| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AULL/DTU 5th Anniversary Show
Dec 16th 2016 | Hacker (c) | def. | Príncipe Halcón, Tribal | three-way | NWG Azteca Title
|
 Alpha-1 Final Act 7
Nov 27th 2016 | Josh Alexander | def. | Scotty O'Shea | "I Quit" | |
Smash (Canada) This is Smash 4th Anniversary Tour - Day 3
Nov 13th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Joe Hendry, John Greed, Shane Sabre | four-way | |
Alpha-1 A Long Halloween
Oct 30th 2016 | Joey Kings | def. | Scotty O'Shea | grudge match | |
Smash (Canada) The Legend of Smash
Oct 23rd 2016 | Brent Banks | def. | Scotty O'Shea | steel cage | |
Smash (Canada)/PROGRESS Smash vs. PROGRESS - Day 2
Sep 18th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Brent Banks | Fans Bring the Keyboards | |
Alpha-1 Matrats 2
Sep 18th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Joey Kings & Josh Alexander | handicap tag | |
Smash (Canada)/PROGRESS Smash vs. PROGRESS - Day 1
Sep 17th 2016 | Mark Andrews | def. | Scotty O'Shea | | |
DWW Summer Heat 2016
Aug 28th 2016 | Mike Rollins | def. | Dustin Quicksilver, El Loco, Phil Atlas, Scotty O'Shea, TARIK | Anything Goes Six Pack Challenge | |
Smash (Canada) Super Showdown IV
Aug 21st 2016 | Brent Banks | def. | Scotty O'Shea | | |
Smash (Canada) Uncensored
Jul 30th 2016 | Evil Uno & Stupefied | def. | Mathieu St. Jacques & Thomas Dubois, Brent Banks & Scotty O'Shea | three-way tag | |
Smash (Canada)/CHIKARA Smash vs CHIKARA
Jul 24th 2016 | Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | def. | Brent Banks & Scotty O'Shea | | |
DWW Night of Glory II
Jul 17th 2016 | Brent Banks | def. | Dustin Quicksilver, Phil Atlas, Scotty O'Shea | no disqualification four-way | |
Alpha-1 The Purge
Jul 3rd 2016 | Josh Alexander & Kobe Durst | def. | Ethan Page & Scotty O'Shea | | |
Smash (Canada) Infinity Project - Chapter 9/10
Jun 11th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Kobe Durst | | |
Smash (Canada) Barry's Bay Beatdown
Jun 4th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Idris Abraham | | |
Smash (Canada) Gold 2016
May 29th 2016 | Brent Banks & Scotty O'Shea | def. | John Greed & Sebastian Suave | | |
House of Hardcore #14
May 7th 2016 | C. J. Mirror & Hacker Scotty & Psycho Mike | def. | Adam Brooks & Ben Ortiz & Beta | 6-person tag | |
Alpha-1 Watch The Throne IV
Apr 10th 2016 | Seleziya Sparx | def. (pin) | Brent Banks, Cheech, Scotty O'Shea (c) | four-way | A1 Alpha Male Title
(title change) |
Smash (Canada) Forest City Rampage
Apr 9th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | TARIK | | |
Smash (Canada) Infinity Project - Chapter 7/8
Apr 2nd 2016 | Mike Rollins | def. | Scotty O'Shea | | |
Smash (Canada) Any Given Sunday 4
Mar 20th 2016 | Kevin Bennett | def. | Brent Banks, Scotty O'Shea | three-way | |
Smash (Canada) Live in North Bay
Mar 12th 2016 | Mike Rollins & Pepper Parks | def. | Alessandro Del Bruno & Scotty O'Shea | | |
Smash (Canada) Brock Get Smashed
Mar 11th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Joey Ryan | | |
Smash (Canada) Fanshawe Get Smashed
Mar 10th 2016 | Scotty O'Shea | def. | Brent Banks, TARIK | three-way | |
Alpha-1 Big Year 7
Feb 21st 2016 | Scotty O'Shea (c) | draw (NC) | Brent Banks | | A1 Alpha Male Title
|
DWW Carnage 2016
Jan 31st 2016 | R. J. City | draw (NC) | Brent Banks, Joe Coleman, Mathieu St. Jacques, Matt Burns, Rude Boy Riley, Scotty O'Shea, Stone Rockwell, Thomas Dubois, Tyler Tirva, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
DWW Carnage 2016
Jan 31st 2016 | Lio Rush | def. | Scotty O'Shea | | |
Smash (Canada)/CZW Smash vs. CZW
Jan 16th 2016 | D. J. Hyde | def. | Scotty O'Shea | | |
Scotty O'Shea during 2016