| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 TNA Xplosion #916 Taping
Feb 21st 2025 | Maggie Lee | def. | Kelsey Heather | dark
| |
TNA Impact #1075 Taping
Feb 20th 2025 | Tessa Blanchard | def. (pin) | Kelsey Heather | | |
SHINE #81
Feb 16th 2025 | Kelsey Heather (c) | def. | Sara Leon | | SHINE Nova Title
|
OVW Nightmare Rumble 2025
Jan 4th 2025 | Haley J | def. | Angelica Risk, Arie Alexander, Audrey Allen, Dayami Ho, Elaine Negroni, Freya the Slaya, Holidead, Karter Cauffman, Kelsey Heather, Leela Feist, Lilith Grimm, Madi the American Badi, Miss Larkan, Mother Endless, Myka Madrid, Shawna Reed, Sierra, Sophia Rose, Tatevik | Nightmare Rumble | |
SHINE #80
Sep 29th 2024 | Kelsey Heather (c) | def. | Lexi Gomez | | SHINE Nova Title
|
NWA Exodus Pro Midwest Journey II
Aug 24th 2024 | Tiffany Nieves | def. | Kelsey Heather, Kylie Paige, Maya World | four-way | NWA Exodus Pro Midwest Women's Title
(title change) |
SHINE #79 - The 12th Anniversary Celebration
Jul 12th 2024 | Kelsey Heather | def. | Amber Nova (c) | | SHINE Nova Title
(title change) |
NWA Exodus Pro Midwest For The Fame
May 12th 2024 | Tiffany Nieves (c) | def. | Kelsey Heather | | MPW Championship
|
Dark Arts Gym Dark Prospects - Ritual 1 (airdate)
Feb 18th 2024 | Kelsey Heather | def. (sub) | Alivia Rose | | |
SHINE #77
Jan 28th 2024 | Kelsey Heather | def. | Emily Locke, Kaitland Alexis | triple-threat | |
SHINE #76
Sep 24th 2023 | Alex Gracia & Kelsey Heather | def. | Scotti & Skai | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #109 Taping
Mar 24th 2023 | Julia Hart | def. (sub) | Kelsey Heather | | |
AEW Dark #129 Taping - Part 1
Feb 5th 2022 | Julia Hart | def. (sub) | Kelsey Heather | | |
AEW Dark #136 Taping
Dec 28th 2021 | Diamante | def. (sub) | Kelsey Heather | | |
SHINE #69
Oct 24th 2021 | Kelsey Heather | def. | Tiffany Nieves | | |
SHINE #68
Sep 19th 2021 | Myka Madrid | def. | Kelsey Heather | | |
AEW Dark #101 - Special Friday Edition Taping
Aug 3rd 2021 | Abadon | def. (pin) | Kelsey Heather | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #18 Taping
Jul 7th 2021 | Leyla Hirsch | def. (sub) | Kelsey Heather | | |
ACW/WWN Southern Stampede 2
Nov 16th 2019 | Lexi Gomez | def. | Kelsey Heather, Masha Slamovich | three-way | |
ACW/WWN Hallowreckoning 2019
Oct 19th 2019 | Avery Taylor (c) | def. | Kelsey Heather | | ACW Women's Title
|
WWNLive Do Or Die Showcase
Aug 18th 2019 | Camron Bra'Nae | def. (pin) | Kelsey Heather | | |
Kelsey Heather