| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Conquest Tour 2016
Mar 12th 2016 | Kenny King & Rhett Titus | def. | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | handicap tag | |
NEW Retribution 2016
Mar 5th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Robbie E. | | |
NEW Wrestlefest XX
Mar 4th 2016 | Matt Hardy & Rey Mysterio | def. | Caleb Konley & Dalton Castle | | |
ROH 14th Anniversary TV Tapings
Feb 27th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Silas Young | "Fight Without Honor" | |
ROH 14th Anniversary Show
Feb 26th 2016 | Hirooki Goto | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
 ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Day 2
Feb 20th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Frankie Kazarian | | |
ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2016 - Day 1
Feb 19th 2016 | Jushin Thunder Liger & Matt Sydal | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle & Ryusuke Taguchi | | |
PWG Bowie
Feb 12th 2016 | Chuck Taylor | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Feb 6th 2016 | Christopher Daniels | def. | Dalton Castle | | |
NEW Over the Top 2016
Jan 30th 2016 | Brian Anthony | def. | Anthony Battle, Anthony Greene, Bobby Ocean, Bull Dredd, Cam Zagami, Chris Battle, Dalton Castle, Dan De Man, Daniel Evans, Flip Gordon, Hanson, J. T. Dunn, Jym Anderson, Keith Youngblood, Lukas Sharp, Mark Shurman, Mikey Webb, Randy Shawn, Ron Zombie, Sami Callihan, Scotty Slade, T. K. O'Ryan, Unknown Participants, Vinny Marseglia, Wrecking Ball Legursky | Rumble | NEW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
NEW Over the Top 2016
Jan 30th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016
Jan 23rd 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Corey Hollis | | |
ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016
Jan 16th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Delirious | | |
ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Jan 15th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Will Ferrara | | |
ROH Winter Warriors Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Jan 9th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Joey Daddiego | | |
2CW #2Sets: The Final Show
Dec 20th 2015 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Dalton Castle | sudden death rules | 2CW Heavyweight Championship
|
2CW #2Sets: The Final Show
Dec 20th 2015 | Sami Callihan (c) | draw (DCO) | Dalton Castle | | 2CW Heavyweight Championship
|
ROH Final Battle 2015 - Night 2 TV Tapings
Dec 19th 2015 | Dalton Castle | def. | Jay Briscoe, Matt Sydal, Moose | four corners survival | |
ROH Final Battle 2015 - Night 1
Dec 18th 2015 | Silas Young | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
2CW Nothing Left To Prove
Dec 17th 2015 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Dalton Castle | | 2CW Heavyweight Championship
|
 DWW Momentum
Dec 6th 2015 | Dalton Castle | def. | Mike Rollins | | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2015
Dec 5th 2015 | Moose | def. | Cheeseburger, Dalton Castle, Rhett Titus | four corners survival | |
 ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 4
Nov 29th 2015 | Dalton Castle | def. | Silas Young | | |
ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 2
Nov 28th 2015 | Sha Samuels | def. | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH/PCW Supershow of Honor 2015 - Show 3
Nov 28th 2015 | Dalton Castle | def. | Ashton Smith, Cedric Alexander, Charlie Garrett, Martin Kirby, Silas Young | 6-Way | |
Dalton Castle