| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CZW Dojo Wars 36
Jul 15th 2015 | Brittany Blake | def. | Willow Monet | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 40: The Last Blitz of Zandig
Aug 12th 2015 | Billy Buckaroo & David John Willard & Ken Phoenix & Mike McCallister | def. | Blackwater & Jeff Cannonball & Josh Adams & Willow Monet | 8-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 41
Aug 19th 2015 | America Monroe & Brittany Blake & Willow Monet | def. | Conor Claxton & Frankie Pickard & Joe Gacy | 6-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 43
Sep 2nd 2015 | Willow Monet | def. | America Monroe | | |
CZW Dojo Wars 45
Sep 16th 2015 | Ben Ortiz & Curt Robinson & Joe Gacy & Penelope Ford | def. | Dan O'Hare & Jeff Cannonball & Laszlo Arpad & Willow Monet | 8-person tag | |
CZW Dojo Wars 50: Champion vs. Champion
Oct 21st 2015 | Penelope Ford & Sozio | def. (pin) | Pectoral Poseidon & Willa Monet | | |
CHIKARA National Pro Wrestling Day 2016
Feb 6th 2016 | Estonian ThunderFrog | def. | Mike Verna, Rock Lobster, Willow Nightingale | four-way elimination | |
GCW Hasbrouck Heights Show
Apr 8th 2016 | Deonna Purrazzo | def. | Karen Yu, Miranda Vionette, Willow Nightingale | four-way elimination | |
WWR Project XX
Apr 10th 2016 | Sonya Strong | def. | Davienne, Miranda Vionette, Willow Nightingale | four-way | |
WWR Identity Crisis
Mar 4th 2017 | Willow Nightingale | def. (pin) | Skylar | | |
HOG New World Rising
Apr 22nd 2017 | Sonya Strong & Willow Nightingale | def. | Sumie Sakai & Violette | | |
WSU Battle Tested
May 13th 2017 | LuFisto | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
WWR The Show Must Go On
Aug 20th 2017 | Willow Nightingale | def. | Vanity | | |
WSU King & Queen of the Ring 2017
Sep 9th 2017 | Blackwater & Su Yung | def. | Anthony Bennett & Willow Nightingale | | |
Limitless Question The Answers
Sep 22nd 2017 | Skylar | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
WWR Adios Aurora
Oct 8th 2017 | Willow Nightingale | def. | Elena Pogosyan | | |
Limitless Hybrid Moments
Nov 3rd 2017 | Terra Calaway | def. | Ashley Vox, Davienne, Kennedi Copeland, Skylar, Willow Nightingale | 6-way scramble | |
WWR Tournament For Tomorrow
Nov 26th 2017 | Karen Q. | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
RISE 6: Brutality
Dec 1st 2017 | Hyan & Maritza Janett | def. | Trixie Tash & Willow Nightingale | | |
RISE 6.5: Throttle
Dec 2nd 2017 | Dust | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
Queens of Combat #20
Jan 20th 2018 | Savannah Evans | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
Queens of Combat #21
Jan 20th 2018 | Priscilla Kelly | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
WWR Five Year Plan
Jan 28th 2018 | Solo Darling | def. | Willow Nightingale | | |
WWR Five Year Plan
Jan 28th 2018 | Jordynne Grace | def. | Alexxis, Davienne, Delmi Exo, Deonna Purrazzo, Faye Jackson, Gillian Leigh, Holidead, Karen Q., LuFisto, Mistress Belmont, Penelope Ford, Skylar, Solo Darling, Sonya Strong, Taeler Hendrix, Tasha Steelz, Terra Calaway, Tessa Blanchard, Willow Nightingale | Rumble | |
Queens of Combat #23
Mar 24th 2018 | Faye Jackson & Jordynne Grace & Willow Nightingale | def. (DQ) | Maria Manic & Penelope Ford & Savannah Evans | 6-person tag | |
Willow Nightingale