| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CMLL Super Viernes
Dec 25th 2009 | Brazo De Plata & Místico & Volador, Jr. | def. | Atlantis & Rey Bucanero & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Dec 18th 2009 | La Sombra & Místico & Volador, Jr. | def. | El Terrible & El Texano Jr. & Mephisto | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Festival Mundial de Lucha Libre
Dec 11th 2009 | Místico | def. | Blue Panther, Damian El Terrible, El Hijo del Fantasma, El Sagrado, El Texano Jr., Felino, Naito | Steel Cage (8-way elimination) | FMLL Title
(title change) |
CMLL Sin Salida 2009
Dec 4th 2009 | Hector Garza & Jon Strongman & Místico | def. | Atlantis & Mr. Niebla & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Nov 20th 2009 | Jon Strongman & Místico & Shocker | def. | Averno & Felino & Negro Casas | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Nov 13th 2009 | Hector Garza & Jon Strongman & Místico | def. | Atlantis & Negro Casas & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
 NJPW Destruction '09
Nov 8th 2009 | Tiger Mask IV | def. | Místico (c) | | IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
CMLL Super Viernes
Oct 30th 2009 | Angel Azteca Jr. & Astro Boy & Sensei | def. | Durango Kid & Rey Escorpion & Semental | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Oct 23rd 2009 | Jon Strongman & Místico & Shocker | def. | Atlantis & Negro Casas & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Oct 16th 2009 | Jon Strongman & Místico & Shocker | def. | Atlantis & Negro Casas & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Oct 2nd 2009 | Black Warrior & Místico & Ultimo Guerrero | def. | Naito & Okumura & Yujiro | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Lunes Arena Puebla
Sep 28th 2009 | Místico (c) | def. | Jushin Thunder Liger | 2 out of 3 falls | IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title
|
CMLL Guadalajara Domingos
Sep 27th 2009 | Místico & Shocker & Toscano | def. | El Texano Jr. & Jushin Thunder Liger & Yujiro | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Torneo Gran Alternativa 2009
Sep 25th 2009 | Okumura & Yujiro | def. | Angel de Oro & Místico | | |
CMLL Torneo Gran Alternativa 2009
Sep 25th 2009 | Angel de Oro & Místico | def. | Mr. Niebla & Tiger Kid | | |
CMLL Torneo Gran Alternativa 2009
Sep 25th 2009 | Angel de Oro & Místico | def. | Atlantis & Camorra | | |
CMLL Lunes Arena Puebla
Sep 21st 2009 | Jushin Thunder Liger & Okumura & Yujiro | def. | Blue Panther & Hector Garza & Místico | 6-person tag | |
CMLL Domingos De Coliseo
Sep 20th 2009 | Jushin Thunder Liger | def. | Místico | 2 out of 3 falls | |
CMLL 76th Anniversary Show
Sep 18th 2009 | Místico | def. | Negro Casas | mask vs. hair (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Domingos De Coliseo
Sep 13th 2009 | Jushin Thunder Liger & Naito & Yujiro | def. | La Sombra & Místico & Volador, Jr. | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Sep 4th 2009 | Místico | def. | Negro Casas | 2 out of 3 falls | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Aug 28th 2009 | La Sombra & Místico & Volador, Jr. | def. | Atlantis & Felino & Mr. Niebla | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
Toryumon Mexico Dragonmania IV
Aug 22nd 2009 | Místico & Shocker & Tiger Mask IV | def. | Arkangel De La Muerte & Atlantis & Ultimo Guerrero | 6-person tag | |
CMLL Super Viernes
Aug 21st 2009 | Blue Panther & La Sombra & Místico | def. | Felino & Heavy Metal & Negro Casas | 6-person tag (2 out of 3 falls) | |
NJPW G1 Climax '09: New Lords, New Laws - Day 7
Aug 15th 2009 | Místico | def. | Tiger Mask IV (c) | | IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
Místico during 2009