantic Championship
|
AEW Revolution 2023
Mar 5th 2023 | Austin Gunn (c) & Colten Gunn (c) | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster, Danhausen & Orange Cassidy, Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | four-way tag | AEW Tag Team Championship
|
AEW Dark #185 Taping - Part 2
Feb 26th 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | Jackson Drake & Jay Malachi & Oliver Sawyer | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #177
Feb 22nd 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. | Alex Reynolds & John Silver, Angelo Parker & Matt Menard, Ari Daivari & Tony Nese, The Blade & The Butcher, Chuck Taylor & Trent Beretta, Dante Martin & Darius Martin, Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis, Penta El Zero Miedo & Rey Fenix, Preston Vance & Rush | tag team battle royale | |
AEW Dynamite #176
Feb 15th 2023 | Anthony Bowens & Daddy Ass & Max Caster & Orange Cassidy | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh & Sonjay Dutt | 8-person tag | |
WrestlePro Violencetines Day
Feb 11th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | CPA | | |
 Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Four Leaf Clover - Night 4
Feb 5th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | Ortiz | | |
Jay Lethal