| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Beyond Wrestling Open RI #57
Jul 6th 2026 | Bobby Orlando | def. | Max Caster | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open RI #56
Jun 29th 2026 | Bobby Orlando | def. | Colton Charles, GKM, Max Caster | Gauntlet | |
 Mystery Wrestling #26
Jun 7th 2026 | Psycho Mike | def. | Max Caster | | |
Beyond Break The Walls Down
Jun 5th 2026 | Max Caster | def. | Corey Duke | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open RI #53
Jun 1st 2026 | Bobby Orlando & Eye Black Jack | def. | Max Caster & Vargas | | |
WrestlePro Better Than You
May 31st 2026 | Max Caster | def. | Yoscifer El | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open RI #51
May 11th 2026 | Bobby Orlando | def. (DQ) | Max Caster | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open RI #46
Apr 6th 2026 | Aaron Ortiz & Anthony Vecchio & Brian Myers | def. | Bryce Donovan & Max Caster & Vinny Scalice | 6-person tag | |
WrestlePro X: 10 Year Anniversary Show
Apr 4th 2026 | Anthony Bowens | def. | Max Caster | | |
HOG x The Big Event SuperClash 2026
Mar 21st 2026 | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster | def. | Jay Lyon & Midas Black | | |
Beyond Wrestling Open RI #40
Feb 9th 2026 | Bear Bronson | def. | Max Caster | | |
 AEW Dynamite #324 - Holiday Bash 2025
Dec 17th 2025 | Bandido, Ricochet | def. | Ace Austin, Anthony Bowens, Bishop Kaun, Brody King, Josh Alexander, Luchasaurus, Mark Davis, Max Caster, Shelton Benjamin, Toa Liona | Dynamite Diamond Battle Royal | |
AEW Saturday Tailgate Brawl - Full Gear Preshow
Nov 22nd 2025 | Austin Gunn & Juice Robinson | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster & Big Bill & Bryan Keith & Truth Magnum & Turbo Floyd | $200,000 Four-Way Tag | |
AEW Collision #117 Taping
Oct 29th 2025 | Kazuchika Okada & Konosuke Takeshita | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster | | |
AEW Collision #114 - Homecoming Taping
Oct 8th 2025 | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster | def. (pin) | Big Bill & Bryan Keith | | |
AEW Collision #112
Sep 27th 2025 | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster | def. (pin) | Blake Christian & Lee Johnson | | |
WrestlePro Killer Smokeshow
Sep 21st 2025 | CPA | def. | Max Caster (c) | | WrestlePro Gold Championship
(title change) |
WrestlePro Alwayz Rahway
Sep 12th 2025 | Max Caster (c) | def. | Matt Cardona (c) | | WrestlePro Gold Championship
(title change) |
WrestlePro Alwayz Rahway
Sep 12th 2025 | Max Caster | def. | Alex Reiman, Brandon Downey, Luke Hawx, MSG, Vargas, Yoscifer El | Ladder (7-way) | |
AEW Collision #110 Taping
Sep 11th 2025 | Big Bill | def. | Max Caster | | |
AEW Collision #107 Taping
Aug 20th 2025 | Zack Sabre Jr. | def. (sub) | Max Caster | "open challenge" | |
AEW Collision #105
Aug 9th 2025 | Katsuyori Shibata | def. (pin) | Max Caster | "open challenge" | |
AEW Collision #104
Jul 31st 2025 | Max Caster | draw (time) | Rush | "open challenge" | |
AEW Collision #103
Jul 26th 2025 | Anthony Bowens | def. (pin) | Max Caster | "open challenge" | |
AEW Collision #102 Taping
Jul 17th 2025 | Kyle O'Reilly | def. (sub) | Max Caster | "open challenge" | |
Max Caster