| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OVW Rise TV #1339
Apr 10th 2025 | Anthony Toatele | def. (pin) | Adam Revolver | | |
OVW March Mayhem 2025
Mar 29th 2025 | Anthony Catena | def. | Anthony Toatele, Tony Evans | triple-threat | |
OVW Rise TV #1337
Mar 27th 2025 | Adam Revolver | def. | Anthony Catena, Anthony Toatele, Brandon Barretta | fatal 4-way | |
OVW Rise TV #1336
Mar 20th 2025 | Anthony Toatele & Jake Lawless & Kal Herro & Omar Amir & Star Rider | def. | Anthony Catena & Donovan Cecil & Erik Surge & Icon Lee & Jota Peso | 10-person tag | |
OVW Overdrive #126 Taping
Mar 13th 2025 | Brandon Barretta | def. | Anthony Toatele | | |
OVW Rise TV #1334
Mar 6th 2025 | Jota Peso & Maximo Suave | def. | Anthony Toatele & Brandon Barretta | | |
OVW Rise TV #1333
Feb 27th 2025 | Anthony Toatele | def. (DQ) | Ashton Adonis | | |
OVW Overdrive #123 Taping
Feb 20th 2025 | AJZ | def. (pin) | Anthony Toatele | | |
OVW Rise TV #1330
Feb 6th 2025 | Dustin Jackson | def. | Anthony Toatele | | |
OVW Rise TV #1328
Jan 23rd 2025 | Anthony Toatele | def. (pin) | Ashton Adonis | | |
OVW Rise TV #1327
Jan 16th 2025 | Jake Lawless | def. | Anthony Toatele | | |
OVW Nightmare Rumble 2025
Jan 4th 2025 | Doug Basham | def. | Adam Revolver, AJZ, Amaddeo Sole, Anthony Toatele, Ashton Adonis, Big Zo, Boy Toy Troy, Brandon Barretta, D'mone Solavino, Deget Bundlez, Donovan Cecil, Dustin Jackson, Erik Surge, Icon Lee, Jack Vaughn, Jake Lawless, Jebediah Blackhawk, Jessie Godderz, Joey Avalon, Jota Peso, Kal Herro, Maximo Suave, Mt. Kadeem, Nick Hamrick, Paul Hubris, Ryan Von Rockit, Tony Bizo, TW3, Will Austin | Nightmare Rumble | |
OVW Overdrive #116 Taping
Jan 2nd 2025 | Adam Revolver & Jessie Godderz | def. (pin) | Anthony Toatele & Erik Surge | | |
OVW Rise TV #1321
Dec 5th 2024 | Adam Revolver & Jessie Godderz | def. (pin) | Anthony Toatele & Erik Surge | | |
OVW Overdrive #111 Taping
Nov 26th 2024 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Boy Toy Troy, Brandon Barretta, Bruss Hamilton, Deget Bundlez, Donovan Cecil, Draco Bennett, Erik Surge, Jake Painter, Jota Peso, Justice Davis, Maximo Suave, Prime Jackson, Ryan Tagan, Showtime Shanklin, Super Z | Reverse Battle Royal | |
OVW Overdrive #110 Taping
Nov 21st 2024 | Donovan Cecil | def. | Anthony Toatele | | |
OVW Overdrive #108 Taping
Nov 7th 2024 | Ryan Von Rockit | def. (pin) | Anthony Toatele | | |
Heroes & Legends XX
Aug 26th 2023 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Eric Fallen | | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XIX
May 13th 2023 | Andrew Anderson | def. | Anthony Toatele (c) | | HLW Legends Title
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends XIX
May 13th 2023 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | A. J. Cazana | | HLW Championship
HLW Legends Title
|
Heroes & Legends XVIII
Oct 29th 2022 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Russ Jones | | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XVII
Jul 9th 2022 | Chase Stevens | def. | Anthony Toatele | | HLW Smoky Mountain Title
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends XVI
Apr 23rd 2022 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Sean Morley | | HLW Championship
HLW Legends Title
|
Heroes & Legends XV
Oct 2nd 2021 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Elijah Burke | | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XIV
Apr 24th 2021 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Dru Skillz (c) | | HLW Championship
HLW Legends Title
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends X8 Tournament
Feb 1st 2020 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Russ Jones | | |
Heroes & Legends X8 Tournament
Feb 1st 2020 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
Heroes & Legends X8 Tournament
Feb 1st 2020 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Scotty Young | | |
Heroes & Legends Professional Wrestling The Way It Should Be
Nov 9th 2019 | Anthony Toatele (c) | def. | Kongo Kong | | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XIII
Oct 5th 2019 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Kongo Kong (c), Nick Cutler, Officer Rod Street, Russ Jones | 5-way | HLW Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends XII
Apr 20th 2019 | Nick Cutler | def. | Anthony Toatele, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
Heroes & Legends Fall Tour 2018 - Day 1
Sep 1st 2018 | Sugar Dunkerton (c) | def. | Anthony Toatele | | HLW Cruiserweight Championship
|
Heroes & Legends X
Apr 21st 2018 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Dylan Bostic | | |
Heroes & Legends IX
Nov 11th 2017 | Kongo Kong | def. (pin) | Anthony Toatele, Dru Skillz (c), Hy-Zaya, Lightning Bolt Johnson, Shane Mercer | Steel Cage (6-way elimination) | HLW Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends VII
Oct 22nd 2016 | Alexander S. Kirk & Matt O'Hare | def. | Anthony Toatele & Eli McFly, Bobby Fulton (c) & Tracy Smothers (c) | 3-way Tag Elimination | HLW Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends VI
Mar 26th 2016 | Billy Gunn | def. | Anthony Toatele | | |
Heroes & Legends V
Jul 25th 2015 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Shannon Moore | | |
Heroes & Legends On the Road
Nov 29th 2014 | Andrew S. Kirk & Anthony Toatele | def. | Jake Omen (c) & Scotty Young (c) | | HLW Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends IV
Sep 13th 2014 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Andrew S. Kirk, Eli McFly, Roderick Street | four-way | |
Anthony Toatele