| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 JCW Gathering of the Juggalos 2019 - Day 2
Aug 2nd 2019 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | DBA & Malcolm Monroe III | | |
JCW Bloodymania 8
Jul 26th 2014 | Hy-Zaya & Shockwave the Robot & The Weedman & Zach Gowen | def. | Breyer Wellington & Jimmy Jacobs & Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | 8-person tag | |
JCW Road to Bloodymania
Jul 25th 2014 | Hy-Zaya & The Weedman | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW Road to the Gathering Tour - Day 7
May 11th 2014 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | Bret Havoc & Kharn Alexander | | |
JCW Bloodymania 7
Aug 11th 2013 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. (pin) | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | | |
JCW Road to Bloodymania
Aug 10th 2013 | Brian Kendrick & Paul London | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW The Oddball Brawl
Feb 16th 2013 | Ring Ryda Blue (c) & Ring Ryda Red (c) | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Send In the Clowns
Jun 30th 2011 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | U-Gene & Zach Gowen | | |
JCW St. Andrews Brawl
May 4th 2011 | Ring Ryda Blue (c) & Ring Ryda Red (c) | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Lights, Camera, Bash 'Em
Apr 6th 2011 | 2 Tuff Tony & Corporal Robinson & Rhino | def. | Breyer Wellington & Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | 6-person tag | |
JCW Hatchet Attacks
Mar 26th 2011 | Madman Pondo (c) & Necro Butcher (c) | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Hardcore Hell
Mar 9th 2011 | Madman Pondo & Necro Butcher | def. | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | barbed wire, thumbtacks & ladders tag | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
JCW Flashlight Hysteria
Feb 23rd 2011 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | 2 Tuff Tony & Corporal Robinson, Breyer Wellington & Butler Geeves, Bull Pain & Isabella Smothers, Madman Pondo & Necro Butcher, Bump N' Ugly #1 & Bump N' Ugly #2, The Jailbird Man & The Weedman, Ring Ryda Blue & Ring Ryda Red | tag team battle royale | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
JCW Flashlight Hysteria
Feb 23rd 2011 | Madman Pondo & Necro Butcher | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | flashlight match (tag) | |
JCW Cold Winter Fights
Jan 19th 2011 | Mad Man Pondo & Necro Butcher | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW Vilent Night
Dec 22nd 2010 | 2 Tuff Tony & Corporal Robinson & The Jailbird Man | def. | Bull Pain & Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | 6-person tag | |
JCW Flashlight Wrestling - Hangin' with Heroes
Aug 15th 2010 | Kamala & The Weedman | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW BloodyMania IV
Aug 15th 2010 | Chris Hero & Claudio Castagnoli | def. | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c), Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe, Ring Ryda Blue & Ring Ryda Red | four-way elimination tag | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
JCW Flashlight Wrestling - Legends & Loonies
Aug 14th 2010 | Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson & Tommy Rich | def. | Kamala & Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | 6-person tag | |
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 16
Jun 12th 2010 | Corporal Robinson & The Weedman | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 15
Jun 11th 2010 | Corporal Robinson & The Weedman | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 14
Jun 9th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Shane Ballard & Shannon Ballard | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 13
Jun 7th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | D-Unit & T-Rent | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 12
Jun 4th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Badd Blood & LTP | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 11
Jun 1st 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Braddock & Matagi | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 10
May 31st 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Derek Stone & Prodigy | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 9
May 29th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Mark Sterling & Superstar Steve | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 8
May 28th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Chuck Wagner & Mike Nolan | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 7
May 27th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Brian Gott & Derek Cornell | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 6
May 26th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Darin Corbin & Ryan Cruz | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 5
May 24th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Ring Ryda Blue & Ring Ryda Red | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 4
May 22nd 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Matt Magnum & Vinny Marseglia | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 3
May 17th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Man Scout Bo & Man Scout Brice | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 2
May 16th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Dave Crist & Jake Crist | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Happy Daze Tour - Day 1
May 15th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Bump N' Ugly #1 & Bump N' Ugly #2, Jobber #1 & Jobber #2 | triple-threat tag | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Pontiac Show (April '10)
Apr 6th 2010 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Bryan Skyline & Jeff Brooks | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Oddball Bonanza
Mar 20th 2010 | Maifu & Saifu | def. | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
JCW Pontiac Show (December '09)
Dec 19th 2009 | Pauly Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | def. | Mad Man Pondo & Necro Butcher | | JCW Tag Team Titles
|
JCW Bloodymania III - Day 2
Aug 9th 2009 | Billy Bong & The Weedman | def. | Brandon Thomaselli (c) & Vito Thomaselli (c) | | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
IWA-MS Truth, Justice, and the IWA Way
Jun 6th 2009 | Brandon Thomaselli & Ian Rotten & Sal Thomaselli | def. | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter & Neil Diamond Cutter | 6-person tag | |
JCW Big Ballas X-Mas Party 2008 (incomplete card)
Dec 20th 2008 | Pauly Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | Bump N' Ugly #1 & Bump N' Ugly #2 | | JCW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
CHIKARA The Artistic Pursuit of Being Yourself
Sep 20th 2008 | Helios & Lince Dorado | def. | Brandon Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
IWA-MS Night of Champions
May 3rd 2008 | Michael Elgin | def. | Brandon Thomaselli | | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2008
Apr 12th 2008 | Cheech & Cloudy | def. (pin) | Brandon Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli, Jason Strife & Troy Walters | three-way tag | |
IWA-MS 500th Show
Mar 1st 2008 | Ash | def. | Brandon Thomaselli, Devon Moore, Dustin Lee, Jason Strife, Mickie Knuckles, Ruckus, Sexxxy Eddy | TLC (8-way) | |
CZW 9 F'n Years
Feb 9th 2008 | Sabian (c) | def. (pin) | Brandon Thomaselli | | CZW Jr. Heavyweight Championship
|
JCW Pontiac Show (December '07)
Dec 21st 2007 | Nosawa & Scott Hall & Violent J | def. | Brandon Thomaselli & Sal Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS A Rotten Farewell
Dec 7th 2007 | Brandon Thomaselli & Sal Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | def. | Dustin Lee & Scotty Vortekz & XOMGX | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS Simply the Best 8
Nov 4th 2007 | Ian Rotten & Sal Thomaselli | def. | Brandon Thomaselli & Vito Thomaselli | | |
IWA-MS 11th Anniversary Show
Oct 13th 2007 | Deranged | def. | Brandon Thomaselli | | |
Pauly Thomaselli