| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 MLW Once Upon A Time In New York Taping
Feb 29th 2024 | Brett Ryan Gosselin | def. | Cannonball, Dyln McKay, Ichiban, Love, Doug, Marcus Mathers | 6-way scramble | |
DREAMWAVE Run This Town
Feb 10th 2024 | Dyln McKay (c) & Marcus Mathers (c) | def. | August Matthews & Davey Bang | | Interim DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
|
MLW Kings of Colosseum 2024
Jan 6th 2024 | Alec Price & Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Griffin McCoy & T. J. Crawford & Tony Deppen | 6-person tag | |
JCW (NJ) Battlebowl
Dec 31st 2023 | Brayden Toon & Broski Jimmy | def. | Dyln McKay & Hunter Drake | | |
GCW Aftermath 2023
Dec 31st 2023 | Dominic Garrini (c) & Kevin Ku (c) | def. | Austin Luke & Dyln McKay | | GCW Tag Team Titles
|
DREAMWAVE Good As Gold 2023
Dec 9th 2023 | Dyln McKay (c) & Marcus Mathers (c) | def. | Aaron Xavier & J Fowler | | Interim DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
|
MLW Holiday Rush
Dec 7th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Griffin McCoy & T. J. Crawford, Jay Lyon & Midas Black | three-way tag | |
GCW What Is Your Choice?
Dec 3rd 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Allie Katch & Effy & Mance Warner | def. | Alec Price & Cole Radrick & Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | 8-person tag | |
MLW Fusion TV Tapings
Nov 18th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Austin Luke & Lucky 13, Jay Lyon & Midas Black | three-way tag | |
JCW (NJ) The Quick And The Dead
Nov 12th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | August Matthews & Davey Bang | | |
DREAMWAVE Follow Your Hart
Oct 14th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Aaron Xavier & Bucky Collins, Doc Simmons & Zach Hendrix, J Fowler & Victor Iniestra | four-way tag | Interim DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
JCW (NJ) Pumpkin Spiced
Oct 8th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Dustin Waller & Kylon King | | |
GCW Fight Club 2023 - Day 1: The Art Of War Games
Oct 7th 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Allie Katch & Effy & Mance Warner & Sawyer Wreck | def. (pin) | Brayden Toon & Cole Radrick & Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers & Shane Mercer | 10-person tag | |
GCW Crushed Up 2023
Sep 10th 2023 | Ciclope & Miedo Extremo | def. | Alec Price & Cole Radrick, Allie Katch & Effy, Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | four-way tag | |
Sean Henderson Presents Dyln McKay's Underground
Aug 25th 2023 | Dyln McKay | def. | Brian Kendrick | | |
JCW (NJ) Dog Day Afternoon
Aug 20th 2023 | Bam Sullivan & Dyln McKay & Gabriel Skye & Marcus Mathers | def. | Brogan Finlay & Donnie Primetime & Hunter Drake & Rico Gonzalez | 8-person tag | |
DREAMWAVE Those Summer Nights
Aug 5th 2023 | Gaige Noonan & Hunter Holdcraft | def. | Dyln McKay (c) & Marcus Mathers (c) | | DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
DREAMWAVE Summer Spectacular 2023
Aug 4th 2023 | Dyln McKay (c) & Marcus Mathers (c) | def. | Aramis & Flamita | | DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
|
N/A Marcus Mathers' All I Want 2
Jul 13th 2023 | Mike Bailey | def. | Dyln McKay | | |
GCW Clean Up Man
Jul 8th 2023 | Dyln McKay & Jimmy Lloyd & Marcus Mathers | def. | Joel Maximo & Jose Maximo & Wil Maximo | 6-person tag | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Episode 79
Jul 6th 2023 | Brad Hollister & T. J. Crawford | def. | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | | |
GCW Backyard Wrestling 5
Jul 4th 2023 | Emanon | def. | Aerial Crow | 2 Out of 3 Falls Ultraviolent Doors Deathmatch | |
DREAMWAVE Nothin' But A Good Time
Jun 17th 2023 | Dyln McKay (c) & Marcus Mathers (c) | def. | Gaige Noonan & Hunter Holdcraft | | DREAMWAVE Tag Team Titles
|
JCW (NJ) After Hours 3
Jun 3rd 2023 | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | def. | Charlie Tiger & Ellis Taylor, Janai Kai & Yoya, Jay Lyon & Midas Black | four-way tag | |
Freelance Wrestling The Last Of Us
May 12th 2023 | August Matthews (c) & Davey Bang (c) | def. | Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers | | Freelance Tag Team Titles
|
Dyln McKay