| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 DEFY Dark Horse
Dec 18th 2021 | Schaff | def. | No Way | street fight | |
AAW Windy City Classic XVI
Nov 26th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Brayden Lee, Gringo Loco, Hartenbower, Jah-C, Jake Lander, Ren Jones, Storm Grayson | ladder (8-way) | |
DEFY Brutalist
Nov 20th 2021 | Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | def. | Ethan HD & Schaff | | |
AAW Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament 2021 - Day 2
Oct 30th 2021 | Mat Fitchett | def. | Schaff | | |
AAW Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament 2021 - Day 2
Oct 30th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Alexander Hammerstone | | |
AAW Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament 2021 - Day 1
Oct 29th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Hakim Zane | | |
DEFY Dangerous
Oct 10th 2021 | Brody King & Eddie Kingston | def. | Ethan HD & Schaff | No Disqualification Tornado Tag | |
AAW Defining Moment 2021
Oct 1st 2021 | Fred Yehi & Josh Alexander | def. | Mat Fitchett & Schaff | | |
DEFY Mad Kingdom
Sep 25th 2021 | Jon Moxley | def. | Schaff | | |
AAW Destination Chicago 2021
Sep 2nd 2021 | Hakim Zane | def. | Ace Perry, Frontman Jah, Rich Swann, Schaff | 5-way | |
DEFY Leviathan - Day 2
Aug 28th 2021 | Lance Archer | def. | Schaff | | |
DEFY Leviathan - Day 1
Aug 27th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Alexander Hammerstone, Calvin Tankman | three-way | |
AAW Savages And Kings
Aug 7th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Jake Something | | |
AAW United We Stand 2021
Jul 9th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Jake Crist | | |
AAW Crush & Destroy
Jun 11th 2021 | Schaff | def. | AJZ | | |
AAW Alive #12 Taping
May 22nd 2021 | Schaff | def. | Calvin Tankman | | |
AAW Take No Prisoners 2021
May 7th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Damian Chambers, Jason Page | three-way | |
AAW Alive #9 Taping
May 7th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Storm Grayson | | |
AAW Alive #7
Apr 24th 2021 | Schaff | def. | Davey Vega | | |
DEFY Kings of Crash
Feb 21st 2020 | Randy Myers | def. | Schaff (c) | | DEFY World Championship
(title change) |
DEFY Year 3
Jan 31st 2020 | Schaff (c) | def. | Artemis Spencer | ladder | DEFY World Championship
|
DEFY Age Of War
Jan 3rd 2020 | Artemis Spencer & Jacob Fatu & Josef | def. | Ethan HD & Mike Santiago & Schaff | 6-person tag | |
DEFY/PCW ULTRA/PROGRESS The Wrestle Summit 2 - Day 2
Dec 1st 2019 | Schaff (c) | def. | Hammerstone | | DEFY World Championship
|
DEFY/PCW ULTRA/PROGRESS The Wrestle Summit 2 - Day 1
Nov 30th 2019 | Brian Cook & Hammerstone & Jorel Nelson & Kevin Cook & Travis Williams | def. | Cody Chhun & Guillermo Rosas & Judas Icarus & Randy Myers & Schaff | 10-person tag | |
DEFY Fight For This
Oct 19th 2019 | Schaff (c) | def. | Tom Lawlor | | DEFY World Championship
|
PCW ULTRA Into the Void
Oct 18th 2019 | Hammerstone | def. | Schaff | | |
DEFY Doomsayer
Sep 27th 2019 | Schaff (c) | def. | Joey Janela | | DEFY World Championship
|
DEFY Defyance Forever
Aug 23rd 2019 | Schaff | def. | Artemis Spencer (c) | | DEFY World Championship
(title change) |
PCW ULTRA No Quarter
Aug 8th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Brian Pillman Jr., Douglas James | three-way | |
DEFY Super 8XGP - Day 2
Jul 27th 2019 | Ethan HD & Mike Santiago | def. | Ativalu & Kaimana, Guillermo Rosas & Super Crazy, Randy Myers & Schaff | four-way tag | |
DEFY Super 8XGP - Day 1
Jul 26th 2019 | Christopher Daniels | def. | Schaff | | |
DEFY RIOT
Jun 16th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Cody Chhun, Mike Santiago, Travis Williams | four-way | |
DEFY Onslaught
Jun 15th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Travis Williams | | |
PCW ULTRA Mind Crawler
Jun 14th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Eli Everfly, Lucas Riley, Matt Vandagriff | four-way | |
DEFY Into The Fire
May 10th 2019 | Penta el Zero M & Rey Fenix | def. | Chris Ridgeway & Schaff | | |
Prestige Viva La Raza
May 3rd 2019 | Bull James | def. (DQ) | Schaff | | |
DEFY Wolves At The Door
Apr 13th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Alexander Hammerstone | chain | |
DEFY Dragon Spirit
Mar 8th 2019 | Schaff | def. | Jaxon Stone | | |
DEFY Slamtown
Feb 9th 2019 | Alexander Hammerstone | draw (NC) | Schaff | | |
DEFY Never Dies - 2nd Anniversary
Jan 19th 2019 | Randy Myers & Schaff & Shane Strickland | def. | Christopher Daniels & Frankie Kazarian & Scorpio Sky | 6-person tag | |
DEFY On Edge
Dec 14th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Brody King | | |
Prestige Rise Or Die Trying 2018
Dec 8th 2018 | Sonico | def. | Julian Whyt, Mike Santiago, Schaff | four-way | |
DEFY City of Thorns
Nov 24th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Willie Mack | | |
DEFY Dia De Los Muertos
Oct 27th 2018 | Shane Strickland (c) | def. | Schaff | | DEFY World Championship
|
Prestige 7: Revenge I Seek
Oct 12th 2018 | Dr. Kliever & Schaff | def. | Brian Cook & Kevin Cook | | |
DEFY CLUB
Sep 8th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Jeff Cobb | | |
DEFY Defyance United
Aug 10th 2018 | WALTER (c) | def. | Schaff | | PROGRESS Title
|
DEFY Swerve Vs. Aries
Jul 20th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Darby Allin | | |
DEFY LOUD
Jul 13th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Ricky Starks | | |
DEFY Requiem
Jun 9th 2018 | Schaff | def. | Kaimana | | |
Schaff