| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 DEFY Heathens
Jun 24th 2023 | Gurv Sihra & Harv Sihra | def. | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | street fight (tag) | DEFY Tag Team Title
(title change) |
Wrestling Revolver And The Ring of Destiny
Jun 17th 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Jon Moxley & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Myron Reed & Rickey Shane Page & Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | 8-person tag | |
DEFY Vertigo
May 13th 2023 | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Judas Icarus & Travis Williams | | DEFY Tag Team Title
|
MLW War Chamber 2023
Apr 6th 2023 | AKIRA & Delirious & Doctor Cornwallis & Rickey Shane Page | def. | 1 Called Manders & Alex Hammerstone & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | War Chamber | |
GCW/DDT GCW Vs. DDT
Mar 31st 2023 | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Chris Brookes & Mizuki Watase & Shunma Katsumata | 6-person tag | |
Circle 6 Clockwork Orange House Of Doom
Mar 31st 2023 | Bobby Beverly | def. | Matthew Justice | Clockwork Orange House of Doom | |
AIW 2-1-SYXX
Mar 24th 2023 | Matt Cardona | def. | Isaiah Broner, Joshua Bishop (c), Matthew Justice | four-way | AIW Absolute Championship
(title change) |
WrestleRex WrestleRex 6
Mar 23rd 2023 | Sam Adonis | def. | Beastman, Jack Pollack, Matthew Justice | four-way | |
Wrestling Revolver DRIP
Mar 4th 2023 | Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | def. | Ace Austin (c) & Chris Bey (c), Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | three-way tag | PWR Tag Team Titles
|
GCW/VXS Jimmy Lloyd's All Grown Up
Feb 17th 2023 | Ciclope | def. | Matthew Justice | Coffin Match | |
DEFY Year 6
Feb 11th 2023 | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Eddie Pearl & Ricky Gibson | | DEFY Tag Team Title
|
MLW SuperFight 2023
Feb 4th 2023 | Real1 | def. | Mance Warner, Matthew Justice, Microman | Four-Way Dumpster Match | |
Wrestling Revolver A Night At The MOXbury
Feb 2nd 2023 | Myron Reed & Trey Miguel & Zachary Wentz | def. | 1 Called Manders & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | no disqualification 6-man tag | |
GCW Don't Talk To Me
Jan 20th 2023 | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | BoJack & Lucky Ali, Caleb Konley & Zane Riley, George South & John Wayne Murdoch | four-way tag | |
GCW Save Me
Jan 7th 2023 | Jimmy Lloyd & Joey Janela | def. | 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice | | |
AIW Jet Black New Year
Dec 30th 2022 | Matthew Justice | def. | Joey Janela | Intense Rules Match | |
GCW One Afternoon Only
Dec 4th 2022 | Allie Katch & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice & Sawyer Wreck | def. | August Matthews & Davey Bang & Logan James & Tyler Matrix | 8-person tag | |
GCW Wasted Time
Dec 3rd 2022 | Ciclope (c) & Miedo Extremo (c) | def. | 2 Cold Scorpio & The Sandman, Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | three-way tag | GCW Tag Team Titles
|
DEFY Fightwave
Nov 26th 2022 | Mance Warner (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | def. | Gurv Sihra & Harv Sihra | | DEFY Tag Team Title
|
AIW Hell On Earth XVII
Nov 25th 2022 | Derek Dillinger (c) | def. | Kaplan, Matthew Justice | three-way | AIW Intense Championship
|
GCW Aura
Nov 20th 2022 | Cole Radrick & Sawyer Wreck & The Dark Sheik | def. | Effy & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | 6-person tag | |
JCW (NJ) Series of Survivals 2022
Nov 19th 2022 | 1 Called Manders & A. J. Gray & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Chris Hamrick & Doug Gilbert & John Wayne Murdoch & Tommy Rich | 8-person tag elimination | |
Black Label Pro Slamilton 2022 - Part 2
Nov 12th 2022 | Isaiah Broner | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
DEFY Kingdom Come
Oct 29th 2022 | Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Miles Deville (c) & Sebastian Wolfe (c) | no disqualification tag | DEFY Tag Team Title
(title change) |
GCW Moment of Clarity
Oct 23rd 2022 | Effy & Mance Warner & Matthew Justice | def. | Aaron Williams & Jeffrey John & Lord Crewe | 6-person tag | |
Matthew Justice