| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 F1RST Saturday Night Nitro 2023
Sep 9th 2023 | Free-Range Kara | def. | Big O. Possum, El Funky Fox, Lore, Renny D, Rob Justice, Ryan Cruz, Scott Story, Shane Black, ThunderFrog | Rumble | |
F1RST Pryes Free-For-All
Jul 23rd 2023 | Big O. Possum & El Funky Fox & Rodeo Randy & Super ThunderFrog | def. | Heavy Metal Lore & Paul Reed & Scott Story & Victor Analog | 8-person tag | |
F1RST The Ranger Rumble
Apr 28th 2023 | Ronnie the Ranger | def. | Big O. Possum, Connor Hopkins, Funky Fox, Jordan, Matt Honey, Paul Reed, Ryan Cruz, Scott Story, Shane Black | Rumble | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza
Jan 13th 2023 | Darin Corbin (c) | def. | Heavy Metal Lore, Kyle Pro, Lince Dorado, Scott Story, Shane Black | 6-Way | F1RST Wrestling Wrestlepalooza Title
|
F1RST Wrestlepalooza XVIII
Oct 1st 2021 | Super ThunderFrog | def. | Brandon Gore, Renny D, Rob Justice, Rylie Jackson, Scott Story | 6-way scramble | |
F1RST Saturday Night Nitro
Mar 7th 2020 | Scott Story & Sebastian Taylor | def. | Bill Williams & Petey Brown | | |
F1RST Up-Down Presents Open Streets Slam 2018
Jun 10th 2018 | Ryan Cruz | def. | Kody Rice, Rob James, Rob Justice, Scott Story, Venom | 6-Way | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza XII
Jun 2nd 2018 | Ryan Cruz | def. | Chaos 300, Ice Cream Jr., Scott Story, The Space Monkey, Wildcat | 6-way scramble | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza XI
Jan 6th 2018 | Super ThunderFrog & Wildcat | def. | Rob Justice & Scott Story | | |
F1RST Live at Uptown VFW
Dec 7th 2017 | Ryan Cruz | def. | Brubaker, Giant Griffin, Scott Story, Super ThunderFrog, Wildcat | 6-Way | |
F1RST Live at the Cabooze Bar
Sep 7th 2017 | Ryan Cruz | def. | Scott Story, Super ThunderFrog, Wildcat | four-way | |
F1RST Up-Down Presents Open Streets Slam 2017
Jun 4th 2017 | Chris Jordan | def. | Scott Story | | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza X
Jun 3rd 2017 | Venom | def. | Jake Parnell, Scott Story | three-way | |
F1RST Mill City Fights
Sep 10th 2016 | Kody Rice | def. | Rob James, Rob Justice, Scott Story, Venom, Wildcat | 6-way scramble | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza at Wooly's 2
Jun 17th 2016 | Nate Redwing (c) | def. | Ryan Slade, Scott Story, Venom | four-way | 3XW Heavyweight Title
|
F1RST matches wrestled by Scott Story