| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OVW Christmas Chaos 2025
Dec 21st 2025 | Donovan Cecil & Jack Vaughn & Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Drew Hernandez & Tommy Boy Evans & Tony Evans | steel cage (3 on 3) | |
OVW Rise TV #1372 - Thanksgiving Thunder
Nov 22nd 2025 | Drew Hernandez & Tony Evans | def. | Donovan Cecil (c) & Jay DeNiro | | OVW Southern Tag Team Title
(title change) |
OVW Rise TV #1372 - Thanksgiving Thunder
Nov 22nd 2025 | Jay DeNiro | draw (NC) | Tommy Boy Evans | no disqualification | |
OVW Rise TV #1371
Nov 20th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Jake Bravado | | |
OVW Overdrive #160 Taping
Oct 30th 2025 | Drew Hernandez & Tony Evans | def. | Jay DeNiro & T-Dub | | |
OVW Overdrive #157 Taping
Oct 16th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Sam Holloway | | |
OVW No Rest For The Wicked 2025
Sep 28th 2025 | Drew Hernandez & Tony Evans | def. | Jay DeNiro & Tommy Boy DeNiro | hair vs. hair tag | |
OVW Rise TV #1363
Sep 25th 2025 | Jay DeNiro & Tommy Boy DeNiro | def. | Canaan Kristopher & Glenn Spectre | | |
OVW Rise TV #1360
Sep 4th 2025 | Jay DeNiro & Tommy Boy DeNiro | def. | Luke Hartman & Mad Dog Martin | | |
OVW Overdrive #149 Taping
Aug 21st 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Scorpious | | |
OVW Fight Night 2025
Aug 17th 2025 | Jay DeNiro & Tommy Boy DeNiro | def. (pin) | Drew Hernandez & Tony Evans | | |
OVW Overdrive #145 Taping
Jul 24th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Draco Bennett | | |
OVW Rise TV #1353
Jul 17th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Boy Toy Troy | | |
OVW Rise TV #1352
Jul 10th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Tommy Mars | | |
OVW Rise TV #1351 - Independence Rage
Jul 1st 2025 | Erik Surge & Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Drew Hernandez & Tony Evans | | |
OVW Rise TV #1350
Jun 26th 2025 | Brandon Barretta | draw (NC) | Jay DeNiro | | |
OVW Hard Reset 2025
Jun 14th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Kash Daniel | | |
OVW Rise TV #1348
Jun 12th 2025 | Tony Evans | def. | Adam Revolver, Anthony Catena, Anthony Toatele, Ashton Adonis, Brady Booker, Brandon Barretta, Donovan Cecil, Drew Hernandez, Dustin Jackson, Elijah Drago, Jack Vaughn, Jake Painter, Jay DeNiro, Kash Daniel, Luscious Lawrence, Tomas Tiberius Rex, Truth Magnum | Rumble | |
OVW Overdrive #138 Taping
Jun 5th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Tommy Mars | | |
OVW Rise TV #1345
May 22nd 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (DQ) | Tony Evans | | |
OVW Overdrive #134 Taping
May 8th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (DQ) | Colby Carter | | |
OVW Rise TV #1342 - Double Crossed
May 1st 2025 | Anthony Toatele & Jay DeNiro & Kash Daniel | def. | Boy Toy Troy & Star Player Prime & Tony Evans | 6-person tag | |
OVW Appalachian Armageddon
Apr 25th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Anthony Catena | | |
OVW Overdrive #132 Taping
Apr 24th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. (pin) | Jake Painter | | |
OVW Rise TV #1340
Apr 17th 2025 | Jay DeNiro | def. | Jake Painter | | |
OVW matches wrestled by Jay DeNiro