| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE Cruiserweight Classic Tapings - First Round
Jun 23rd 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Tommaso Ciampa | | |
AAW Killers Among Us 2016
Jun 17th 2016 | Zack Sabre Jr. | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
EVOLVE #63
Jun 11th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. (KO) | Ethan Carter III | "Last Man Standing" | |
EVOLVE #63
Jun 11th 2016 | Anthony Nese | def. (pin) | Drew Gulak, Johnny Gargano, Lince Dorado, TJP | 5-way elimination | |
EVOLVE #62
Jun 10th 2016 | Drew Galloway & Ethan Carter III | def. (pin) | Johnny Gargano & TJP | | |
NXT TV Taping #199
Jun 9th 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | def. | Mojo Rawley & Zack Ryder | | |
 Smash (Canada) Gold 2016
May 29th 2016 | Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Eric Young | | Smash Wrestling Title
|
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2016 - Day 2
May 28th 2016 | Candice LeRae & Johnny Gargano | def. | Gregory Iron & Veda Scott | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2016 - Day 1
May 27th 2016 | Josh Alexander | def. | Johnny Gargano | | |
NXT TV Taping #195
May 19th 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | def. | Nick Miller & Shane Thorne | | |
NXT TV Taping #196
May 19th 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | def. | Dash Wilder & Scott Dawson | | |
EVOLVE #61
May 7th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. (DQ) | Drew Galloway | | |
EVOLVE #60
May 6th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. (sub) | Marty Scurll | | |
NXT TV Taping #194
Apr 28th 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | def. | Danny Burch & Rob Ryzin | | |
DREAMWAVE Anniversary VII
Apr 9th 2016 | Heidi Lovelace & J. T. Dunn | def. | Candice LeRae & Johnny Gargano | | |
AAW Epic: The 12 Year Anniversary Event
Apr 9th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Andrew Everett | | |
AIW Forgot About Dre
Apr 8th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Alex Shelley | Loser Leaves AIW | |
AIW Forgot About Dre
Apr 8th 2016 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Alex Shelley | | |
WWNLive Mercury Rising 2016
Apr 2nd 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Kota Ibushi & T. J. Perkins | def. (pin) | Marty Scurll & Tommy End & Will Ospreay | 6-person tag | |
NXT TV Taping #189
Apr 2nd 2016 | Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa | def. (sub) | Aiden English & Simon Gotch | | |
EVOLVE #59
Apr 2nd 2016 | Drew Gulak & Tracy Williams | def. | Drew Galloway (c) & Johnny Gargano (c) | | EVOLVE Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
EVOLVE #58
Apr 1st 2016 | Drew Galloway (c) & Johnny Gargano (c) | def. | Anthony Nese & Caleb Konley | | EVOLVE Tag Team Titles
|
EVOLVE #57
Mar 20th 2016 | Drew Galloway (c) & Johnny Gargano (c) | def. (pin) | Bill Carr & Dan Barry | | EVOLVE Tag Team Titles
|
EVOLVE #56
Mar 19th 2016 | Zack Sabre Jr. | def. (sub) | Johnny Gargano | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 11
Mar 18th 2016 | Josh Prohibition | def. | Alex Daniels, Alex Kellar, B.J. Whitmer, Big Moe, Brian Carson, Britt Baker, Candice LeRae, Cheech, Cloudy, Colin Delaney, Dick Justice, Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Evan Adams, Frankie Flynn, Garrison King, Gregory Iron, Jerry, Jock Samson, Johnny Gargano, Joshua Singh, Louis Lyndon, Marion Fontaine, Raymond Rowe, Rex Brody, Ryan Kaplan, The Space Monkey, Tim Donst, Tim Donst, Tracy Williams | Battle Royal | |
Johnny Gargano