| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ICW No Holds Barred Volume 25
May 15th 2022 | Krule | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
No Peace Underground/Ruthless Pro/Circle 6 Body Count Battle
May 7th 2022 | Kevin Giza | def. | Apollo Starr, Bobby Beverly, Casanova Valentine, Darren McCarty, Gregory Iron, Josh Crane, Madman Pondo, Malcolm Monroe III, Mathias Thrasher, Mickie Knuckles, Neil Diamond Cutter, Otis Cogar, Remington Rhor, Rickey Shane Page, Satu Jinn, ThunderKitty, TJ Meyer | Body Count Battle Elimination Match | |
No Peace Underground/New Fear City Murdermania
Apr 1st 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Tony Nese | no ring deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 21
Jan 22nd 2022 | Satu Jinn | def. (pin) | Casanova Valentine | | |
VxS/NPU Already Dead
Jan 7th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Chelsea Durden, Gory, Kit Osbourne, Otis Cogar, Tye Hyll | 6-Way Lucha Rules Mosh Pit Scramble Match | |
FMW-E/H2O Destiny - Onita Vs. Tremont
Oct 31st 2021 | Chainsaw Tony | def. | Alex Stretch, Bam Sullivan, Brandon Kirk, Casanova Valentine, Conor Claxton, Crazy Ivan, Dan O'Hare, Drew Blood, Frankie Pickard, Kaide Lothbrok, Larry Legend, Low Life Louie, Marc Angel, Mouse, Neil Diamond Cutter, Robby Illuminati, Robby Mireno, Ruckus, Sean Henderson | Hardcore Rumble | |
IWA-MS King Of The Deathmatch '21 - Day 2
Jul 31st 2021 | Casanova Valentine & Dan O'Hare & Insane Lane & Jeff Cannonball & Kevin Giza | def. | Bobby Beverly & Dale Patricks & Jake Crist & Rebecca Payne & Shane Mercer | 10-person tag fans bring the weapons elimination | |
IWA-MS King Of The Deathmatch '21 - Day 1
Jul 30th 2021 | Orin Veidt | def. | Casanova Valentine | fans bring the weapons | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 16
Jul 10th 2021 | Satu Jinn | def. | Casanova Valentine, Danny Demanto, Tank | Homerun Derby Four-Way | |
ICW No Holds Barred Unlucky 13
Jun 26th 2021 | Tank | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X7
Jun 25th 2021 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Dale Patricks | | |
No Peace Underground Rewiring the Human Body
May 21st 2021 | Atticus Cogar | def. | Casanova Valentine | no ring deathmatch | |
GCW/Unsanctioned Pro Fueled By Spite
Apr 10th 2021 | Hoodfoot | def. | Casanova Valentine | street fight | |
No Peace Underground MurderMania
Apr 8th 2021 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Mad Man Pondo | referee: Markus Crane
Taipei deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X5
Dec 12th 2020 | Alex Ocean | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
No Peace Underground Body Count Battle 2020
Nov 12th 2020 | Allie Kat | def. | AKIRA, Alex Ocean, Casanova Valentine, Dominic Garrini, Eddy Only, Jimmy Lloyd, John Wayne Murdoch, Lindsay Snow, Matthew Justice, Neil Diamond Cutter, Orin Veidt, Otis Cogar, Reed Bentley, Robert Martyr | Body Count Battle Elimination Deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X3
Nov 6th 2020 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Satu Jinn | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X2
Oct 16th 2020 | AKIRA | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 6 - Rollin' With The Punches
Sep 11th 2020 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Jeff Cannonball | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X
Sep 10th 2020 | John Wayne Murdoch | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 4 - Deathmatch Circus - Part 1
Aug 8th 2020 | SHLAK | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 5 - Deathmatch Circus - Part 2
Aug 8th 2020 | Mance Warner | def. (ref) | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 3.75 - Pit
Aug 7th 2020 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Dale Patricks | no ring deathmatch | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '20 - Day 2
Aug 1st 2020 | Tristen Ramsey | def. | BC Killer, Casanova Valentine, Eddy Only | fans bring the weapons (4-way) | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '20 - Day 1
Jul 31st 2020 | SHLAK | def. | Casanova Valentine | fans bring the weapons | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 3 - Deathmatch Drive-In
Jul 4th 2020 | Matthew Justice | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 2 - Deathmatch Drive-In
Jun 27th 2020 | Nick Gage | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
CZW 21st Anniversary
Feb 8th 2020 | Masada | def. | Casanova Valentine | "No Ropes Barbed Wire" | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 1
Jan 4th 2020 | Homicide | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
No Peace Underground Body Count Battle
Dec 21st 2019 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Leon Scott | no ring deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Markus Crane's Wasteland
Sep 16th 2019 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Dysfunction | No Ring Kitchen Massacre Deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Gore For Gold II
Sep 13th 2019 | Effy Gibbes | def. | Casanova Valentine | no ring deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Bloodbath on the Bayou II: Ebola Fest
Aug 3rd 2019 | Markus Crane (c) | def. | Casanova Valentine | no ring deathmatch | NPU Title
|
CZW Tournament of Death 18
Jun 22nd 2019 | Officer O'Hare | def. | Casanova Valentine | Texas Tumbleweed Deathmatch | |
CZW Tournament of Death 18
Jun 22nd 2019 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Big Joe | Bundles and Boards Match | |
No Peace Underground Summer of Samhain
May 31st 2019 | Markus Crane | def. | Casanova Valentine (c), G-Raver | 3-Way No Ring Deathmatch | NPU Title
(title change) |
CZW Tangled Web 2019
May 11th 2019 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Officer O'Hare | "hardcore" | |
Blackcraft No Apologies
Apr 5th 2019 | Zicky Dice | def. | Anthony Greene, Arik Cannon, Atticus Cogar, Benjamin Carter, Casanova Valentine, Conan Lycan, Connor Braxton, Corey Futuristic, Dale Patricks, Dave Dutra, Derek Direction, Gory, John Wayne Murdoch, Justin Credible, Kit Osbourne, KTB, Lady Frost, Lord Crewe, Mance Warner, Matt Light, Pinkie Sanchez, Rory Gulak, Royce Isaacs, Sledge, Stockade, Swoggle, Victor Benjamin | Battle Royal | |
CZW Twenty
Feb 9th 2019 | Matt Tremont | def. | Casanova Valentine | CZW Rules | |
No Peace Underground Gauntlet of Death
Feb 8th 2019 | Casanova Valentine (c) | def. | Barrington Hughes | no ring deathmatch | NPU Title
|
McAloon Productions Come Hell or High Water
Feb 1st 2019 | Mil Muertes | def. (pin) | Casanova Valentine, Vernon White | triple-threat | |
McAloon Productions Ultimate Bar Brawl
Jan 31st 2019 | Effy | def. | Casanova Valentine, Ethan Page, Matt Cross | four-way elimination | |
No Peace Underground Bloodbath on the Bayou
Nov 10th 2018 | Kit Osbourne | def. | Casanova Valentine, Markus Crane | 3-Way No Ring Deathmatch | |
No Peace Underground Ultraviolent Halloween Extravaganza
Oct 13th 2018 | Casanova Valentine (c) | def. | G-Raver | no ring deathmatch | NPU Title
|
IWA-MS The Juice Is Worth The Squeeze
Oct 5th 2018 | Nick Gage | def. | Casanova Valentine, SHLAK | Street Fight (3-way) | |
No Peace Underground Gore For Gold
Aug 25th 2018 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Johnny Knockout, Markus Crane | 3-Way No Ring Deathmatch | NPU Title
|
JCW Oddball Wrestling 2018
Jul 19th 2018 | Big Fucking Joe | def. | Casanova Valentine | Brooklyn to Brighton Superbrawl | |
CZW Tournament of Death 17
Jun 9th 2018 | Jimmy Lloyd | def. | Casanova Valentine, G-Raver, Stockade | Cinder Blocks and Baseball Bats Bundles Match (4-way) | |
Casanova Valentine