| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Circle 6 Double Dose
Feb 1st 2025 | Danhausen | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
Circle 6 Thriller II
Oct 5th 2024 | Luigi Primo | def. | Casanova Valentine, Dominick Denaro, Luigi, Super Mario, Vinnie Massaro | 6-way scramble | |
Beyond Wrestling Open: Hot Dog And A Handshake
Jun 10th 2024 | Hotdog Starkes | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
Circle 6 Barroom Blitz
Jun 7th 2024 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Frank the Clown | no ring deathmatch | |
Circle 6/NFC Circle 6 x NFC Kickoff Party
Apr 3rd 2024 | Chris Brookes & MAO | def. | Casanova Valentine & Nate Webb | No Ring Tag Team Match | |
Circle 6 EIP - 2 Year Anniversary
Mar 3rd 2024 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Zicky Dice | street fight | |
Circle 6 Barroom Blitz
Mar 2nd 2024 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Peter Avalon | no ring deathmatch | |
VxS Arrival
Feb 23rd 2024 | Casanova Valentine & Colby Corino | def. | Gabriel Skye & Tristen Thai | | |
 Circle 6/NFC Barroom Blitz Japan
Oct 13th 2023 | Toshiyuki Sakuda | def. | Casanova Valentine | no ring deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 52
Sep 23rd 2023 | Otis Cogar | def. (ref) | Casanova Valentine | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 50
Jul 28th 2023 | Matt Tremont (c) | def. | Casanova Valentine | deathmatch | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
|
Circle 6/NFC MurderMania 2023
Mar 31st 2023 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Atticus Cogar | no ring deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X16
Mar 18th 2023 | Hoodfoot | def. | Casanova Valentine | deathmatch | |
Circle 6 Obey Your Master
Mar 11th 2023 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Otis Cogar | No Ring Match | |
No Peace Underground Of Omen And Doom
Feb 26th 2023 | Otis Cogar & Su Yung | def. | Casanova Valentine & Kit Osbourne | Deathmatch (tag) | NPU Tag Team Titles
|
 ICW No Holds Barred Volume 41
Feb 11th 2023 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Michael Caden | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X14
Dec 29th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Dr. Redacted | steel cage | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 38: Ultraviolent Vortex
Dec 16th 2022 | Abdullah Kobayashi | def. | Casanova Valentine, John Wayne Murdoch, Matt Tremont | four-way deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 37
Nov 19th 2022 | Hoodfoot | def. | Casanova Valentine | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 35 - Deathmatch Horror Story 2022
Oct 29th 2022 | Cassie Kruger | def. | Chris Bradley | deathmatch | |
 ICW No Holds Barred/DMDU ICW No Holds Barred Vs. DMDU
Oct 16th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Will Walker | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 34
Oct 15th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Damian Rivers | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X12
Oct 14th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Gweedo | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 33
Oct 9th 2022 | Krule | def. | Casanova Valentine, Danny Demanto, La Sadika | four-way deathmatch | |
Circle 6 Barroom Blitz #1
Oct 6th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Bestia 666 | No Ring Bar Fight | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 32
Sep 10th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Jordan Samson | deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X: Battle of the Tough Guys II - Part 1
Aug 27th 2022 | Bobby Beverly | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
Circle 6 Soul Doubt
Aug 20th 2022 | Rickey Shane Page | def. | Casanova Valentine, Keita Murray, Kody Lane, Masada, Vinnie Massaro | Gauntlet | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 26
Jun 25th 2022 | Bobby Beverly | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 25
May 15th 2022 | Krule | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
No Peace Underground/Ruthless Pro/Circle 6 Body Count Battle
May 7th 2022 | Kevin Giza | def. | Apollo Starr, Bobby Beverly, Casanova Valentine, Darren McCarty, Gregory Iron, Josh Crane, Madman Pondo, Malcolm Monroe III, Mathias Thrasher, Mickie Knuckles, Neil Diamond Cutter, Otis Cogar, Remington Rhor, Rickey Shane Page, Satu Jinn, ThunderKitty, TJ Meyer | Body Count Battle Elimination Match | |
No Peace Underground/New Fear City Murdermania
Apr 1st 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Tony Nese | no ring deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 21
Jan 22nd 2022 | Satu Jinn | def. (pin) | Casanova Valentine | | |
VxS/NPU Already Dead
Jan 7th 2022 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Chelsea Durden, Gory, Kit Osbourne, Otis Cogar, Tye Hyll | 6-Way Lucha Rules Mosh Pit Scramble Match | |
FMW-E/H2O Destiny - Onita Vs. Tremont
Oct 31st 2021 | Chainsaw Tony | def. | Alex Stretch, Bam Sullivan, Brandon Kirk, Casanova Valentine, Conor Claxton, Crazy Ivan, Dan O'Hare, Drew Blood, Frankie Pickard, Kaide Lothbrok, Larry Legend, Low Life Louie, Marc Angel, Mouse, Neil Diamond Cutter, Robby Illuminati, Robby Mireno, Ruckus, Sean Henderson | Hardcore Rumble | |
IWA-MS King Of The Deathmatch '21 - Day 2
Jul 31st 2021 | Casanova Valentine & Dan O'Hare & Insane Lane & Jeff Cannonball & Kevin Giza | def. | Bobby Beverly & Dale Patricks & Jake Crist & Rebecca Payne & Shane Mercer | 10-person tag fans bring the weapons elimination | |
IWA-MS King Of The Deathmatch '21 - Day 1
Jul 30th 2021 | Orin Veidt | def. | Casanova Valentine | fans bring the weapons | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 16
Jul 10th 2021 | Satu Jinn | def. | Casanova Valentine, Danny Demanto, Tank | Homerun Derby Four-Way | |
ICW No Holds Barred Unlucky 13
Jun 26th 2021 | Tank | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X7
Jun 25th 2021 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Dale Patricks | | |
No Peace Underground Rewiring the Human Body
May 21st 2021 | Atticus Cogar | def. | Casanova Valentine | no ring deathmatch | |
GCW/Unsanctioned Pro Fueled By Spite
Apr 10th 2021 | Hoodfoot | def. | Casanova Valentine | street fight | |
No Peace Underground MurderMania
Apr 8th 2021 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Mad Man Pondo | referee: Markus Crane
Taipei deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X5
Dec 12th 2020 | Alex Ocean | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
No Peace Underground Body Count Battle 2020
Nov 12th 2020 | Allie Kat | def. | AKIRA, Alex Ocean, Casanova Valentine, Dominic Garrini, Eddy Only, Jimmy Lloyd, John Wayne Murdoch, Lindsay Snow, Matthew Justice, Neil Diamond Cutter, Orin Veidt, Otis Cogar, Reed Bentley, Robert Martyr | Body Count Battle Elimination Deathmatch | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X3
Nov 6th 2020 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Satu Jinn | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X2
Oct 16th 2020 | AKIRA | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 6 - Rollin' With The Punches
Sep 11th 2020 | Casanova Valentine | def. | Jeff Cannonball | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X
Sep 10th 2020 | John Wayne Murdoch | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
ICW No Holds Barred Volume 4 - Deathmatch Circus - Part 1
Aug 8th 2020 | SHLAK | def. | Casanova Valentine | | |
Casanova Valentine