| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2019 - Day 1
May 8th 2019 | P. J. Black | def. (pin) | Alex Coughlin | | |
ROH Masters of the Craft 2019
Apr 14th 2019 | Bandido | def. (pin) | Carístico, Flip Gordon, P. J. Black | four-way | |
ROH Steel City Excellence 2019
Apr 13th 2019 | P. J. Black | def. | Eli Isom | | |
Bar Wrestling 33: Juiced
Apr 10th 2019 | P. J. Black | def. | Andy Brown | | |
ROH/NJPW G1 SuperCard
Apr 6th 2019 | Kenny King | def. | Bad Luck Fale, Beer City Bruiser, Brian Milonas, BUSHI, Chase Owens, Cheeseburger, Colt Cabana, Delirious, Hirooki Goto, Jonathan Gresham, Jushin Thunder Liger, King Haku, Leon St. Giovanni, Minoru Suzuki, P. J. Black, Rhett Titus, Rocky Romero, Ryusuke Taguchi, Shaheem Ali, Shingo Takagi, SHO, T. K. O'Ryan, The Great Muta, Tomohiro Ishii, Tracy Williams, Vinny Marseglia, Will Ferrara, YOH, YOSHI-HASHI | "Honor Rumble" | |
ROH Road to G1 Supercard - Day 4
Mar 31st 2019 | Kenny King | def. | P. J. Black | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 16th 2019 | Bandido | def. | P. J. Black | | |
Bar Wrestling 32: The Trouble With Tribbles
Mar 13th 2019 | P. J. Black & Taya Valkyrie | def. | Luchasaurus & Penelope Ford | | |
 Blackcraft/DWW The Ritual
Feb 23rd 2019 | Johnny Blackcraft (c) | def. | P. J. Black | | Blackcraft Heavyweight Title
|
Bar Wrestling 31: Three's Company - Day 2
Feb 21st 2019 | P. J. Black | def. | Brian Cage, Killer Kross, Rickey Shane Page | four-way | |
Bar Wrestling 30: Three's Company - Day 1
Feb 20th 2019 | Heather Monroe & Jake Atlas & Ray Rosas | def. | Kris Wolf & P. J. Black & Taya Valkyrie | 6-person tag | |
Bar Wrestling 29: Four Touchdowns in a Single Game
Jan 31st 2019 | P. J. Black & Taya Valkyrie | def. | Diamante & Maxx Stardom | | |
PCW ULTRA A2K19
Jan 18th 2019 | Johnny Ultra & P. J. Black | def. | Penta el Zero M & Rey Fenix | | |
Bar Wrestling 28: The Best City I've Ever Been To
Jan 16th 2019 | Brian Cage | def. (pin) | P. J. Black | | |
ROH Honor Reigns Supreme 2019
Jan 13th 2019 | Bandido | def. (pin) | P. J. Black | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jan 12th 2019 | Nick Aldis (c) | def. | P. J. Black | | NWA World Heavyweight Title
|
Bar Wrestling 26: Mistletoe Can Be Deadly If You Eat It
Dec 19th 2018 | P. J. Black | def. | Luchasaurus | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Dec 15th 2018 | Juice Robinson | def. (DQ) | P. J. Black | | |
Bar Wrestling 24: As You Wish
Nov 28th 2018 | P. J. Black & Taya Valkyrie | def. (pin) | Delilah Doom & Eli Everfly | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2018 - Supershow
Nov 24th 2018 | Johnny Impact & P. J. Black | def. | Juventud Guerrera & Ultimo Dragon | | |
WrestleCade 4th Annual Showcase of Champions
Nov 23rd 2018 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. | P. J. Black | | AML Title
|
ROH Survival of the Fittest 2018
Nov 4th 2018 | Marty Scurll | def. (pin) | Christopher Daniels, Guerrero Maya Jr., Hangman Page, Jonathan Gresham, P. J. Black | 6-man Mayhem Match | |
ROH Survival of the Fittest 2018
Nov 4th 2018 | P. J. Black | def. (pin) | Luchasaurus | | |
PCW ULTRA Possessed
Oct 26th 2018 | Penta el Zero M (c) | def. | P. J. Black | | PCW ULTRA Heavyweight Title
|
Bar Wrestling 20: Ain't My First Rodeo Drive!
Oct 3rd 2018 | Joey Ryan & Peter Avalon & Ray Rosas | def. | Luchasaurus & P. J. Black & Super Panda | 6-person tag | |
Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa
P.J. Black