| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Alpha-1 Final Act X
Nov 17th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Brett Michael David, Kody Lane, Trey Miguel (c) | four-way elimination | A1 Zero Gravity Title
(title change) |
 Bar Wrestling 46: Something Wicked This Way Comes
Oct 31st 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Priscilla Kelly | | |
AEW Dynamite #5
Oct 30th 2019 | Chuck Taylor & Orange Cassidy & Trent | def. (pin) | Alex Reynolds & John Silver & Q. T. Marshall | 6-person tag | |
 OTT Fifth Year Anniversary
Oct 26th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | B-Cool | | |
 FCP Infinity 2019
Oct 25th 2019 | Chuck Mambo | def. | Carlos Romo, Chief Deputy Dunne, Clint Margera, Connor Mills, Orange Cassidy | 6-way scramble | |
Beyond Sodom And Gomorrah
Oct 12th 2019 | Warhorse (c) | def. | Orange Cassidy | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
|
GCW No Sleep
Oct 12th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Matt Tremont | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios 2019 - Day 3
Oct 6th 2019 | Lance Steel & Ophidian & Princess Kimberlee | def. | Fire Ant & Green Ant II & Thief Ant | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios 2019 - Day 2
Oct 5th 2019 | Fire Ant & Green Ant II & Thief Ant | def. | Boomer Hatfield & Dasher Hatfield & Molly McCoy | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios 2019 - Day 1
Oct 4th 2019 | Fire Ant & Green Ant II & Thief Ant | def. | Lance Lude & Mike Quackenbush & Rob Killjoy | 6-person tag | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Season 2 Episode 1
Oct 3rd 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Thomas Santell | | |
GCW Curtain Call
Sep 30th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Ethan Page | | |
Prestige Roseland
Sep 29th 2019 | Su Yung | def. (ref) | Orange Cassidy | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '19 - Day 3
Sep 22nd 2019 | Artemis Spencer & Caveman Ugg & Jungle Boy & Orange Cassidy & Paris De Silva | def. | Black Taurus & Kyle Fletcher & Lucky Kid & Mick Moretti & Tony Deppen | 10-person tag | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 16 - Part 1
Sep 21st 2019 | Erick Stevens | def. | Orange Cassidy (c) | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
(title change) |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '19 - Day 2
Sep 20th 2019 | David Starr | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
WrestlePro Return to Rahway
Sep 14th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. (pin) | Bobby Wayward | | |
CHIKARA Chikarasaurus Rex 2019
Sep 7th 2019 | Fire Ant | def. (pin) | Cajun Crawdad | | |
Black Label Pro/GCW 2 Cups Stuffed
Aug 30th 2019 | Gangrel | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
Blitzkrieg! Pro/BTW Four Years Of Blitzkrieg
Aug 24th 2019 | The Boogeyman | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
LVAC Mall Madness
Aug 17th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Dan Champion | | |
F1RST Live at Uptown VFW
Aug 2nd 2019 | Darin Corbin | def. | Orange Cassidy (c) | | F1RST Wrestling Uptown VFW Title
(title change) |
Bar Wrestling 41: And Out Come the Wolves
Aug 1st 2019 | Brian Cage & Scott Steiner | def. | Joey Ryan & Orange Cassidy | | |
Beyond Americanrana 2019
Jul 28th 2019 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. | R.D. Evans | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
|
GCW Beg For Mercy
Jul 26th 2019 | Nick Gage (c) | def. | Orange Cassidy | | GCW World Championship
|
GCW Lights Out
Jul 21st 2019 | Effy | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
LVAC Let's Hang Out! '19
Jul 19th 2019 | Andy Williams & Faye Jackson & Orange Cassidy & Pepper Parks | def. | Allie Kat & Chuck Taylor & Hallowicked & Merlok | 8-person tag | |
EVOLVE #132
Jul 14th 2019 | Arturo Ruas & Austin Theory | def. | Josh Briggs & Orange Cassidy | | |
Bar Wrestling 40: Melissa & Brian's Wedding Reception
Jul 12th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Ray Rosas | | |
Smash (Canada) Orange Is The New Smash! - Day 2
Jul 7th 2019 | Sebastian Suave | def. | Cody Deaner, Orange Cassidy | three-way | |
Smash (Canada) Orange Is The New Smash! - Day 1
Jul 6th 2019 | Psycho Mike | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
F1RST Wrestlepalooza XV
Jun 28th 2019 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. | Darin Corbin, Joey Ryan | three-way | F1RST Wrestling Uptown VFW Title
|
WrestlePro Shotgun Thursday Night
Jun 27th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Mario Bokara | | |
WrestleCircus Big Top Revival
Jun 23rd 2019 | Peter Avalon | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 12
Jun 19th 2019 | Chuck Taylor & Orange Cassidy | def. | BLANK & Still Life With Apricots and Pears | | |
Beyond Secret Show
Jun 9th 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Kimber Lee, Kris Stadtlander (c) | no disqualification triple-threat | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
(title change) |
CHIKARA Summer Night City
Jun 7th 2019 | Fire Ant | def. (pin) | Tony Deppen | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 10
Jun 5th 2019 | Shawn Spears | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
IWTV The Midwest Mixtape
May 26th 2019 | Kris Statlander | def. | Orange Cassidy (c) | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
(title change) |
CHIKARA Aniversario: Scotch Mist
May 26th 2019 | E. M. Demorest & Matt Makowski & Tunku Amir | def. (KO) | Fire Ant & Green Ant II & Thief Ant | 6-person tag | |
SFP Let It Ride
May 26th 2019 | Priscilla Kelly | def. | Marko Stunt, Orange Cassidy | three-way | |
AEW Double Or Nothing
May 25th 2019 | Adam Page | def. | Ace Romero, Billy Gunn, Brandon Cutler, Brian Pillman Jr., Dustin Thomas, Glacier, Isiah Kassidy, Jimmy Havoc, Joey Janela, Jungle Boy, Luchasaurus, Marko Stunt, Marq Quen, Michael Nakazawa, MJF, Orange Cassidy, Shawn Spears, Sonny Kiss, Sunny Daze, Tommy Dreamer | pre-show
Casino Battle Royale | |
WrestleCircus Encore
May 12th 2019 | Gentleman Jervis | def. (pin) | Orange Cassidy | | WrestleCircus Sideshow Championship
(title change) |
CHIKARA The Infinite Gauntlet 2019
May 11th 2019 | Fire Ant & Green Ant II | def. (pin) | Cajun Crawdad & Merlok | | |
PWG Mystery Vortex VI
May 10th 2019 | Chuck Taylor | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 6
May 8th 2019 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. | Jordynne Grace | | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
|
Beyond/WWR Lethal Lottery
May 5th 2019 | Chris Dickinson | def. | Curt Stallion, Jake Parnell, Joey Janela, Joey Ryan, Orange Cassidy, Penelope Ford, Solo Darling | Battle Royal | |
Beyond/WWR Lethal Lottery
May 5th 2019 | Orange Cassidy & Penelope Ford | def. | Shockwave the Robot & Veda Scott | | |
GCW The Last Ones Left
May 4th 2019 | Joey Janela | def. | Orange Cassidy | | |
GCW The Block Is Hot
May 3rd 2019 | Orange Cassidy | def. | Lucky 13 | | |
Orange Cassidy