| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OVW Saturday Night Special (December '12)
Dec 1st 2012 | Eddie Diamond & Nick Dumeyer & Tony Gunn | def. (pin) | Elvis Pridemoore & The Assassin & The Bodyguy | 6-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #692
Nov 22nd 2012 | Eddie Diamond | def. (pin) | Nick Dumeyer | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special (November '12)
Nov 3rd 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore & Stephon J. Baxter III | def. (pin) | David Vaughn & Nick Dumeyer, Raphael Constantine & The Bodyguy | triple-threat tag | |
OVW TV Taping #687
Oct 17th 2012 | Nick Dumeyer | def. (pin) | Joe Rosa | dark
| |
OVW Louisville Show (October '12)
Oct 14th 2012 | Dylan Bostic & Eddie Diamond | def. | Elvis Pridemoore & Nick Dumeyer | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (October '12)
Oct 6th 2012 | Sam Shaw | def. | Arik Kristopher, Dylan Bostic, Eddie Diamond, Elvis Pridemoore, James "Moose" Thomas, Joe Coleman, Michael Hayes, Nick Dumeyer, Raphael Constantine, Ryan Howe, Sean Conway, Stephon Smith, Tony Gunn, VIP | Battle Royal | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (September '12)
Sep 1st 2012 | Crimson | def. | Adam Revolver, Alex Silva, Chris Silvio, Cliff Compton, Dylan Bostic, Eddie Diamond, Elvis Pridemoore, Fabiano Rolento, J. Best, James "Moose" Thomas, Jason Wayne, Jessie Godderz, Joe Coleman, Kody Kastle, Max Wolfgang, Michael Hayes, Nick Dumeyer, Randy Royal, Raphael Constantine, Raul LaMotta, Ricky Chevy, Rob Terry, Rocco Bellagio, Rudy Switchblade, Sean Conway, Shiloh Jonze, Ted McNaler, Tony Gunn, VIP | Nightmare Rumble | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (September '12)
Sep 1st 2012 | Jason Wayne & Rocco Bellagio | def. (pin) | Kody Kastle & Nick Dumeyer | | |
OVW TV Taping #677
Aug 8th 2012 | Jason Wayne & Joe Coleman & Rocco Bellagio | def. (pin) | Arik Kristopher & Elvis Pridemoore & Nick Dumeyer | dark
6-person tag | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (August '12)
Aug 4th 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore & Nick Dumeyer & Ryan Howe | def. (pin) | Eddie Diamond & J. Best & Ricky Chevy | 6-person tag | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (July '12)
Jul 7th 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore | def. | Arik Kristopher, David Osborne, Eddie Diamond, Fabiano Rolento, Jay West, Max Wolfgang, Nick Dumeyer, Raul LaMotta, Sean Conway, Shiloh Jonze | bunkhouse battle royal | |
OVW TV Taping #672
Jul 4th 2012 | Nick Dumeyer & Tony Gunn | def. (pin) | Arik Kristopher & Ricky Chevy | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #667
May 30th 2012 | Nick Dumeyer | def. (pin) | Randy Royal | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special (May '12)
May 12th 2012 | Arik Kristopher & Daniel Pruce & Elvis Pridemoore & Tony Gunn | def. (sub) | Mike Von Wolfgang & Nick Dumeyer & Raphael Constantine & Ricky Chevy | 8-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #661
Apr 18th 2012 | Epiphany & Randy Royal | def. (pin) | C. J. Lane & Nick Dumeyer | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special (April '12)
Apr 7th 2012 | Alex Silva & Brandon Baronis & Brent Baronis & Dylan Bostic & Elvis Pridemoore | def. (pin) | Nick Dumeyer & Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey & The Assassin & Tony Gunn | 10-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #659
Apr 4th 2012 | Alex Silva | def. | Nick Dumeyer | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special (March '12)
Mar 3rd 2012 | Jamin Olivencia | def. | Andrew Patton, Chase King, Jack Black, Joe Coleman, Nick Dumeyer, Randy Royal, The American Assassin, Tony Gunn, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
OVW TV Taping #653
Feb 22nd 2012 | Jack Black & Joe Coleman | def. (pin) | Nick Dumeyer & Rick Cutler | | |
OVW TV Taping #652
Feb 15th 2012 | Dylan Bostic | def. (pin) | Nick Dumeyer | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special (February '12)
Feb 4th 2012 | Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey | def. (pin) | Assassin #2 & Nick Dumeyer | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (February '12)
Feb 4th 2012 | Nick Dumeyer | def. (pin) | Randy Terrez | | |
OVW TV Taping #649
Jan 25th 2012 | Jessie Godderz | def. | Nick Dumeyer | | |
OVW Taylorsville Show (January '12)
Jan 20th 2012 | Chase Evans & Johnny Spade & Sean Conway | def. (pin) | David C. & David Osborne & Nick Dumeyer & Tony Gunn | handicap tag | |
OVW TV Taping #648
Jan 18th 2012 | Anarquia & Rudo | def. (pin) | Assassin #2 & Assassin #3 | dark
| |
Nick Dumeyer