| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Legends of Wrestling Detroit Show
Apr 20th 2019 | Tito Santana | def. | Drew Anderson | | |
PWS Fight Night
Mar 6th 2015 | Jos A & Jos B & Tito Santana | vs. | Antonio Nixon & Philip Simon II & Val Delamorte | 6-person tag | |
PWS Fight-Mare Before Christmas
Dec 7th 2012 | Tito Santana | def. | Mantaur | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 1
Sep 14th 2012 | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Ultramantis Black | def. | Kazuaki Mihara & The Mysterious And Handsome Stranger & Tito Santana | 6-person tag | |
 Pro Wrestling Superstars WrestleReunion 8
Apr 14th 2012 | Tito Santana | def. | Shawn Spears | | |
Pro Wrestling Superstars Tribute to CWF
Mar 31st 2012 | Tito Santana | def. (pin) | Honky Tonk Man | | |
JCW Legends & Icons
Aug 12th 2011 | Greg Valentine | def. | Tito Santana | steel cage | |
PWG Kurt Russellreunion 2: The Reunioning
Jan 29th 2011 | Roddy Piper | def. | Barry Orton, Bob Orton Jr., Chavo Guerrero Sr., Cruel Connection I, Danny Davis, Jimmy Hart, Mando Guerrero, Mike Graham, Rock Riddle, Savio Vega, Sean Morley, Shane Douglas, Tatanka, Terry Funk, The Barbarian, The Warlord, Tito Santana, Vampiro | Battle Royal | |
WSU/NWS The Awesome Challenge
Dec 12th 2009 | Tito Santana | def. | Kevin Matthews | | |
JCW Bloodymania
Aug 12th 2007 | Mad Man Pondo & Necro Butcher | def. | Human Tornado & Zach Gowen, Axl Rotten & Ian Rotten, Brutus Beefcake & Greg Valentine, Alofa & Samu, Akira Raijin & Brute Issei, Damaja & Doug Basham, Jorge Santana & Tito Santana | 8 Team Tag Team Elimination | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
WrestleReunion #3: When Legends Collide
Sep 10th 2005 | Greg Valentine | def. | Tito Santana (c) | | IWA Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
WrestleReunion #2
Aug 27th 2005 | Tito Santana | def. | Greg Valentine (c) | | IWA Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
WCW Nitro
Jan 10th 2000 | Tito Santana | def. (pin) | Jeff Jarrett | "Dungeon" | |
WCW/AAA When Worlds Collide
Nov 6th 1994 | 2 Cold Scorpio & Pegasus Kid & Tito Santana | def. (pin) | Blue Panther & Jerry Estrada & La Parka | 6-person tag | |
WWF WWF Live
Aug 12th 1993 | Bastion Booger | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #358
Jul 6th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Barry Hardy | | |
WWF MSG Show (Jun '93)
Jun 12th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Papa Shango | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw
Jun 7th 1993 | Adam Bomb | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #353
May 25th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Burt Centeno | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #352
May 24th 1993 | Mr. Hughes | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
 WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 15
Apr 25th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
 WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 14
Apr 24th 1993 | El Matador | def. (DQ) | Doink the Clown (Borne) | | |
 WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 13
Apr 23rd 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 12
Apr 22nd 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
 WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 10
Apr 20th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 9
Apr 19th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 7
Apr 18th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 5
Apr 16th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
 WWF European Spring Tour '93 - Day 3
Apr 14th 1993 | Doink the Clown (Borne) | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #348
Apr 6th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Reno Riggins | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #345
Apr 6th 1993 | Razor Ramon | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #343
Apr 6th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Louie Spicolli | | |
WWF WrestleMania IX
Apr 4th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Papa Shango | dark
| |
WWF MSG Show (Mar '93)
Mar 21st 1993 | Jerry Lawler | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #344
Mar 9th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Dale Wolfe | | |
WWF Superstars of Wrestling Taping #341
Mar 8th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | The Brooklyn Brawler | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Mar 1st 1993 | Irwin R. Schyster & Ted DiBiase | def. (pin) | El Matador & Virgil | | |
WWF Monday Night Raw Taping
Feb 1st 1993 | Razor Ramon | def. (pin) | Bob Backlund, Damien Demento, El Matador, Giant Gonzalez, Iron Mike Sharpe, Kamala, Kim Chee, Koko B Ware, Owen Hart, Shawn Michaels, Skinner, Tatanka, Terry Taylor, The Berzerker, Typhoon | battle royale (16 man) | |
WWF MSG Show (Jan '93) : Headlock On Hunger Charity Show
Jan 29th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Skinner | | |
WWF Royal Rumble '93
Jan 24th 1993 | Yokozuna | def. | Bob Backlund, Brian Knobbs, Carlos Colon, Damien Demento, Earthquake, El Matador, Fatu, Genichiro Tenryu, Irwin R. Schyster, Jerry Lawler, Jerry Sags, Koko B Ware, Max Moon, Mr. Perfect, Owen Hart, Papa Shango, Randy Savage, Repo Man, Ric Flair, Rick Martel, Samu, Skinner, Tatanka, Ted DiBiase, Terry Taylor, The Berzerker, The Undertaker, Typhoon, Virgil | 30-man Royal Rumble | |
WWF Monday Night Raw
Jan 18th 1993 | Ric Flair | draw (NC) | El Matador | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #333
Jan 4th 1993 | El Matador | def. (pin) | The Predator | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #320
Oct 13th 1992 | Razor Ramon | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
WWF MSG Show (Sep '92)
Sep 11th 1992 | The Mountie | def. (pin) | El Matador | | |
WWF WWF Live
Sep 10th 1992 | The Mountie | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF WWF Live
Sep 8th 1992 | The Mountie | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF WWF Live
Sep 7th 1992 | The Mountie | def. | El Matador | | |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #316
Sep 2nd 1992 | El Matador | def. (CO) | Kamala | | |
WWF SummerSlam '92
Aug 29th 1992 | Papa Shango | def. (pin) | El Matador | dark
| |
WWF Wrestling Challenge Taping #312
Aug 11th 1992 | El Matador | def. (pin) | Louie Spicolli | | |
Tito Santana