| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 EWF Covina Show
Oct 5th 2013 | Eli Everfly | def. | Hoss Hogg | | |
VPW Summer Sizzle Tour '14 Simi Valley Show
Jun 14th 2014 | Che Cabrera | def. (pin) | Eli Everfly | | |
VPW Terror Rising '14 - Night 1
Oct 25th 2014 | Ricky Ruffin | def. (pin) | Eli Everfly, Clay Tawzer, Kaka Meng | fatal 4-way | |
 The Crash 5th Anniversary Show
Nov 26th 2016 | Black Danger & Douglas James & Ultimo Maldito | def. | Arkangel Divino & Eli Everfly & Mirage | 6-person tag | |
PCW Young Guns
Apr 22nd 2017 | Fidel Bravo | def. | Eli Everfly | | |
PCW Showdown
Jun 2nd 2017 | Eli Everfly | def. (DQ) | Alexander Hammerstone | | |
The Crash Crash Wrestling
Jul 14th 2017 | Eli Everfly & Famous B & Ultimo Maldito | def. | Arkangel Divino & Black Boy | 6-person tag | |
PCW Second to None
Jul 28th 2017 | Shane Strickland | def. | Eli Everfly, Misterioso Jr., Rey Fenix | four-way | |
The Crash Crash Wrestling
Sep 2nd 2017 | Homicide | def. | Eli Everfly, Último Ninja | three-way | |
PCW Demonized
Oct 6th 2017 | Daga & Penta el Zero M & Rey Fenix | def. | Dave Crist & Eli Everfly & Sami Callihan | 6-person tag | |
GCW Worst Behavior
Oct 28th 2017 | Tony Deppen | def. | Eli Everfly, Smiley (c), Zenshi | four-way | GCW Extreme Championship
(title change) |
Bar Wrestling 6: Head of Household
Nov 9th 2017 | Eli Everfly & Pinkie Sanchez & Super Panda | def. | B-Boy & Brody King & Eric Watts | 6-person tag | |
GCW Line In the Sand
Nov 11th 2017 | Eli Everfly | def. | Unbreakable Andy | | |
GCW Ready To Die: The 2nd Anniversary
Dec 16th 2017 | Tony Deppen (c) | def. | Eli Everfly | | GCW Extreme Championship
|
Rey Mysterio Presents Lucha Wonderland
Dec 22nd 2017 | Black Danger & Steve Pain | def. (pin) | Black Diamond & Eli Everfly | | |
Bar Wrestling 8: Happily Ever After
Jan 18th 2018 | Delilah Doom & Eli Everfly | def. | Joey Janela & Penelope Ford | | |
GCW Hit 'Em Up
Jan 20th 2018 | Eli Everfly | def. | Darby Allin | | |
GCW Gang Affiliated
Feb 17th 2018 | Eli Everfly | def. | B-Boy, Jack Evans, Unbreakable Andy | four-way | |
Bar Wrestling 9: February Stars
Feb 22nd 2018 | Delilah Doom & Eli Everfly | def. | Jason Cade & Ruby Raze | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 4 Episode 10: A Snake Scorned (Part 2)
Mar 3rd 2018 | Marty Martinez | def. | Eli Everfly, Mil Muertes | dark
three-way | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 4 Episode 15: The Hunted
Mar 10th 2018 | Cage | def. | Eli Everfly | dark
| |
PCW ULTRA Tuff Luck
Mar 16th 2018 | Eli Everfly | def. (pin) | Chris Bey | | |
PWG Time is a Flat Circle
Mar 23rd 2018 | Brody King | def. (pin) | Douglas James, Eli Everfly, Jake Atlas | four-way | |
GCW Joey Janela's Spring Break 2
Apr 7th 2018 | Eli Everfly | def. (pin) | DJ Z, Gringo Loco, KTB, Teddy Hart, Tony Deppen | 6-Way | |
Bar Wrestling 11: April O'Neil
Apr 12th 2018 | Peter Avalon & Ray Rosas | def. | Delilah Doom & Eli Everfly, Indi Hartwell & Tessa Blanchard, Lance Lude & Rob Killjoy | four-way tag | |
Eli Everfly