| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AEW Dynamite #273 - Dynamite on 34th Street Taping
Dec 22nd 2024 | Kazuchika Okada | def. (pin) | Shelton Benjamin | Continental Classic Blue League Match | |
AEW Collision #74 - Christmas Collision
Dec 21st 2024 | Daniel Garcia | def. (pin) | Shelton Benjamin | Continental Classic Blue League Match | |
AEW Dynamite #272 - Holiday Bash 2024
Dec 18th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. (pin) | The Beast Mortos | Continental Classic Blue League Match | |
AEW Dynamite #270
Dec 4th 2024 | Kyle Fletcher | def. (pin) | Shelton Benjamin | Continental Classic Blue League Match | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade SuperShow 2024
Nov 30th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Mike Bailey | | |
AEW Dynamite #269 - Thanksgiving Eve Dynamite
Nov 27th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. (pin) | Mark Briscoe | Continental Classic Blue League Match | |
AEW Collision #70 Taping
Nov 14th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. (pin) | Komander | | |
AEW Dynamite #265 - Fright Night Dynamite
Oct 30th 2024 | Swerve Strickland | def. (pin) | Shelton Benjamin | | |
Battleground Championship Wrestling A Nightmare On S. Swanson St.
Oct 26th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Rich Swann | | |
AEW Dynamite #264
Oct 23rd 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. (pin) | Sammy Guevara | | |
AEW Dynamite #263
Oct 16th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. (pin) | Lio Rush | | |
 The Crash Crash Wrestling
Oct 4th 2024 | Alberto El Patron | def. | DMT Azul, Shelton Benjamin | three-way | |
DEFY By Design
Sep 20th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Kevin Knight | | |
West Coast Pro/DPW/Prestige Untouchable
Jul 20th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Titus Alexander | | |
Prestige Combat Clash PDX
Jul 12th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Mike Santana | | |
 PROGRESS Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2024 - Day 2
May 27th 2024 | Man Like DeReiss | def. (DQ) | Shelton Benjamin | | |
PROGRESS Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2024 - Day 1
May 26th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Leon Slater | | |
Prestige Alive Or Just Breathing
May 16th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Tom Lawlor | | |
 OPW Australian Stampede
Apr 13th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Tommy Knight | | |
 WWC La Hora De La Verdad 2024
Mar 9th 2024 | Shelton Benjamin | def. | Gilbert | | |
WWE Main Event Taping
Sep 11th 2023 | Erik & Ivar | def. | Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin | | |
 WWE WWE Live SuperShow
Aug 20th 2023 | A.J. Styles & Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows | def. | Austin Theory & Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin | 6-person tag | |
WWE WWE Live SuperShow
Aug 19th 2023 | A.J. Styles & Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows | def. | Austin Theory & Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin | 6-person tag | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Jun 19th 2023 | Sanga & Veer | def. (pin) | Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin | | |
WWE Monday NIght Raw
May 15th 2023 | Mustafa Ali | def. | Akira Tozawa, Angel, Apollo Crews, Baron Corbin, Bronson Reed, Cedric Alexander, Chad Gable, Dexter Lumis, Dolph Ziggler, Elias, Erik, Humberto, Ivar, JD McDonagh, Johnny Gargano, ma.çé, Matt Riddle, mån.sôör, Otis, Ricochet, Riddick Moss, Shelton Benjamin, Von Wagner, Xyon Quinn | battle royale | |
Shelton Benjamin