| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Dragon Gate The Gate Of Victory 2012 - Day 1
Oct 6th 2012 | Johnny Gargano & Masato Yoshino & Naruki Doi | def. | Dragon Kid & Gamma & Masaaki Mochizuki | 6-person tag | |
 AIW Point Break
Sep 23rd 2012 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Eric Ryan | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 3
Sep 16th 2012 | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Ultramantis Black | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 2
Sep 15th 2012 | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano | def. | Command Bolshoi & Kaori Yoneyama & Tsubasa Kuragaki | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 1
Sep 14th 2012 | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano | def. | Ebessan III & Kikutaro & Takoyakida | 6-person tag | |
EVOLVE #17: Generico vs Del Sol III
Sep 8th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. (CO) | Jon Davis | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
 FCP International Tekkers 2012
Aug 24th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | Open The Freedom Gate Title
|
Dragon Gate USA Enter the Dragon '12: Third Anniversary Celebration
Jul 29th 2012 | Johnny Gargano | def. (sub) | Chuck Taylor | "I Quit" | |
Dragon Gate USA Untouchable '12
Jul 28th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Akira Tozawa | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
AIW Absolution VII
Jul 1st 2012 | Tim Donst | def. | Eric Ryan (c), Johnny Gargano, Shiima Xion | four-way | AIW Absolute Championship
(title change) |
EVOLVE #16: Style Battle Finals
Jun 30th 2012 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Tony Nese | | |
EVOLVE #15: Gargano vs. Taylor
Jun 29th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Chuck Taylor | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
EVOLVE #14: Generico vs. del Sol
Jun 28th 2012 | Tony Nese | def. | Alex Reynolds, Johnny Gargano, Lince Dorado | four-way | |
CHIKARA Smack in the Middle
Jun 24th 2012 | El Generico & Gran Akuma & Scott Parker & Shane Matthews | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano & Ophidian | 8-person tag | |
Beyond/SLA Double Trouble
Jun 16th 2012 | ACH | draw (time) | Johnny Gargano | | |
CHIKARA Chikarasaurus Rex: How to Hatch a Dinosaur
Jun 2nd 2012 | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor (c) & Johnny Gargano (c) | tag (2 out of 3 falls) | CHIKARA Campeonatos de Parejas
(title change) |
AAW Day of Defiance 2012
May 19th 2012 | Arik Cannon | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
AAW Day of Defiance 2012
May 19th 2012 | B.J. Whitmer | def. | Arik Cannon, Bobby Beverly, Dan Lawrence, Danny Daniels, Darin Corbin, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron, Jacob Hallows, Jesse Emerson, Joey Eastman, Johnny Gargano, Jordan McEntyre, Knight Wagner, Louis Lyndon, Marion Fontaine, Mason Beck, Shane Hollister, T. D. Thomas, Tweek Phoenix | Battle Royal | |
EVOLVE #13: Gargano vs. Fox
May 12th 2012 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | A. R. Fox | | Dragon Gate Open The Freedom Gate Championship
|
EVOLVE #12: Callihan vs. Fox
May 11th 2012 | Chuck Taylor & Silas Young | def. | Johnny Gargano & Samuray del Sol | | |
CHIKARA The Contaminated Cowl
Apr 29th 2012 | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Scott Parker (c) & Shane Matthews (c) | tag (2 out of 3 falls) | CHIKARA Campeonatos de Parejas
(title change) |
CHIKARA Hot Off the Griddle
Apr 28th 2012 | Gran Akuma | def. (sub) | Chuck Taylor & Icarus & Johnny Gargano | handicap tag | |
CZW Best Of The Best 11
Apr 14th 2012 | Samuray del Sol | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor, Johnny Gargano | three-way elimination | |
CHIKARA I'll Be a Mummy's Uncle
Apr 14th 2012 | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano | def. | Joel Maximo & Wil Maximo, Jack Bonza & Q. T. Marshall, Harlem Bravado & Lancelot Bravado | fatal 4-way elimination tag | |
 EVOLVE #11: Finlay vs. Callihan
Apr 13th 2012 | Chuck Taylor | def. | Johnny Gargano, Samuray del Sol | triple-threat elimination | |
Johnny Gargano