| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WCPBTW The Reboot
Mar 8th 2025 | Chase Emery & Nick Hamrick & Shane Douglas | def. | Christopher Prince & Josh Benson & Robby Starr | 6-person tag | |
WCPBTW The Reunion 3: Cavalcade Of Legends
Mar 9th 2024 | Dillon Fulton & Jackie Fulton & Jarron Fulton | def. | N8 Mattson & Robby Starr & Wrecking Ball Legursky | street fight (6-man tag) | |
WCPBTW The Reunion 3: Cavalcade Of Legends
Mar 9th 2024 | Kerry Morton | def. | Bryant Huff, Josh Benson, Paul Burchill, Robby Starr, Sean Casey, The Iron Russian, Tommy Rich, Tony Atlas | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The Great Fall Bash 2
Sep 30th 2023 | The Boogeyman | def. | Robby Superstar | | |
WCPBTW The Reunion 2: Glory Days Bash
Mar 11th 2023 | Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson | def. | Dru Skillz & Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW The Great Fall Bash
Oct 15th 2022 | The Barbarian & The Warlord | def. | Robby Starr & The Iron Russian | | |
WCPBTW The Great Fall Bash
Oct 15th 2022 | Robby Starr | def. | Bryant Huff | | |
WCPBTW Champaign County Fair
Aug 10th 2022 | Onyx (c) & Shark Boy (c) | def. | James Runyan & The Masked Super-Starr | | WCPBTW Ohio State Tag Team Titles
|
WCPBTW Champaign County Fair
Aug 10th 2022 | Onyx | draw (DDQ) | The Masked Super-Starr | | |
WCPBTW Lightning Strikes
Apr 9th 2022 | Jackie Fulton & Shane Douglas | def. | N8 Mattson & Robby Starr & The Iron Russian | handicap tag | |
WCPBTW Lightning Strikes
Apr 9th 2022 | Onyx | def. | Amos Awakening, Austin Jefferson Vest, Bushwhacker Luke, Chris Cannon, Kerry Morton, Robby Starr, Tony Atlas | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The Reunion: A Homecoming
Mar 12th 2022 | Sam Houston | def. | Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW The 178th Annual Champaign County Fair
Aug 7th 2019 | Onyx | def. | Asher Knox, Jimmy Shane, Robby Starr, Sean Casey, Tyler Robinson | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The 178th Annual Champaign County Fair
Aug 7th 2019 | Onyx (c) & Tyler Robinson (c) | def. | Asher Knox & Robby Starr | | WCPBTW Ohio State Tag Team Titles
|
WCPBTW Enter The Dragon
Mar 16th 2019 | War Eagle | def. | Daltono Charloso, Eric Fallen, Lemmy San Dimas, Lord Thomas, Matt Burns, Mecha Mercenary, Robby Starr, Sean Casey, The Scottish Giant, Tony Chini | battle royale | |
WCPBTW Enter The Dragon
Mar 16th 2019 | Honky Tonk Man & War Eagle | def. | Robby Starr & Sean Casey | | |
WCPBTW November To Remember
Nov 30th 2018 | War Eagle | def. | Robby Starr | | WCPBTW Triple Crown of Wrestling Championship
(title change) |
WCPBTW Live In Chillicothe
Oct 20th 2018 | Robby Starr & The Pittsburgh Stealer #2 | def. | Tyler Robinson & War Eagle | | |
WCPBTW Live In Chillicothe
Oct 20th 2018 | Robby Starr | def. | Tyler Robinson | | |
WCPBTW Summer Spectacular
Aug 18th 2018 | Tim Horner Jr. & War Eagle | def. | Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham & Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW Summer Spectacular
Aug 18th 2018 | Robby Starr | def. | Tim Horner Jr. | | |
WCPBTW The 177th Annual Champaign County Fair
Aug 8th 2018 | Fargo Fulton | def. | Big Jim Hutchinson, Brian Pillman Jr., Eric Fallen, Robby Starr, Sean Casey | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The 177th Annual Champaign County Fair
Aug 8th 2018 | Brian Pillman Jr. & Fargo Fulton | def. | Robby Starr & Sean Casey | | |
WCPBTW Memorial Weekend Professional Wrestling Super Show 2018
May 26th 2018 | Bobby Fulton & Nick Curry | def. | Gary Wolfe & Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW Saint Valentine's Massacre
Feb 17th 2018 | Brian Pillman Jr. | def. | Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW The First Capital End of Summer Extravaganza
Aug 18th 2017 | Onyx | def. | Big Jim Hutchinson, Cody Hawk, Fargo Fulton, N8 Mattson, Robby Starr, Sean Casey, Shane Storm, Tyler Robinson | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The First Capital End of Summer Extravaganza
Aug 18th 2017 | Bill Dundee & Fargo Fulton & Tyler Robinson | def. | Cody Hawk & Robby Starr & Shane Storm | 6-person tag | |
WCPBTW The Night Of The Road Warrior
Jan 14th 2017 | Sean Casey | def. | Cody Hawk, Matt Taylor, Robby Starr, Shane Storm, The Iron Russian, War Eagle | 7-Way Blindfold Elimination Match | |
WCPBTW The Night Of The Road Warrior
Jan 14th 2017 | Sean Casey & War Eagle | def. | Robby Starr & Shane Storm | | |
WCPBTW Holiday Havoc - Night Of the Stinger
Dec 2nd 2016 | Sean Casey | def. | Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW The Gathering: Night Of The Living Legends
Aug 12th 2016 | Jason Kincaid | def. | Cody Hawk, Matt Brannigan, Onyx, Robby Starr, Rusty Shank, Sean Casey, Sherman Tank, The Masked Assassin | battle royale | |
WCPBTW The Gathering: Night Of The Living Legends
Aug 12th 2016 | Sean Casey | def. | Robby Starr | | |
WCPBTW AdenaMania 2016
Mar 12th 2016 | Onyx | def. | Cody Hawk, Iron Russian #1, Iron Russian #2, Robby Starr, Sean Casey, Tyler Robinson, Unknown Participants | battle royale | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Memorial Show
Sep 26th 2011 | Robby Starr | def. | Chris Kole, Christian Vaughn | three-way | |
Robby Starr