| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AEW Dark: Elevation #77 Taping
Aug 17th 2022 | Julia Hart | def. (sub) | Hayley Shadows | | |
NWA Powerrr S9E11 - Celebration 74 Taping
Jun 13th 2022 | Ella Envy & Kenzie Paige | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows & Jaylee | | |
NWA Powerrr S9E10 Taping
Jun 13th 2022 | Kamille | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV #1184
Apr 21st 2022 | Shawna Reed | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV #1183
Apr 14th 2022 | Michelle Green | def. (pin) | Charlie Kruel, Hayley Shadows | dark
three-way | |
OVW TV #1182
Apr 7th 2022 | Leila Grey | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV #1177 - Fan Appreciation Night
Mar 3rd 2022 | Hayley Shadows | def. | Charlie Kruel | | |
OVW TV #1175
Feb 17th 2022 | Hayley Shadows | def. (pin) | Lilith Grimm | dark
| |
OVW TV #1174
Feb 10th 2022 | Dream Girl Ellie | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows | dark
| |
OVW TV #1171
Jan 20th 2022 | Arie Alexander | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special - Nightmare Rumble 2022
Jan 15th 2022 | Angelina Love | def. | Alice Crowley, Arie Alexander, Bashley Bones, Brittany Garcia, Charlie Kruel, Hayley Shadows, Jada Stone, Judi Hendrix, Kelsey Lynn, Kolbe Max, Linda Kay, Lindsay Snow, Lindsey Carlson, Lucy B. Sweet, Myka Madrid, Nikki Victory, Olivia Devine, Shannon the Dude, Sierra | Nightmare Rumble | |
OVW TV #1170
Jan 13th 2022 | Dream Girl Ellie & Hayley Shadows & Shawna Reed | def. (pin) | Charlie Kruel & Judi Hendrix & Kolbe Max | 6-person tag | |
OVW TV #1166 - Christmas Chaos 2021
Dec 16th 2021 | Arie Alexander & Hayley Shadows | def. (pin) | Dream Girl Ellie & Judi Hendrix | dark
| |
OVW TV #1160
Nov 4th 2021 | Arie Alexander | draw (NC) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV #1111 / Overdrive Taping
Nov 24th 2020 | Arie Alexander & Ella & Joseline Navarro & Shawna Reed | def. (pin) | Haley J & Harley Fairfax & Hayley Shadows & Salena Dean | 8-person tag elimination | |
IWA-MS BattleBroads #2
Feb 22nd 2020 | Hayley Shadows | def. | Ava Lee | | |
IWA-MS Battle of the Super Juniors 2020
Feb 20th 2020 | Alice Crowley & ThunderKitty | def. | Haley J & Hayley Shadows | no disqualification tag | |
IWA-MS Double Jeopardy
Nov 14th 2019 | Alice Crowley (c) | def. | Hayley Shadows, Kayla Kassidy | three-way | IWA:MS Womens Title
|
IWA-MS The Show Must Go On
Nov 2nd 2019 | Alice Crowley (c) | def. | Hayley Shadows | | IWA:MS Womens Title
|
IWA-MS She's Amazing
Oct 27th 2019 | Hayley Shadows | def. | Harley Fairfax, Kaydee Knox | three-way | |
WWNLive Do Or Die Showcase
Aug 18th 2019 | Gia Roman & Lavender Skye & Rahne Victoria | def. (pin) | Chelsea Durden & Hayley Shadows & Shawna Reed | 6-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #1027
Apr 17th 2019 | Hayley Shadows | def. (pin) | ThunderKitty | | |
OVW TV Taping #1024
Mar 27th 2019 | ThunderKitty | def. (sub) | Hayley Shadows, Maria James | dark
triple-threat | |
OVW TV Taping #991
Aug 15th 2018 | Cali Young | def. (sub) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV Taping #989
Aug 1st 2018 | Meg & Rebel | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows & Kaci Dillon | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #978
May 16th 2018 | Cali | def. (sub) | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV Taping #977
May 9th 2018 | Cali & Hayley Shadows & Meg | def. (sub) | Jaylee & Jessie Belle & Maria James | dark
6-person tag | |
WWE Smackdown Live
Aug 29th 2017 | Tamina | def. (pin) | Tina Stock | | |
WCPBTW Vengeance Is Mine
Jul 6th 2017 | Shawna Reed | def. | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV Taping #862
Feb 24th 2016 | Jessie Belle | def. (pin) | Hayley Shadows, Maria James | dark
triple-threat | |
OVW TV Taping #854
Dec 30th 2015 | Hayley Shadows & Maria James | def. | Jessie Belle & Lexi Green | | |
IWA-MS Prelude to Death 2015
Jun 14th 2015 | Hayley Shadows | def. | Lexi Green | | |
AAW The Super Summer Sizzler Charity Show
Aug 2nd 2013 | Heidi Lovelace | def. | Hayley Shadows | | |
OVW TV Taping #689
Oct 31st 2012 | Jessie Belle | def. | December, Emily Elizabeth, Epiphany, Josette Bynum, Scarlett Bordeaux, Taeler Hendrix | dark
Battle Royal | |
Hayley Shadows