| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 The Crash 5th Anniversary Show
Nov 26th 2016 | Jeff Hardy & Rey Fenix & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. | Jeff Cobb & Nicho El Millonario & Teddy Hart | 6-person tag | |
 AAA Star Battle Japan 2016
Oct 26th 2016 | Akebono & Naomichi Marufuji & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. | Brian Cage & El Texano Jr. & Pentagon Jr. | 6-person tag | |
AAA Ring & Rock StAAArs 5
Sep 16th 2016 | Brian Cage & El Mesias & Johnny Mundo | def. | Dr. Wagner Jr. & El Texano Jr. & Rey Mysterio Jr. | 6-person tag | |
AAA TripleMania XXIV
Aug 28th 2016 | Dragon Azteca Jr. & Prince Puma & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. (pin) | Marty Martinez & Mil Muertes & The Monster Matanza Cueto | 6-person tag | |
 WWC Noche De Campeones 2016
Jul 16th 2016 | Carlito Carribean Cool (c) | def. | Mr. 450, Rey Mysterio Jr. | three-way | WWC Universal Heavyweight Title
|
 Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 35: Cien
Jun 12th 2016 | The Monster Matanza Cueto | def. (pin) | Rey Mysterio | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 32: The Cueto Cup
Jun 11th 2016 | Johnny Mundo (c) | def. (pin) | Rey Mysterio | | |
AAA Lucha Libre World Cup 2016 - Day 2
Jun 5th 2016 | Dr. Wagner Jr. & Dragon Azteca Jr. & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. | MAYBACH Taniguchi & Naomichi Marufuji & Taiji Ishimori | 6-person tag | |
AAA Lucha Libre World Cup 2016 - Day 2
Jun 5th 2016 | Brian Cage & Chavo Guerrero Jr. & Johnny Mundo | def. | Dr. Wagner Jr. & Dragon Azteca Jr. & Rey Mysterio Jr. | 6-person tag | |
AAA Lucha Libre World Cup 2016 - Day 1
Jun 3rd 2016 | Dr. Wagner Jr. & Dragon Azteca Jr. & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. (pin) | Eli Drake & Ethan Carter III & Tyrus | 6-person tag | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 28: Booyaka! Booyaka! (part 3)
May 8th 2016 | Rey Mysterio | def. | P. J. Black | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 11: Aztec Warfare III
Apr 9th 2016 | Sexy Star | def. (pin) | Dr. Wagner Jr., Drago, Famous B, Jack Evans, Jeremiah Crane, Joey Ryan, Johnny Mundo, Kobra Moon, Mariposa, Marty Martinez, Mascarita Sagrada, Mil Muertes, P. J. Black, Pentagon Dark, Rey Mysterio, Ricky Mandel, Son of Havoc, The Mack, The Monster Matanza Cueto (c) | Aztec Warfare | Lucha Underground Championship
(title change) |
WrestleCon Supershow 2016
Apr 2nd 2016 | Matt Sydal & Rey Mysterio & Ricochet | def. | Brian Cage & Chris Hero & Zack Sabre Jr. | 6-person tag | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 9: Loser Leaves Lucha
Mar 27th 2016 | Rey Mysterio | def. (pin) | Chavo Guerrero Jr. | Loser Leaves Lucha Underground | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 6: The Open Road to Revenge (part 2)
Mar 26th 2016 | Pentagon Dark | def. | Chavo Guerrero Jr., Rey Mysterio Jr. | three-way | |
UR Fight iPPV
Mar 20th 2016 | Rey Mysterio | def. (pin) | Kurt Angle | 2 out of 3 falls | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 1: Wheel of Misfortune (part 1)
Mar 19th 2016 | Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. (pin) | Pentagon Dark | | |
Lucha Underground Austin Warfare
Mar 15th 2016 | Cage & Prince Puma & Rey Mysterio | def. (pin) | Jack Evans & Johnny Mundo & P. J. Black | 6-person tag | |
 QPW Sudan Power
Mar 11th 2016 | Carlito & Rey Mysterio Jr. | def. | Chris Masters & Sonjay Dutt | | |
NEW Wrestlefest XX
Mar 4th 2016 | Matt Hardy & Rey Mysterio | def. | Caleb Konley & Dalton Castle | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 26: Ultima Lucha Dos Part 3
Jan 31st 2016 | Rey Mysterio | def. (pin) | Prince Puma | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 19: Judgement Day
Jan 17th 2016 | Jack Evans (c) & Johnny Mundo (c) & P. J. Black (c) | def. (DQ) | Dragon Azteca Jr. & Prince Puma & Rey Mysterio | 6-person tag | Lucha Underground Trio Tag Team Championship
|
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 18: Enter the Mundo (part 2)
Jan 17th 2016 | Jack Evans & Johnny Mundo & P. J. Black | def. (pin) | Dragon Azteca Jr. (c) & Prince Puma (c) & Rey Mysterio (c) | 6-person tag | Lucha Underground Trio Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 20: The Contenders
Jan 16th 2016 | Fénix & Ivelisse & Johnny Mundo & King Cuerno & Pentagon Jr. & Taya | def. (pin) | Prince Puma & Rey Mysterio & Sexy Star & Son of Havoc & Texano & The Mack | 12-person tag | |
 5 Star UK Tour - Day 3
Jan 15th 2016 | Rey Mysterio & Will Ospreay & Zack Sabre Jr. | def. | Jimmy Havoc & Magnus & Marty Scurll | 6-person tag | |
5 Star UK Tour - Day 2
Jan 14th 2016 | A.J. Styles | def. | Rey Mysterio | | |
5 Star UK Tour - Day 1
Jan 13th 2016 | Rey Mysterio | def. (DQ) | Jay Lethal | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 16: Graver Consequences
Jan 10th 2016 | Dragon Azteca Jr. (c) & Prince Puma (c) & Rey Mysterio (c) | def. | Ivelisse & Johnny Mundo & Son of Havoc | 6-person tag | Lucha Underground Trio Tag Team Championship
|
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 2 Episode 14: Cage in a Cage (part 2)
Jan 10th 2016 | Dragon Azteca Jr. & Prince Puma & Rey Mysterio | def. | Angélico (c) & Ivelisse (c) & Son of Havoc (c), Fénix & Jack Evans & P. J. Black, Cortez Castro & Joey Ryan & Mr. Cisco | four-way tag | Lucha Underground Trio Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
Rey Mysterio during 2016