Carmelo Hayes
Profile & Match Listing • Facts & Stats • PWI Ratings • Opponents & Partners • Win/Loss Record • Star Ratings • Win Types • Relations • PPVIntroduction
Below you can see all known star ratings for wrestling matches featuring in Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Please note that ratings are given to the overall match; not to the performers within them. Therefore, high or low ratings may reflect aspects of the match including booking, length and performance of partners/opponents, over which the performers may have little or no control. Please also note that a match that received a particular rating many years ago may have been judged on a different criteria from today's.Following the same rating system devised in part by Jim Cornette, matches are rated from the lowest rating of -***** (-5) through to the highest rating of ***** (+5), with a small number of matches being rated above that theoretical maximum. Matches with a rating of zero stars are referred to as a "DUD" and an average match tends to score around a ** (2) rating. All ratings can only be considered subjective and this page is designed purely for reference purposes.
Carmelo Hayes during 2019
Promotion Search: All • NXT • WWE Year Search: All • 2015 • 2016 • 2017 • 2018 • 2019 • 2020 • 2021 • 2022
Matches Shown: 1 to 46 of 46 (first • prev • next • last) ... Results per page: 10 • 25 • 50 • 100 • 250 • All ... Sort: newest first • oldest first ... Title Matches: Click to View
| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) | Rating | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 WWE Friday Night SmackdownJan 30th 2026 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Rey Fenix | WWE United States Championship | ***¾ (3.75) | |
 WWE Friday Night SmackdownJan 23rd 2026 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Ilja Dragunov | WWE United States Championship | ***¾ (3.75) | |
 WWE Friday Night SmackdownJan 16th 2026 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Leon Slater | WWE United States Championship | **** (4.00) | |
 WWE Friday Night SmackdownJan 9th 2026 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Shinsuke Nakamura | WWE United States Championship | ***¾ (3.75) | |
 WWE Friday Night SmackdownJan 2nd 2026 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano | WWE United States Championship | **** (4.00) | |
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Dec 5th 2025 | Ilja Dragunov (c) | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | WWE United States Championship | ***½ (3.5) | |
| WWE Monday Night Raw Nov 24th 2025 | Gunther | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | ****¼ (4.25) | ||
| NXT TV #680 - Homecoming Sep 16th 2025 | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Jun 13th 2025 | Randy Orton | def. (pin) | Aleister Black, Carmelo Hayes, L.A. Knight | fatal 4-way | ***½ (3.5) | |
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown May 30th 2025 | Andrade | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes, Jacob Fatu | triple-threat | ***½ (3.5) | |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2025 Feb 1st 2025 | Jey Uso | def. | A.J. Styles, Andrade, Braun Strowman, Bron Breakker, Carmelo Hayes, Chad Gable, CM Punk, Damian Priest, Dominik Mysterio, Drew McIntyre, Finn Bálor, IShowSpeed, Jacob Fatu, Jimmy Uso, Joe Hendry, John Cena, L.A. Knight, Logan Paul, Ludwig Kaiser, Otis, Penta, Rey Mysterio, Roman Reigns, Sami Zayn, Santos Escobar, Seth Rollins, Sheamus, Shinsuke Nakamura, The Miz | 30-man Royal Rumble | ****½ (4.5) | |
| WWE Crown Jewel 2024 Nov 2nd 2024 | L.A. Knight (c) | def. (pin) | Andrade, Carmelo Hayes | triple-threat | WWE United States Championship | ***¾ (3.75) |
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Sep 27th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Andrade | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Aug 30th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Andrade | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Aug 16th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Andrade | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Aug 2nd 2024 | Andrade | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Jul 19th 2024 | Andrade | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| WWE Money In The Bank 2024 Jul 6th 2024 | Drew McIntyre | def. | Andrade, Carmelo Hayes, Chad Gable, Jey Uso, L.A. Knight | "Money In The Bank" ladder (6-way) | **** (4.00) | |
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown May 17th 2024 | Randy Orton | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| NXT Stand & Deliver 2024 Apr 6th 2024 | Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| NXT Vengeance Day 2024 Feb 4th 2024 | Baron Corbin & Bron Breakker | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| NXT TV #595 Jan 30th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Cruz Del Toro & Joaquin Wilde | **** (4.00) | ||
| WWE Royal Rumble 2024 Jan 27th 2024 | Cody Rhodes | def. | Andrade, Austin Theory, Bobby Lashley, Bron Breakker, Bronson Reed, Carlito, Carmelo Hayes, CM Punk, Damian Priest, Dominik Mysterio, Drew McIntyre, Finn Bálor, Grayson Waller, Gunther, Ivar, JD McDonagh, Jey Uso, Jimmy Uso, Karrion Kross, Kofi Kingston, Ludwig Kaiser, Omos, Pat McAfee, R-Truth, Ricochet, Sami Zayn, Santos Escobar, Shinsuke Nakamura, The Miz | 30-man Royal Rumble | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| NXT Deadline 2023 Dec 9th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Lexis King | *** (3.00) | ||
| NXT TV #582 - Halloween Havoc 2023 - Day 2 Oct 31st 2023 | Ilja Dragunov (c) | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | NXT Championship | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| NXT No Mercy 2023 Sep 30th 2023 | Ilja Dragunov | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes (c) | NXT Championship (title change) | ****¾ (4.75) | |
| NXT Great American Bash 2023 Jul 30th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Ilja Dragunov | NXT Championship | ****¾ (4.75) | |
| NXT TV #564 - Gold Rush - Day 2 Jun 27th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Baron Corbin | NXT Championship | ***½ (3.5) | |
| NXT Battleground 2023 May 28th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Bron Breakker | NXT Championship | **** (4.00) | |
| NXT Stand & Deliver 2023 Apr 1st 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Bron Breakker (c) | NXT Championship (title change) | ***¼ (3.25) | |
| NXT TV #547 Feb 28th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Tyler Bate | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| NXT Vengeance Day 2023 Feb 4th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Apollo Crews | 2 out of 3 falls | ***¼ (3.25) | |
| NXT TV #541 Jan 17th 2023 | Apollo Crews & Axiom | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| NXT TV #537 Taping Dec 14th 2022 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Axiom | ****¼ (4.25) | ||
| NXT Deadline Dec 10th 2022 | Grayson Waller | def. | Axiom, Carmelo Hayes, JD McDonagh, Joe Gacy | Iron Survivor Challenge | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| NXT Halloween Havoc 2022 Oct 22nd 2022 | Wes Lee | def. | Carmelo Hayes, Nathan Frazer, Oro Mensah, Von Wagner | ladder (5-way) | NXT North American Championship (title change) | ****¼ (4.25) |
| NXT Worlds Collide 2022 Sep 4th 2022 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Ricochet | NXT North American Championship | ****½ (4.5) | |
| NXT TV #509 Jun 7th 2022 | Apollo Crews & Solo Sikoa | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes & Grayson Waller | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| NXT In Your House 2022 Jun 4th 2022 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Cameron Grimes (c) | NXT North American Championship (title change) | ***¾ (3.75) | |
| NXT TV #504 - Spring Breakin' May 3rd 2022 | Cameron Grimes (c) | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes, Solo Sikoa | triple-threat | NXT North American Championship | **** (4.00) |
| NXT Stand and Deliver '22 Apr 2nd 2022 | Cameron Grimes | def. | Carmelo Hayes (c), Grayson Waller, Santos Escobar, Solo Sikoa | ladder (5-way) | NXT North American Championship (title change) | ****¼ (4.25) |
| NXT TV #495 Mar 1st 2022 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | draw (pin) | Pete Dunne | NXT North American Championship | ***½ (3.5) | |
| NXT TV #493 - Vengeance Day Feb 15th 2022 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Cameron Grimes | NXT North American Championship | ***½ (3.5) | |
| NXT TV #487 - New Year's Evil 2022 Jan 4th 2022 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Roderick Strong (c) | NXT North American Championship NXT Cruiserweight Championship (title change) | **** (4.00) | |
| NXT WarGames 2021 Dec 5th 2021 | Bron Breakker & Carmelo Hayes & Grayson Waller & Tony D'Angelo | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & L.A. Knight & Pete Dunne & Tommaso Ciampa | WarGames | ****¾ (4.75) | |
| NXT TV #481 Nov 23rd 2021 | Carmelo Hayes (c) | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano, Pete Dunne | three-way | NXT North American Championship | ***½ (3.5) |
- this page (http://www.profightdb.com/wrestler-star-ratings/carmelo-hayes-12054.html)
- the Internet Wrestling Database homepage (www.profightdb.com)