| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 3
Aug 16th 2009 | Jorge Rivera & Mike Quackenbush | def. | Frightmare & Turbo | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 1
Aug 14th 2009 | Brendan Michael Thomas | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Never Kneel at the Altar of Conformity
Jul 31st 2009 | Colin Delaney & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Hydra | 6-person tag | |
AIW Absolution 4
Jun 12th 2009 | Flip Kendrick & Louis Lyndon | def. | Amasis & Ophidian, Jon Moxley & Sami Callihan, Frightmare & Klondike Kremlin | four-way tag | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yang
May 24th 2009 | Cheech & Cloudy & Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Helios & Jigsaw & Lince Dorado & Mike Quackenbush | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yin
May 23rd 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
JAPW Double Header - Evening Show
May 9th 2009 | Amasis & Ophidian | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked | | |
CHIKARA The Bobliographon
Apr 26th 2009 | Delirious & Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Brodie Lee & Eddie Kingston & Grizzly Redwood | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Behind the 8 Ball
Apr 25th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 3
Mar 29th 2009 | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked, Ryan Drago & Tony Kozina, Hydra & Tim Donst, Crossbones & Ultramantis Black, Beef Wellington & Steven Weiner, Create-A-Wrestler & Player Uno, Mitch Ryder & Pinkie Sanchez, Marshe Rockett & Willie Richardson, Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson, Cheech & Cloudy, Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | tag team gauntlet | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 1
Mar 27th 2009 | Johnny Saint & Mike Quackenbush & Skayde | def. (pin) | Delirious & Frightmare & Hallowicked | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Secret Delaware Show with Lucha Libre Mexicana
Mar 9th 2009 | Klondike Grizzly & STIGMA | def. | Cometa de Oro & Frightmare | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 4
Feb 28th 2009 | Jimmy DeMarco | def. | Benny Boone, Bobby Beverly, Brady Beverly, Chest Flexor, Christian Faith, Dick Wiggler, Dubleve, Eric Ryan, Fire Ant, Frightmare, Gran Akuma, Gregory Iron, Hailey Hatred, Hobo Joe, Icarus, Joey the Snake, John Thorne, Josh Prohibition, K. Fernandez, Luis Diamante, Marion Fontaine, Nick Belushi, Orange Cassidy, Pinkie Sanchez, Rebis, Southside St. Clair, Super Oprah, T. J. Dynamite, Vincent Nothing | Battle Royal | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 4
Feb 28th 2009 | Luis Diamante | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Motive, Means, Opportunity
Feb 21st 2009 | Ophidian | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA If the Airplane is Snowed In, Put your Bloody Skis On and Get Going!
Feb 20th 2009 | Brodie Lee | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Revelation X
Jan 25th 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | | |
CHIKARA Face with a View
Dec 12th 2008 | Brodie Lee | def. | Frightmare | | |
Frightmare